BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Generation Kill

 
 
Bandini
08:27 / 30.09.08


Had a look but couldn't see a thread for this.

It has finished now in America and will hopefully soon come to the UK.

It is a seven part miniseries that tells the story of an embedded reporter with a group of reconnaissance marines during the first phase of the Iraq War.

Adapted by David Simon and Ed Burns (previously wrote for The Wire) so as you would expect the characterisation is superb and after 8 hours spent with Bravo Company you feel as if you know them very well.

The writing brilliantly encapsulates the personal, the social and the political story. The influence of David Simon's past as a journalist seems to constantly have an effect on the work he is involved in. His work more and more reminds me of Sam Fuller; anyone else see that?

Did anyone watch this, what did you think?
 
 
Tuna Ghost: Pratt knot hero
20:22 / 30.09.08
I've seen it. When you say The writing brilliantly encapsulates the personal, the social and the political story. I want to say the same for the series, except for the political part. There's not much dialog on it--the series takes place over basically one week, so there wasn't much time-- but eventually it starts dawning on the soldiers that the war is sort of fucked up when they start discovering non-iraqis fighting them, but beyond that not so much.

My roommate, who served in the Marines for a little while before getting booted for never doing what someone told him to do, said that it was a pretty accurate picture of life in the Marines. Most notable of his comments, to me, concerns what he viewed as one of if not the worst part of being in the Marines: you're trapped with a bunch of guys and most of them are stupid or violent or both (my roommate, by the way, is one or more of those things at all times and he still couldn't stand life in the Corps).

It looks nice, at least. What little violence found in the series is graphic and occasionally shocking, and the aftermath of war shown in all its gory details. But there's humor too, and I would recommend it I think.
 
 
Bandini
10:23 / 01.10.08
I think the political came out in the subtleties. You got the impression that a lot of the things you were seeing were a result of political decisions trickling down. It certainly wasn't as explicit within the series though.
 
 
Peach Pie
12:49 / 12.11.09

I liked the nuances too...perhaps I started watching assuming there wouldn't be any in the dialogue. There's a real feel of "All Human Life is Here": very smart soldiers intent on making life better for Iraqis who wind up progressively more frustrated, a depressing 19 yr old who enjoys killing because it's just like playing GTA, soldiers who get too scared to perform, soldiers who are incompetent but somehow wind up taking the glory for successful missions, and Ray Person.

I don't like war but I love this series.
 
  
Add Your Reply