BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Angels and Demons

 
 
yichihyon
01:19 / 16.05.09
Any body see the movie or read the book? What do you think? Personally I liked this movie version better than the Da Vinci Code.
 
 
Colonel Kadmon
22:38 / 17.05.09
I thought it a far, far better movie than The Da Vinci Code. I know it's getting terrible reviews, but I don't think they're generated by the movie alone. It's really not that bad. Sure, it's not a work of art in any respect, but as a popcorn thriller, it works pretty well. The thing is that Angels and Demons is a better read than Da Vinci Code in the first place, not least because it has a good, climactic ending, not the damp squib fizzle-out of its more successful sequel.

The film of DVC really accentuated its weak points - the ending, caricatures instead of characters and endless inaccurate exposition. A&D, on the other hand, plays to the strengths of the novel - the relentless pace and sheer chutzpah. The performances are better, the direction less laboured and lumpenly didactic, and it had a proper climax.

It's still ridiculous, though no more so than the cellphone-imaging bits of The Dark Knight, and I doubt it'll stand up to repeated viewings. I can't think of a better Vatican-based thriller, however.

What's the bets that Howard already owns the rights to the new one, The Lost Symbol?
 
 
wicker woman
03:30 / 20.05.09
I mostly gave up on Dan Brown after reading Digital Fortress, reading it gave me the impression of a crime reenactment on television as compared to The DaVinci Code; i.e., "only the names have been changed..."

I had thought about giving this movie a go in spite of that, but then I heard one hell of a scene-chewing reading from Ewan McGregor's character today on NPR, and now I'm considerably less sure.
 
  
Add Your Reply