BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


ACME nominated for a real award!

 
 
sleazenation
14:22 / 22.11.01
Two cheers for the UK newspaper the Guardian for nominating the Jimmy Corrigan collection for its Guardian Fist book award.

3 boos for Calling its author Chris Hare instead of Chris Ware and for making its sample pages too small to actually be read. And for claiming its the first graphic novel to be considered for a major prize when Watchmen was nominated for a HUGO and Sandman 19 won the world fantasy award.


check it out here

[ 22-11-2001: Message edited by: sleazenation ]
 
 
adamswish
14:28 / 22.11.01
quote:Originally posted by sleazenation:
and Sandman 19 won the world fantasy award.


Didn't they change the rules for that award after Sandman won. Seem to remember something about the old school judges slightly miffed that a "comic" had beaten the more ernest work?
 
 
sleazenation
14:41 / 22.11.01
Indeed they have. Now comics are only eligable for a special comics award.
 
 
yawn - thing's buddy
11:31 / 23.11.01
and a shite 'n onion roll for the sub-editor in the Saturday mag last weekend who described the book as being about Jimmy and his 'awful dad'.

Read the fucking thing you cunts.

The 'idea' of comics are now mainstream, actually have been for ages, but this will not save the industry. It will simply result in mass appropriation by other media which have been starved of creativite thinkers since, oh, lets see, 1988?

Comics as a medium is dying. It's like bloody poetry as The Gay Man pointed out in a recent interview. Sure, poetry sutvives to this day, but you don't get punters queuein' up to bust up some rhymes much these days.

Anyway, the current buzz for illustration is on it's last legs too. Expect luxurious airbrush art and bars clad in black leather and platinum to dominate in the next few years.

Jimmy Corrigan is the last gasp by this sorry industry to get noticed. A fuckin throwback of a story, with art gallery art and *******. (Ohh, I don't like the modern world, it's so cheap - fuck you Ware it hurts asshole)

So fuck you too Guardian, don't dare give us fanboys this prize (yeah, us - this award goes to me an' you if it wins - think about it)- because you will make life difficult for everyone.

"look, comics ARE good. ARE relevant For example check this chunky volume out - it looks like a book and won a Guardian literary prize!'

Puh-lease.

I will never 'defend' comics again.

I don't know why I ever did. What is the reason for this compulsion? Just read stuff you like and stop looking for acceptance.

Cunts.

And by the way: 'Don't quote me.'

Final word: xmen will never sell in the numbers it used to. Never.

And yes, I do feel like a cock reading x-factor on the train. In fact I have to do a photocopy reduction and stick it inside a Joseph Campbell tome just to feel safe.

Reading the collected trade publicly is even worse. Looks like a bloody fun pack colouring in piece of shite or something.

I hate comics. I hate the guardian. I hate you. (apart from 2 others on this board, you're all wankers)



oh yeah, here:

 
 
bio k9
09:17 / 25.11.01
whatever.
 
 
Ronald Thomas Clontle
09:26 / 25.11.01
I think the industry is dying, but the medium is growing. Ware is a step in the right direction.
 
 
bio k9
09:32 / 25.11.01
What the hell are you doing at home? Its 8:00 on a Saturday night for gods sake? And youre here talking about comics?
 
 
Ronald Thomas Clontle
09:32 / 25.11.01
I'm at my parents house up in Westchester. I'm not feeling well, and all of my friends are out of town. Not a lot of partying to do this weekend, man. I did see The Fall last night, that rocked....
 
  
Add Your Reply