BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Brotherhood: Revolution of the Imagination?

 
 
The Packard Goose
22:12 / 18.07.01
Okay, I just picked up the second issue, and while I didn't get the same punch from it that I did from #1, I still like what I'm seeing here.
What I really dig most is the "Revolution Not Evolution" idea. We have not seen any proof that Asher is a mutant. All we have is Hoffman's claim to that effect, and Hoffman is pursuing an agenda the details of which we the readers have not been fully clued into yet.
I'm thinking, and this is pure speculation, mind you, that this title is going to re-examine what being a mutant in the Marvel Universe is all about. Is it a matter of having an "X-gene," whatever the hell that is? Or is it a matter of realizing that you are a freak, that you are unique, that there may be billions of normal people on the planet but you are not one of them?
Haven't we all felt, especially in the magical years or puberty, that we could explode?
Hoffman, Orwell, Fagin, et al really remind me of King Mob, Elfayed, Mad Tom, and the whole Invisibles gang. I'm not saying (yet) that Grant Morrison is X, but the recruitment of Asher seems to be a Marvelization of Dane's recruitment in The Invisibles. Convince an intelligent kid who's unhappy with the status quo that he's part of a very special group, a group about which the kid has heard many strange, wondrous, and even horrible things, and who knows? You may be able to mold a messiah, a revolutionary, or even a superhero.
What do y'all think? Is it possible to make a mutant using nothing but imagination and a well-told story?
 
 
Ellis
22:27 / 18.07.01
Everyone seems to think Howard Mackie is X.

Crappy publicity stunt.

If they had a good writer they should have just admitted it. The only reason to not admit it is if the writers name would stop people from buying it.

That said it will probably turn out to be Alan Moore or Grant.

[But why would Grant WANT to Marvelise the Invisibles? Hasn't that story already been told?]

I didnt like the book, I read the first issue and it seemed whiney... Angst ridden kid discovers he may be special... etc.

I havent seen the second issue yet... maybe it sold out?

I think if it turns out he isnt a mutant it could be cool, and the book certainly has a lot of potential, but i doubt its going to achieve it.

I'll definately look at the trade when its released though.

Incidentally: I think you are born a mutant and the powers come through in puberty. Unless u are born deformed or something.
 
 
Templar
00:29 / 19.07.01
I thought this was what the X-men was about all the time? (The kind of idea put into Stan Lee's mouth in Mallrats). I thought the first issue sucked - a pretty basic rewrite of the underlying tensions of the whole thing, but making them kind of obvious. Hopefully the second one will pick it up a bit.
 
 
Lothar Tuppan
14:36 / 19.07.01
I really disliked the first issue and I passed the 2nd one by. The first issue just seemed forced and trite to me.
 
 
Mr Tricks
20:13 / 19.07.01
Ditto...

let us know if it picks up.
 
 
Ellis
20:15 / 19.07.01
I looked at Issue 2 today... Oh the dialogue!

The scene in the toilets where our jumping on character is almost attacked by some punks is especially bad...
 
  
Add Your Reply