BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Godless Insanity

 
 
pointless and uncalled for
11:08 / 28.03.02
Worshipping God can keep you sane: study


Tracey Tong
National Post, with files from Southam News

Regular religious worship can relieve the severity of mental health problems and shorten the hospital stays of psychiatric patients, a new study suggests.

"Our results show that religious commitment has a significant impact on depressive symptoms, satisfaction with life, hospital use and alcohol use," says the study, which is being published today in the Canadian Journal of Psychiatry.

It is the first known Canadian psychiatric study to examine religious commitment and spirituality among psychiatric patients.

The four-month study used questionnaires, interviews and reviews of the medical histories of 44 adult male and 44 adult female patients admitted to Canadian psychiatric in-patient units in 1999.

The study found 59% of participants "believed in a God who rewards and punishes"; 27% said they attended worship frequently and 35% said they "prayed once or more daily."

Patients who worshipped more frequently, attending religious meetings once or more weekly, appeared to benefit the most. These patients were less depressed, had shorter hospital stays, lower rates of alcohol abuse and longer life expectancy than those who worshipped less frequently or not at all.

"Traditionally, psychiatrists thought that spirituality wasn't important with in-patients, but the study has showed us that their level of spirituality is the same as that of the rest of the population," said Dr. Marilyn Baetz, an assistant professor at the University of Saskatchewan, in Saskatoon, who conducted the study.

She said the findings suggest regular worship can help to regulate behaviour and provide social resources for coping with stress and "a sense of coherence and meaning to life."

Another important finding was that patients who worshipped believed they were getting better, even though their problems remained.

Dr. Baetz concludes that a patient's belief system must be addressed by a mental-health professional, and that, in some situations, clergy should be involved.

"What psychiatrists can take away from this study is that, for some people, religion and beliefs could be an important part of an overall treatment," said Dr. Baetz, who is currently at work on a study of the mental-health benefits of religion to the general population. "Patient treatment needs a closer link with a clergy and a safe group, if it's important to the patient."

"I'd have to say, from experience of being a pastor for 25 years, the findings are right on the mark," Major Cliff Hollman, spokesman for the Salvation Army, said yesterday.

Maj. Hollman said he has witnessed how religious commitment helps people in coming to grips with problems.

"There's a support mechanism that comes through spiritually, but also through the attendance at a church where there is a network that is able to bring people into a fold, or surround them with support," he said.

from The National Post.
 
 
deja_vroom
13:46 / 28.03.02
Heh. Funny, it contradicts everything that faith is supposed to represent - the firm belief in things you cannot prove; standing by stuff that is clearly either drug induced delirium or proof of insanity: Strolling over the surface of water, making water into wine, coming back from the death etc.

Also interesting in light of the attitude one can feel in the Bible, that dismisses and belittles common human and/or scientific experience as "folly". There's even a psalm that goes (I´m paraphrasing it) something like: "What it reason to man is madness to God; what is reason to God is madness to men".

Funny.
 
 
pointless and uncalled for
13:54 / 28.03.02
Leaves me wondering if there will be some psychiatrists prescribing neurosuppressants and a daily dose of God.

The phrase "religion is the opium of the masses" also comes to mind.
 
 
w1rebaby
14:25 / 28.03.02
and, yet again, a journalist fails to understand the concept of causal connection
 
 
Lurid Archive
00:16 / 29.03.02
I think the journo has it about right here. Its the worship that keeps you sane, the belief doesn't count for shit.

Funnily enough, I read about a similar positive effect for Trekkies. I might be misremembering, but I think the idea was that sense of community and especially attending sci-fi conferences really does help peoples mental health. Even if it is based round a ridged forehead, nauseatingly prim and techno babble dominated activity like Star Trek.
 
 
wembley can change in 28 days
00:40 / 29.03.02
I think that's bloody fascinating. I guess in some small way I have to blame Ryan, my best friend at age seven, for my current mental state. I grew up Presbyterian; he's Jewish, and even at such a tender age, the equation in my head went: My Story not equals His Story, but we like Ryan and don't want him (or self) to go to Hell; therefore both stories are mistaken.

Fortunately, I'm an evangelist in the Church of Theatre, whose stories are not limited to one book and whose congregation like to hug other members. So I'll be fine. Really.
 
 
Persephone
00:45 / 29.03.02
Fortunately, I'm an evangelist in the Church of Theatre, whose stories are not limited to one book and whose congregation like to hug other members. So I'll be fine. Really.

grins

If it doesn't drive you mad...

You know... that *is* true about the hugging, isn't it?
 
 
Ganesh
09:11 / 29.03.02
Pretty much any regular social activity is, generally speaking, more conducive to 'sanity' than being completely socially isolated - as Lurid Archive says, the actual focus is secondary. In fact, it could be argued that organised religion is the socially-acceptable face of psychosis...
 
 
rizla mission
20:12 / 29.03.02
"the socially-acceptable face of psychosis..." I like it.
 
  
Add Your Reply