BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Prof X

 
 
quinine92001
18:00 / 30.03.02
Which Prof X do you like? I like Millar or Morrison's version much more than the Prof X of the past. Why to do I "new coke" over classic?
 
 
Trijhaos
18:17 / 30.03.02
I think it'd be easier to make a choice if we knew exactly in which direction Morrison was going. We saw Xavier in 2(?) issues before he got his body snatched by Cassie. That's not exactly long enough to form a really good opinion.

But, going on what I know, I'm going to have to go with Morrison's take on Xavier.
 
 
Tamayyurt
22:22 / 31.03.02
I agree, M&M's Xavier is a lot cooler.

"Why to do I ?like? "new coke" over classic?"

well, he's much more proactive... classic coke always went on about his dream but only went about fighting superhero fights. New Coke is intellegenty going about making his dream a reality by interacting with the outside/real world. Also New Coke messes with people minds every now and again.
 
 
Utopia
10:33 / 01.04.02
new coke also doesn't have a fucking hover-chair.
 
 
Mr Tricks
19:45 / 02.04.02
Does anyone even remember when he had a totally mundane wheel chair & a green plad blanket?
 
 
Trijhaos
19:49 / 02.04.02
I remember reading a couple X-men comics that had him in a real wheelchair with a green blanket over his legs.

I also remember reading this one comic where he could walk, and he wore this nifty golden armour. He used his powers to steal the Blackbird or some other plane, I can't quite remember exactly. I thought that was cool.
 
 
Haus, Heart, Home, Hearth
13:57 / 18.03.04
Mecha X, he can't walk but he can sure fly!
 
 
houdini
14:07 / 18.03.04

Of the many, many fix-and-reset cycles in the great X-soap, the issue of Xavier's legs is one that bugs me a lot.

Originally, Xavier loses his legs when they are crushed in a rockfall by Lucifer.

He regained the ability to walk when the Shi'ar cloned him a new body after realizing that his original body was hosting a Brood Queen egg.

He couldn't walk much for a long time after that because he'd forgotten how over the intervening period.

Eventually he went off to space with the Starjammers (something about his cloned body breaking down...?). When next we saw him, in New Mutants #50, he was wholly capable of walking.

Eventually, Xavier returned to Earth to help the X-Men fight the Shadow King. During the battle Farouk caused him to recall the original loss of his legs, triggering some kind of dubious muscle memory thing that caused his legs to re-break. This was all blatant set-up to get him back in the chair so that everything could be back to the zero point before launching (now recently "New") X-Men #1.

Then Morrison does the whole Cassandra/Nano-Sentinels switcharoo and Charley's walking again. No trouble in adapting this time.

Then along comes Mags and takes it all away again.

Personally, I'd let the man walk and leave it at that. Progress in comics is not necessarily as bad of a thing as we sometimes think.
 
 
Aertho
14:47 / 18.03.04
Well, the potential for Polaris to get in there and fix his spinal nano-sentinels is still an option. Not that they'd ever do that though. Editors say that he LIKES being crippled, just like Rogue LIKES being covered up like Diane Keaton at all times.
 
 
_Boboss
15:16 / 18.03.04
well, he just works better as a symbol if he's a crip doesn't he?

'such a brilliant mind....such a rubbish body' n that
 
 
Haus, Heart, Home, Hearth
21:23 / 18.03.04
I thought he was more of a Blood
 
 
Mike-O
21:43 / 18.03.04
Ha....
 
 
raelianautopsy
23:07 / 18.03.04
I liked it in the 80s when Professor X could walk and I liked it now when he could walk. It's the exact same stupid thing as the early 90s when they made him crippled just so they could do their stupid relaunch; same as the stupid relaunch now.

Its so annoying in comics when the keep evolving charecters and then keep taking back the changes and going back to the tired old ways thats been done for years.

Prof. X just looks so cool with a cane, doesn't he?
 
 
spake
23:42 / 18.03.04
The idea of Prof X walking could be taken somewhere quite cool i think. The issues in Uncanny X-Men (just post X-tinction Agenda), when he was Lilandra's personal warlord (even though he was a superskrull in disguise), were truly awesome. The way Jim Lee drew his lean, yet powerfully muscular physique impressed me. A powerful body housing a powerful mind? what better symbol for the perfect world / [m]utopia that the prof had envisioned.

Bring back his legs i say.
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
13:17 / 19.03.04
The most ridiculous thing I saw was when 'Magneto returned' somewhere areound 1992. The X-Men were about to attack Asteroid M and Xavier was all like "I can't attack Magneto in a wheelchair! That would be shit! I may have the mightiest mutant mind but I'd be a sitting duck! I know, I'll use a special experimental Shi'ar battlesuit thingy that will give me mobility at the cost of vastly reducing my mental powers! Yeah, that'll be a good idea. Then afterwards, neither I nor my X-Men will ever speak of it again..."
 
 
A beautiful tunnel of ghosts
16:11 / 19.03.04
I'd prefer Professor X to have the use of his legs, but it's a character reference point in a way: it's ironic that the most powerful telepath in the world is confined to a wheelchair and that if he had the use of his legs, I think he'd be used more as a character. Because he's in a wheelchair, he tends to get written off as a brain on wheels, which Morrison parallels with Martha, and as a bald gentleman with a cane, the visual tends to make me think of Lex Luthor. I think it's an image thing as well: as a mutant with a non-apparent power, Professor X may be looked on differently by the public because he's in a wheelchair. I also think he's probably wearing fishnet stockings and suspenders beneath that green blanket, a la Everett Scott in The Rocky Horror Picture Show.

Professor X with a cane is a great image, but artistically, the only Professor X for me is the Yul Brynner one in Fantastic Four, where he's literally flown in to stop Madrox. The sequence of him as he leans ever forward in his chair, concentrating to stop Madrox's multiple selves is a powerfully dramatic scene, which I don't think would have been the same had he just been leaning on a cane.

Character-wise, whether or not he's in a wheelchair doesn't matter: he's got the biggest, most powerful support group of anyone in a wheelchair that I know, money is no object to him and he has his own private jet - storywise, it's a useful, if overused plot device. The ongoing 'will he, won't he' over the use of his legs will remain ongoing, and IMO I don't see it as a revision of his character as such: just because he can't walk doesn't diminish his character any.
 
  
Add Your Reply