BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Commonality of experience?

 
 
illmatic
12:52 / 30.06.08
So, the poster formly known as Freektemple posted this in a thread asking for advice and so forth:

I want ...to be told what to do and expect

Now, my pat answer to that sort of query for years has been that everyone is different, we all have different past experience/physiologies/"degrees of readiness" and so forth, so one cannot be told what to expect. Everyone's experience is different and unique and part of the learning curve is interpreting *whatever happens* (if indeed anything in a way that's useful to you. While I'd still agree with the second part of that statement, I don't know to what degree I'd go along with the first. .

I suppose what I'm asking is, is there a commonality of experience between practices that transcends individual practiconers? Depends on the practice, I suppose. I think everyone who's not done it before - and many who have - would get something out of basic meditation, but as I was writing that I recalled a guy in whom a very simple meditation practice has triggered some psychotic episodes. Maybe we are all different, after all.

Hmm. Don't know. Bit of an out loud muse this. What do people think? is there a commonality between experience that is striking? Or not?

BTW Freektemple, even I did know fer sure what you would have happen, I still don't think I'd tell you - why should I spoil your fun
 
 
the Kite
13:19 / 30.06.08
Frankly Rex I think you had it right all along. Yes we do all differ in significant ways that impact how we get new info, how we grow and learn, how we change our lives. Pat answers, like cliches, earn their place by proving themselves boringly, repetitively true.

That said ...

Yes, also, we all have a lot in common, from our common DNA to our approximate locations/directions in space and history (more pat truisms) but I don't believe that a list of common factors would produce an 'essence' of what we are about. Perhaps we could think of our commonality much as we might think of what it means to belong to the same family. Some but not all have the same hair colouring or the same nose or the same build, except for those who married in and brought their own hair/nose/build to the mix ...
 
 
Ticker
13:29 / 30.06.08
The historic and present Mystery Schools seemed/seem to be able to manipulate personal gnostic experience with fairly good percentages. That said, the modern ones I know of all have a generous amount of room for custom tailoring for individual students. The degree of customization maybe more necessary now with the large variance in culture?

There's also the aspect of in depth preparation and induction into a magical culture that sets up the commonalities. The schools' process may also serve to filter out those who do not have/share the same required internal widgets.
 
 
EmberLeo
21:00 / 30.06.08
That, and I think we're more philosophically Individualistic these days than perhaps they were back then. The idea that it's okay to need personalization, that one should receive personalization, rather than that one should go be learning how things are for the group, and exhibiting the discipline and maturity necessary to fulfill their social roles.

There are strengths and weaknesses in either perspective.

--Ember--
 
 
Foretold Soldier
17:35 / 29.07.08
In my opinion, all doors lead to the same hallway when traveled far enough.

Regardless of the images our brains use to convert astral information, I feel that underneath it all there is the same ultimate truth. I guess we'll know when we get there eh?
 
  
Add Your Reply