BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Angel: After the Fall

 
 
Feverfew
18:28 / 31.01.08


Bless Buffy Season Eight, because it's success led to this. But at the same time, there's slight cursing, because the end of Angel Season 5 was just, that, good.

I can confess that I'm a Whedonite. God, take a look at my rambling within the Serenity thread to see it. But I was always more of an Angel fan than a Buffy, or, later, Firefly, fan, for one simple, yet shallow, reason. With Buffy and Firefly, I came in after the event had started, and had to spend time looking for my seat in the darkness, whereas with Angel, I was prepared, and came in on the ground floor. (The UK ground floor, I grant you, heavily cut by Channel 4 and bounced around the shedules, but still, I Was There At The Start sort of thing. I told you it was shallow.)

So, with Angel, I followed the show from inception to destruction. Everyone has their quirks, I guess.

And when it finished, even if it was before it's time or just at the right time, it was still... I don't know, cut off, as if there was a lot more story behind what was going on. Which, obviously, there was, but the conclusion was still good enough to tie off the stump.

What I'm eventually getting at is that, having read #1-3 of After the Fall, I'm left with the most mixed of mixed feelings. After all, it's a joy to see the characters back - and in Official Canon, apparently - but a the same time, the story's always going to be a difficult sell.

Not that it's a bad story. As punishment for Angel's daring to inconvenience the Senior Partners, they have sent the whole of LA to hell, and cut it off from the rest of the world, trapping those in, in, and those out, out. Not that the Out matters yet, of course. Angel is trying to help the humans stuck inside, but Demon Lords have risen and carved the city up into their own personal fiefdoms, and Team Angel are now an extremely motley crew, not to mention the re-appearance of Gwen, Nina, and Connor.

I don't want to spoil how the other regulars are involved - and I can't remember how to do those flashy spoiler tags, so, hey - but they're all there, in their own different ways - and some much more different than others.

The art, however, veers from impressive to oddly annoying; IGN pretty much has it when they "believed Urru is talented when he "lets loose" creating demons, but less impressive when it comes to matching characters to their respective actors."

So, is anyone else out there following this? Or am I a lone voice in the darkness?
 
 
FinderWolf
00:16 / 01.02.08
I flipped through the first issue and speed-read most of it; I found the art so poor overall that that feature alone was enough to dissuade me from buying it. I haven't looked through the other two - the overall production quality doesn't seem to be nearly as high as the Buffy: Season 8 series...
 
 
hachiman
06:22 / 04.02.08
Yeah, the art is problematic. granted i cant draw stick figures, but the series is suffering because of the art.
It's a pity too, the writing is fun, and the story has been progressing nicely.

Plus Angel is riding a Dragon, how cool is that?
 
 
Eskay Uno
18:32 / 04.02.08
I agree that the art is far from spectacular. It's definitely serviceable though, isn't it? I'm really enjoying the book so far: The character voices are spot on, and I love where each one is now in their lives (or after-lives). The twists and turns keep coming, there's some great action and interaction - if you were a fan of the show I highly recommend this book.
 
 
Feverfew
17:44 / 18.04.08
Up to issue six, now, and fundamentally nothing has actually happened - I get the idea of establishing your storyline, but when you ostensibly only have a twelve-issue maxi-series to work with, spending five issues setting up a Big Fight (tm) then cutting straight to a three-issue arc setting up the setting up seems a little strange, if only possibly to me.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
23:44 / 19.04.08
It's becoming quite the trend, I've noticed -- a lot of miniseries spend a great deal of time on set-up and then the resolution is about a page long when it's all said and told. Happened with Umbrella Academy. Hell, it's one of the things I appreciate about Mike Mignola, his ability to pace miniseries correctly.
 
 
Neville Barker
00:27 / 24.04.08
I too feel that the art trips up the story, and it takes alot for me to even really pay attention to art. I hate to pick on the Urru, you know, I hate to hurt anyone's feelings...

But I like the book alot. I too prefer the Angel tv show to the Buffy, not that Buffy is bad or either is inherently better than the other. At first I never got into either - my wife started absorbing them voraciously about two or three years ago, largely when I was at work. I'd catch an episode here or there of Buffy, generally liked what I saw, but usually sat next to her on the couch and read through them. Same with Angel at first, but then suddenly something caught my eye somewhere in the 2nd or 3rd season and made me really interested. I began to see the influence Chris Claremont's uncanny x-men had had on Mr. Whedon. When baby Connor was abducted by what's his name I knew he would shortly show up again grown because, well, because of cable. Joss was every bit as inspired by the same stuff I was, and therein lied the key for me to unlock Angel.

To me Angel was brilliant - an even better and certainly more concise attempt at creating a team of superheroes without creating a team of superheroes than Buffy.

So far to me the comic has continued the story almost perfectly. Granted, it is different - a little more grandiose. But that's surely because Mr. Whedon no longer has to worry about how to actually 'do' grandiose things for a camera. Just have them draw it, right? I think that's where Urru was the choice, I just don't think its translating very well visually. But the story's there. Or at least on the right path.
 
  
Add Your Reply