BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Radiohead- In Rainbows

 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
 
Robert B
01:14 / 01.11.07
Seth,
I agree. I meant in comparison to their own stuff but then only certain songs I suppose.
 
 
wicker woman
06:17 / 15.11.07
Any ideas whether this sort of thing will have repercussions for people like you? I noted your rather mixed feelings about downloading music.

Likely not. The whole album is up on Limewire; and where Limewire goes, so go likely better quality recordings on p2p sites.

While I agree with the sentiment that Radiohead couldn't have pulled this off if they weren't as well-known as they are, I do think this will become a more viable model as music inevitably becomes more digital and the recording industry dies a shrieking, wrinkled, well-deserved death.

Which is scary, in its own way. Rifling through the liner notes and the occasional extra goody is a... vital?... part of the experience of an album, I think. I mean, I never got around to growing the seeds that came with Tori Amos' Scarlet's Walk, but it was massively cool that they were there.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
11:29 / 15.11.07
It's very Marillion

D'you mean when Fish was a member (though in a sense, of course, Fish will always be a member) or after they were washed up on dry land, as it were?

It's just that I'm not really seeing the influence of stuff like 'Garden Party' 'Punch And Judy' or 'He Knows You Know' on anyone much these days, except possibly The Killers.

Perhaps one day I'll find myself punching the air to 'Market Square Heroes' on a trip to a sales conference that seems limitless, boundless, endless, but I do hope not. All appearances to the contrary, I do try to be a good person, you know?
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
12:18 / 28.12.07
Interestingly, the release of "In Rainbows" has been identified as one of the dumbest moves of the year by Fortune magazine. The logic for this is that two thirds of the buyers did not actually pay anything for it, with the remaining third paying around six dollars. This certainly seems pretty bad - on iTunes it would have sold for $7.99 for the album. This assumes, of course, that all the people who downloaded it for free would have bought it from iTunes, rather than... downloading it for free.

Also worth noting that the royalty for a download from iTunes would have been a dollar per album, whereas the profit on the donations for this were pure profit - which means they actually doubled their money on the same number of downloads. So, was the unit cost per download more than a dollar per? I very much doubt it. Which means that Radiohead, personally, probably made more on selling "In Rainbows" than they would have if they had released it through the usual channels, at least on digital downloads.

That's interesting - and it's interesting that Fortune is portraying it as a stupid move, as if, say, there would have been no free file sharing of the album if Radiohead themselves had not facilitated them. The people who do most certainly lose out here are the record label, which would have received a sizeable cut from the iTunes music store for whoever many albums were sold there.
 
 
jamesPD
13:54 / 08.07.08
Did anybody catch Radiohead on their last UK tour? I didn't buy a ticket since I'm neither a huge fan nor was I going to be in the country at the time, but my housemate did. However, he chose to sell the tickets (at a loss) rather than attend.

Apparently the first night consisted of solely new stuff, while the second was all from OK Computer and earlier. Was anyone at either of these gigs? Were they any good?
 
 
ZF!
18:39 / 09.07.08
Though not a fan, a friend had a spare, so I went the first night.

Wasn't all new stuff, well, here's the setlist:

Setlist

01 15 Step
02 Bodysnatchers
03 All I Need
04 The National Anthem
05 Pyramid Song
06 Nude
07 Arpeggi
08 The Gloaming
09 Dollars and Cents
10 Faust Arp
11 There There
12 Just
13 Climbing Up The Walls
14 Reckoner
15 Everything In Its Right Place
16 How To Disappear Completely
17 Jigsaw Falling Into Place

Encore 1:

18 Videotape
19 Airbag
20 Bangers ‘n Mash
21 Planet Telex
22 The Tourist

Encore 2:

23 Cymbal Rush
24 You And Whose Army?
25 Idioteque

It was ok, quite a good atmosphere.
 
 
ZF!
18:48 / 09.07.08
Actually, on last.fm there are tons of reviews and pics, whcih would probably give you a better idea.

Here there be Radiohead reviews...

first one is quite amusing, but long.
 
 
dark horse
14:15 / 21.07.08
how much did barbe-dudes pay for In Rainbows? i have to admit i didn't pay radiohead anything but i felt guilty about it afterwards cos of how great the record is...
 
 
grant
00:47 / 25.07.08
I didn't pay anything; I wouldn't have bought it anyway.

I did just discover this. It's a video for "Videotape" done as part of a contest.

1. It's pretty haunting, and unlike nearly everything else I've seen on the aniBOOM YouTube channel.

2. I think it points to a slightly different relationship to the music than most fan/artist/label triangles. I suppose other acts have had contests for fans or curious relationships with bootleggers & tapers. But this kind of co-creation seems a little different. The band is judging videos assembled by a coalition organized around a YouTube channel.
 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
  
Add Your Reply