BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Shock Doctrine

 
 
Eek! A Freek!
17:53 / 28.08.08
Naomi Klein received way more than her 15 minutes by penning No Logo, the classic which kicked the anti-corporate movement into high gear. Most people who choked on tear gas while protesting the IMF or WTO did so clutching a copy of her book.

Last year she followed up with "The Shock Doctrine".

In this new tome the intrepid Montrealer plays connect-the-dots to show a thread running through Milton Friedman's Chicago School economics, Project MKUltra, and the Free Market makeovers of such countries as Chile, Indonesia, Poland, China, South Africa, Russia, and others.

The picture she paints is a depressing one where people are robbed, tortured, and even slaughtered to grant even more riches to a handful of people who form a global financial elite.

The premise is that a series of shocks - whether physical, political or economic - can be used to soften up the masses to such a point to where they no longer are even able to protest their mistreatment, even in the staunchest democracies, let alone stand against the Imperial tide.

It speaks of a return to a feudal society under the banner of "Democracy".

I am only half way through the book which has thus far been a case by case look at how Chicago School "Shock Treatment" has transformed countries which were leaning towards nationalism for the betterment of their people. It's been one of those, "Read a chapter, get blood boiling, fume for a few days, repeat..." reads.

Anybody else reading or have read it? Thoughts?
 
 
Mark Parsons
18:51 / 28.08.08
I bought it on impulse (is there any other kind of purchase? Not for me, alas) but it has gone on my pile(s) of "Things to be Read at Some Point, Given Infinite Leisure Time."

She also published a short work, a sort of top ten elements of corporate/fascism, with US as the modern example of creeping fascism. I checked that out from the library TWICE and have not gotten around to reading it (yet).
 
 
Archtypically Foolish
22:55 / 25.09.08
I have not read No Logo but I had to read The Shock Doctrine for a class a few weeks ago. It was the first thing we read, what a way to jump start a class let me tell you...

Soon: freektemple again is right, it's the kind of book you have to be constantly putting down b/c the situation is so enraging. It's also pretty damn frustrating it brings with it not only that sense of creeping corporate facist imperialism, but also a vauge sense of conspiracy paranoia and powerlessness. I think that's why it's so enraging.

Other than that I think it is well written and engaging, one of my favorite parts is when she is talking about the Tiananmen Square protests & Massacre. I was always lead to to believe that it was a question of a totalitarian communist nation oppressing a group of radically democratic students. To find out that the situation was actually something closer to the opposite, that communist China was attempting to pass free-market capitalist policies was well - kind of like the day I found out what Columbus did when he got to the 'New World.
 
 
Benny the Ball
15:40 / 28.09.08
I find reading Klein's stuff hard going, often they are interesting but I drown in the verbosity, and feel that points can be laboured.

I've yet to finish this book, and have liked what I've read, i just feel that I've read all I need to and I'm only about half way through.
 
 
Eek! A Freek!
12:28 / 29.09.08
I finally did finish the book last week.
Benny: I felt the same way half way through, but you learn more and more, especially when you read about the tsunami and Katrina.
The book leaves you with hope, however, and you certainly look at the current economic crisis through a new lens.
I'm starting to believe that even the staunchest Freidmanites are starting to question the Free-Market Gospel.
 
 
HCE
13:15 / 14.10.08
I haven't hit the hope bit, yet. Where is that?
 
 
Eek! A Freek!
17:52 / 14.10.08
The last chapter talks about a growing backlash against Chicago School free market idealism: the rise of South American socialism, becoming immune or at least resistant to shock, etc...

Looking to the States in the Present: there's talk (And some panic) about nationalizing banks. Goes against Chicago School doctrine, but some economists are waking up to the fact that a mixed economy with strong Keynesian safety nets may provide some relief to the current crisis.

Part of me thinks that the current crisis is yet another shock which will be used to push through yet more free market reform, but even more I'm starting to think that America is slowly warming up to the Idea that some aspects of socialism may not be such a bad thing after all...
 
  
Add Your Reply