BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Code Geass: Lelouch of the Rebellion

 
 
Mysterious Transfer Student
22:00 / 28.10.07


This is a show I started watching with little knowledge and no real expectations, having been vaguely attracted by some of the talent involved - director Goro Taniguchi and scenarist Ichiro Okouchi worked on some excellent earlier shows, including RahXephon, Planetes and Eureka Seven. On paper it appeared a standard second-division TV anime, stuffed with cliches: handsomely tormented boyish male leads, saccharine girls, poorly defined psychic powers, inch-deep evil empires and clunking mecha combat; better still, it'd been hyped to the heavens on both sides of the Pacific, received slavish and uncritical adoration from fan communities, and came loaded with horrendously intrusive corporate sponsorship. That whole negative impression lasted three or four episodes, by which time Code Geass had shifted into high gear and begun to reveal itself as an audacious, brilliantly executed, Frankenstein's monster of a pile-up between Alexandre Dumas, Mobile Suit Gundam, V for Vendetta and Death Note. I haven't been so surprised by a show in ages.

The scenario is ridiculously epic. On a near-future parallel Earth, Japan has been conquered and subjugated by the fascistic, social-Darwinist Britannian Empire, renamed 'Area 11' and its people 'Elevens'. Exiled Britannian prince Lelouch Lamperouge lives under an assumed identity in a privileged colonial community in Tokyo, attends private school with his beloved sister Nunnally and fritters away his prodigious intellect with gambling and chess, distracting himself from the unsolved murder of his mother years before. His childhood friend Suzaku Kururugi, son of the last prime minister of Japan, serves in the Britannian military and endeavours to change the system from within, driven by guilt stemming from the death of his father who refused to surrender during the invasion. Caught up one day in a skirmish between Britannian troops and Japanese guerillas, Lelouch opens a capsule aboard the rebels' stolen truck to discover a witchlike girl named C.C., who in return for his allegiance offers him the 'Power of the King' - Geass, the ability to make any person obey him without question. Reigniting his ambition to destroy the Britannian Empire, Lelouch assumes the identity of the masked revolutionary Zero, uses his strategic genius to transform the ragtag Japanese rebels into his personal army, and publicly declares war on injustice and oppression. Suzaku, meanwhile, is put to work as the pilot of the newest Britannian combat mecha, Lancelot - and ordered, naturally, to hunt down Zero....

Code Geass is a harder anime to love than something like Eureka Seven or Tengen Toppa Gurren-Lagann. Despite the creators' best efforts to use the school backdrop as combined soap-opera venue and light relief, the emotional content isn't as heartfelt or well-developed as it is in E7;the victories the characters are allowed against their enemies aren't heroic or unambiguously triumphant, but generally at the cost of intricate planning and heavy sacrifices. Lelouch's Machiavellian brilliance is occasionally overdone and Suzaku's white-knight rigidity annoying - for the first portion of the series, until their determination to see through the paths and identities they've chosen begins to really take its toll on them and everyone around them. Whether or not you buy into the central dynamic of these two will heavily influence your enjoyment, but there's many more spoils to choose from. The extended action set-pieces are stunning - the battle of Narita is probably the best single action-based installment of an anime series I've seen - the music, design and animation are all first rate, and there's a vast array of stellar voice acting on display: Noriaki Sugiyama and Fumiko Orikasa from Bleach as the class clown Rivalz and tragic Shirley, Ami Koshimizu (E7's Anemone) as Starbuck-esque mecha pilot Karen Stadtfeld, and Jun Fukuyama as Lelouch himself, effortlessly slipping between the personas of airhead dilettante, kindly big brother and megalomaniac insurrectionist. The secondary cast members are something to savour too, notably Diethard, the cynical Britannian TV producer who becomes entranced by Zero's theatrical genius, and Euphemia, the naive princess whose determination to do right by the downtrodden Elevens spells disaster for Lelouch's plans.

It's been licensed already, so I won't tell you how to find it, but the DVD release is to be recommended over the TV version - this is a show that deserves to be seen in the best format you can manage. Oh, and the twenty-five episodes to date are only season one - renewal came only at the last moment, and so some of the later episodes may seem a little busy as the creators try to draw together the myriad plot threads. It doesn't matter; season one is still some of the best anime you'll this year.
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
13:04 / 29.10.07


R0x0r.

This sounds superb on a number of levels - it seems not to be available through the usual channels, however. How does one get hold of the DVD, if one does.
 
 
Seth
16:20 / 29.10.07
I've got it on download as we speak... although I have to admit that my anime backlog alone is now running to about four weeks constant viewing with minimal sleep and take out food. While it's great to live in abundance I feel as though I am running from an avalanche.
 
