BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


the Brotherhood

 
 
Elijah, Freelance Rabbi
18:33 / 10.09.01
so, anyone read this? i got the first few and am kinda digging it, decent story, good "anti X Men" feel to the way the recruit the main char, and a guy with an aussie accent, cool!

anyone else reading it, love it, hate it ?

ENG
 
 
sleazenation
18:56 / 10.09.01
I bought the first issue.

Words almost failed to describe just how bad thius is. The 2 dimensional characterisation tand willful mishandeling of an otherwise interesting idea.

this is without doubt the worst of the current crop of x-titles
 
 
Mercury
22:12 / 10.09.01
Personally I didn't think it was that bad. Gice it a go, a couple more issues. The Brotherhood could explore an idea: what if the reader really didn't agree with the mutants? What if the usual "oh let's give the muties some basic rights" was to be shattered by the same things happening theses days in European countries with Arab immigrants? What it the muties raised their fingers to "tolerance"?

I haven't read x-titles for years and years and so I don't know if this was explored already but at least it seems viable.

- Mercury
 
 
Lurker in the corner
00:39 / 11.09.01
I read it and its ok, but the art is crap! I could draw better drunk.
 
 
Mr Wolfe
03:08 / 11.09.01
I said this already- read it 1ce, hated it, read 1-3 + came away really impressed- now 4 is out + I'm undecided. I'm halfway convinced its GM or someone as clever- tho the dialogue is admittedly not as punchy as it could be.

still, consider these styles:

1) mysterious leader + mysterious writer are both 'x'- issue # 2 is nicely titled 'who is X?'

2) nice grasp of how shitty adolescence is- which is what being a marvel mutant was always referring to anyway. whether a young mutant or a tortured teenage virgin-- a realistic + tough friend, a night club for your kind, a spliff, + a dope girl are high on the 'most wanted list'.

3) nice new touch for marvel, that- casual + rather amoral drug use.

4) everybody loves anarchist terrorists. rabid, at that.

5) colombine- + they're misguided +, ultimately, prejudiced, just like in real life. I think that's sort of the point of the first 3 issues- that he could have gone colombine (the shoot-em-up video game in issue 2) but instead his life gets more complex.

I heard mackie but I don't buy it- I looked thru some issues of mutant X + they're shite- at a wild guess I'd say Pete Milligan- based on the blood power, same as 'the anarchist' in X-force.
 
 
CameronStewart
11:24 / 11.09.01
It's more or less been officially acknowledged that "X" is Howard Mackie.
 
 
klint
03:14 / 12.09.01
quote: It's more or less been officially acknowledged that "X" is Howard Mackie.

I know you work at Marvel, but what is your source?
 
 
Lurker in the corner
03:22 / 13.09.01
CameronStewart may be making a joke.

[ 13-09-2001: Message edited by: Cobweb ]
 
 
deletia
06:24 / 13.09.01
Presumably if it was somebody whose name was going to sell more copies of the book, it would be on the front cover, which is why Mackie seems a good bet in some ways. I mean, I'm no expert, but I'm guessing that not many people go "ooo, a new one by Howard Mackie!"
 
 
Monkey Boy Z
03:48 / 14.09.01
I'm hoping it's more literal than that, a fictional character a la King Mob or Captian Kirk pulling themselves off the page and into reality (of course, I'd have to go into my whole Shatner-is-really-kirk-stuck-in-the-past theory that people are afraid to think about). There seems to be a lot of writers these days who wish they were Morrison though, like Young's Monarchy. But I wonder how long a book promoting terrorists will last in these umm, interesting times.

All in all though, I've been reading it despite myself, the brotherhood is not only an okay read, it's a neat direction for comics to take. The more mainstream books that don't feature super heroes there are, well, the more people like Warren Ellis will be happy, and heck, I like Warren Ellis.

mbz
disable smilies in this post.
 
 
moriarty
04:02 / 14.09.01
quote:Originally posted by Monkey Boy Z:
(of course, I'd have to go into my whole Shatner-is-really-kirk-stuck-in-the-past theory that people are afraid to think about).


You aren't alone. And you never will be.
 
 
Monkey Boy Z
05:08 / 16.09.01
Well, it would explain all the lengths he went to to keep the character alive, even past the generations movie, with the novel the "shatner" shell wrote... and really, all his acting is just kirk doing this, kirk doing that.

No, wait, I mean. Ha ha ha. I'm not serious!
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
11:28 / 21.09.01
Brotherhood cancelled.
 
 
The Packard Goose
11:53 / 21.09.01
That's too bad. I think this series had a great deal of potential. But, better to cancel something in disarray than to put some hard work into making it better, right?
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
15:46 / 26.09.01
Nah, X was Howard Mackie. They made a lot of jokes about it on the X-Men panel at San Diego that you would have only gotten if you knoew that.

And Rich Johnson "All The Rage" has been spreading it about.
 
  
Add Your Reply