 
Shiny: Well Over Thirty
08:11 / 30.11.07
I’ve just seen episode 17, and I think I’ve finally found the real meat of the show. I wasn’t that into Lelouch as a character until the last few episodes, but my opinion is really changing now. What I really like is that at this point it seems to be coming at the idea of the half crazed scheming strategic genius from a different and deeper direction than is perhaps usual, sure Lelouch can scheme and plot away with the best of them, but even so his plans seem to fall apart almost as often as not, and to do him damage both material and psychological when they do. And that’s got to be closer to the reality of how it would really be for someone like that, than the dozens of strategic genius one can find in the genre who’s plans never come apart until their final downfall. I suppose there were hints of this direction far earlier on – specifically the business with the cat, but it’s taken me this long to theorize that this is perhaps a very important thematic thread to the show.
 
 
Shiny: Well Over Thirty
07:52 / 02.12.07
Right I've finished. I'll be quite circumspect, but there are some spoilers here. No specifics about details, but definitely some comments about the tone, and my feelings about plot developments await below.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

My those last few were distressing, but in a very entertaining way. I think I'd actually have been fine with the ending if it were the final ending, and there weren't another series; I quite enjoy the sort of ending that makes one make up one's own mind about how it all ends up. However knowing there is more to come, and that we will eventually be told exactly what happens next, I'm going crazy wanting to know what happens. Not completely sure how I feel about the very, very fucked up thing, that I'm not going to describe here, but which I suspect anyone who has seen the show will know exactly what I'm talking about. It was horrible, obviously, and the story developments that came from it probably made it worthwhile, but I did feel that maybe the development that caused it clunked just a little - it's maybe the fact that the plot needed to rely on absurdly bad luck to get us to that point, and I think the strings showed a bit. That said Code Geass has gone out of it's way to establish bad luck as a consistantly important factor in it's world, and so I suppose I shouldn't be too negative about it being cranked up a notch towards the end.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
End Spoilers
 
 
Seth
21:09 / 15.01.08
Iggy and I just blasted through the whole of Season 1 today. I agree that it's less emotionally satisfying than other series, but I think that's mainly due to the hyperactive pace of the whole show. It zooms through events and what little time there is for rest is usually taken up with the high school, which feels a little tacked on in order to meet the demographic. The pace inevitably means that some characters suffer from not having well realised enough motivations, which in turn hampers the believability of some key events (I'm looking at you, Nina Einstein).

There are a few things that need cleaning up for me...

Villeta/Chigusa speculates that Zero removed her memories of seeing his face... and while that's certainly in keeping with her character's deductive reasoning (she experienced a memory blank when he stole her Knightmare doesn't know the specific rules behind his Geass that he can only perform the trick once per person) it still leaves us with an annoyingly convenient deus-ex amnesia. While it allowed some excellent later scenes the manner in which her memories were lost and regained was clunky.

Why is Suzaka given the Lancelot in the first place? Is that ever explained? He has a high synch ratio with it, but in order for anyone to know that they have to have given it to him in the first place, which seems a stretch given that he's a Japanese honourary Brittanian. Was it just that it was so experimental that it was given to someone that Lloyd believed to be expendable?

What happened between episodes 18 and 19 (I Order Kururugi Suzaku and Island of the Gods respectively)? We're shown how they get away from the Avalon (great delayed explanation and a nicely satisfying escape) but not how they get from Shikinejima to Kaminejima, why they have become separated and what has happened to their Knightmares, which we're told have been recovered separately. While most of episode 19 is great (besides the needless nudity) I still have no real idea how we got there.

If those things were cleared up for me I'd be much happier with what was overall a great show which spilled over into brilliance the further it went. Great ending, great raising of the stakes, with everything from the horrific episode 22 onwards - Bloodstained Euphie - being jaw droppingly good.

Any word on when we're getting Season 2?
 
 
Mysterious Transfer Student
14:17 / 16.01.08
God, I'd nearly forgotten I'd made this thread. I'm glad Seth, Iggy and Shiny all seem to have enjoyed a show that looking back, probably wasn't as awesome as I'd touted it to be, but is still damn fun at times. I just rewatched the last third of the series and while it's still plainly not in the same class as other anime Barbelith's taken to heart, it's so cheeky and viscerally enjoyable that I can't deny it a place among my favourites of 2007. Just look at the show's attitude to the obligatory product placement: where another series might expect to be embarrassed about a Pizza Hut endorsement, CG plasters the logo over every surface, has the characters munching on and talking about pizza at every opportunity, and even has C.C. assiduously collecting tokens for the purchase of the outsized 'Cheese-kun' plushy (which couldn't help but remind me of Chiyo-dad from Azumanga Daioh.

For the record, the nudity in later episodes is tacked on for the DVD release and so is an unnecessary side-effect of watching the show in a decent print. Things like Suzaku grappling with Karen by the water are a little embarrassing in that regard and don't really contribute much to either character. I'd also volunteer that the show is chock full of outrageous plot holes and doesn't really recover after the Mao storyline and the absurd handling of Shirley, which strained credibility too far for me even though (or rather, because) the writers' intentions of providing foreshadowing for Lelouch were so obvious. The Nina and Villetta issues are similarly hard to cover over, although Nina's entrance and Lloyd's horrified reaction - the first time he ever acts like something other than a facetious twit - was one of my favourite moments in the final episode. As for the fudging of events between #18-19, as far as I can make out the scattering of the characters was an effect of the Avalon's hadron cannon blast interacting with Rakshata's jamming device, though that was never spelled out.

Why is Suzaka given the Lancelot in the first place? ... Was it just that it was so experimental that it was given to someone that Lloyd believed to be expendable?

That's more or less it: Clovis dislikes Lloyd and his projects - Lloyd operates under the aegis of Clovis's rival Schneizel, and it's plain Lloyd is considered a wasteful flake by the mainstream of the Britannian military - and so only a Honorary Britannian is deemed expendable enough to pilot a dangerous experimental Knightmare. In fairness to Lloyd, his treating of Suzaku as a disposable component is no more than a part of his extremely mechanistic and distancing attitude to life in general. Later of course, Suzaku's relationship with Euphie and his proven skill in battle under Cornelia mean both he and the Lancelot become accepted assets.

Season two is due in April and the word is we're in for a horribly contrived 'One Year Later' resumption.... I think at this stage I prefer the show as an unfinished work with all the glaring flaws, joins showing and strident gaucheness intact. I'd not put them in the same category, but I'm reminded of Kazuya Tsurumaki's great comment regarding the chaotic final stages of the production of the Evangelion TV series, that he wanted to show that process of disintegration itself on screen. Instead of the falling away of Eva's final act Code Geass has a series of increasingly bizarre crescendoes, and considering that the show has burnt almost of all its narrative assets by the final episode of season one - is there a single character left for Lelouch to use his Geass on, for one? - I'm wondering what season two could possibly offer that's distinctively CG rather than a.n.other Sunrise production. The promised origins of C.C. and the newly revealed V.V., the Jupiter connection, and the eventual solution to Marianne's murder will hopefully be worth it.
 
 
Seth
14:25 / 07.04.08
The first episode of season two aired yesterday... can anyone recommend a good fansub?
 
 
Mysterious Transfer Student
22:06 / 07.04.08
More shows should have a season two opener entitled The Day the Devil Awakens! It pays to start out lurid and overblown and build from there.

In fairness, and as I mentioned before, having so thoroughly exhausted its assets last season restarting Code Geass was always going to be tricky, but to summarise: it's one year on, the rebellion is toast, most of the Black Knights are dead or in jail, Villetta's a teacher at Ashford Academy (! - amnesia? undercover? either's possible), there's no sign of Nunnally, Lelouch has lost all memory of being Zero and gained a seemingly nice, normal younger brother named Rollo, and Suzaku is working for the Emperor Himself. There's plenty of what CG always delivers: violent Knightmare action, ridiculous amounts of fan-service involving Karen, and juicy evil-mastermind dialogue from Lelouch. Plus, the new opening theme is nostalgic for being by Orange Range, who did OP#1 for Bleach and will always have a place in my heart for that alone.

As for subs, with a hot show like this the number of groups competing for your attention hardly bears thinking about, but [gg] did a superior version of S1 and [Eclipse] are reliable - take your pick, since choosing a group that's likely to make it all the way to the end of the season without dissolving into acrimonious IRC flamewars is an intarweb sk!ll rarer than ESP.
 
 
Seth
23:38 / 08.04.08
So far, so much a butt-ton of mirroring of the first episode of the first season. It sets the tone again nicely, but these writers have a LOT of explaining to do.
 
 
Mysterious Transfer Student
20:46 / 22.06.08
Anyone still with this? The second series is up to episode eleven - it would have been twelve, but episode eight was postponed due to the unfortunate timing of starting a story arc set in China the same week as the earthquakes - and so far I'm enjoying it enormously. Code Geass really has an idiosyncratic attitude to plotting that's either brilliant or uber myopic; rather than skilfully resolve plot points it continues to shovel greater and greater numbers of characters, factions, relationships, Macguffins and twists onto the pile, building the teetering mass higher and higher without a care that it'll come down around its ears at any time. I can't think of another show that turns up the fan-service all the way like this - not just on an eye-candy level (though Karen and Villetta could probably use a break - it's only the show's flagrantly signalled male pairings that mitigate its sexist appeal), but each overwrought relationship turn, lovingly designed new mecha, cornball declaration of undying fealty and cry havoc on the battlefield is so in-your-face there's no option but to give in and luxuriate. CG's always on the point of being a trainwreck, but I wouldn't stoop to say it's so-bad-it's-good - the scriptwriting and design are still terrific, and for twenty-five minutes a week it's more fun than any other show I'm watching. And Lelouch, who's both cold-blooded and vulnerable, is my favourite male protagonist of the season.
 
  
Add Your Reply