BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Judicial Murder of Doctor Watson

 
 
All Acting Regiment
19:43 / 30.09.07
THE JUDICIAL MURDER OF DOCTOR WATSON


I

“Cleverness and cunning are the gifts of heaven; ignorance and stupidity may be feigned. Jealousy arises often from a narrow heart, disputes are set off by thoughtless jokes.”

So the fellow mused.

I had arranged to meet him at ten at my old Club in Soho, and then to take him to Holmes' house where Holmes would listen to what he had to say. Holmes himself was laid up with a terrible sort of cold. None the less, when I informed him about the appeal I had received from this plaintive man, Holmes had demanded that I bring him to Baker Street as soon as possible, where Holmes, somewhat in the manner of the Princess de Cleves, would receive him whilst sitting up in bed sipping cocoa.

The fellow who now sat before me was the sort of man who, whilst being far from ugly in almost all aspects, was none the less closest to ugliness in the form of his hands, which were far from small, and certainly indelicate. He was dressed in the professorial manner, with a tweed jacket, half-moon glasses and a watch-chain.

“For the heart,” he continued, “is more dangerous than the River with its nine bends, and there are evil faces that ten coats of mail cannot conceal. Wine and women have often caused the downfall of states, but who has ever seen good men spoiled by books?”

“Quite, quite,” I said. “But look here, my good man, what does all this mean?”

My request was met with marble silence. He had been talking in this manner from the very first time he accosted me in the street. I was quite baffled! With a sly look he rubbed his hands together and said:

“There is a season for frowning. There is a season for laughing.”

As it happened, our repeated knocks on Holmes' door were rebuffed by the housemaid, who assured us that nothing was wrong, but that we were not to call for a good while.

II

{Here the engines of murder ticked forward to their inevitable destination. “One, two”, they said; “One, two, one, two”, and then “One”.}

III

It was a heavy volume in French called (I could not read it very well) The Flares of Evil with which he battered on my poor skull. As I lay in a tumbled pool, thinking on my former beauty, he said:

“ ... in favour of something more valuable.”

“The only thing I understand,” said I, “is that I am the one who does not understand.”
 
 
Jawsus-son Starship
18:00 / 01.10.07
I had arranged to meet him at ten at my old Club in Soho, and then to take him to Holmes' house where Holmes would listen to what he had to say. Holmes himself was laid up with a terrible sort of cold. None the less, when I informed him about the appeal I had received from this plaintive man, Holmes had demanded that I bring him to Baker Street as soon as possible, where Holmes, somewhat in the manner of the Princess de Cleves, would receive him whilst sitting up in bed sipping cocoa.

I love this; the repetition of Holmes' name highlights Watson's feelings for the man; it feels like he worships the man to such an extent that he's stopped being a man and become the entity simply known as Holmes.

The rest, not so much. It feels rushed - you wanted to say something so much that you forget that it's not about where we go, but how we get there. Maybe the point is that all murders follow the same path, and that it's pointless to repeat it. But it jars with a character as verbose as the Watson we intially meet, to skip past an oppotunity to use fifteen words when five will do.

There's no journey, we just end up at an ending. There's a wonderful voice here, and I'd love to see this expanded to something fuller, rounder. Do you plan to expand it?

Or have I missed the point entirely?
 
 
All Acting Regiment
23:52 / 02.10.07
I'm not sure, you see. It might well be worth expanding, as you say so.
 
 
DavidXBrunt
15:15 / 29.10.07
I can see the appeal of Watson, an Army Doctor who no doubt has plenty of experience and knowledge of the randomness of insanity and life being seduced into forgetting that when he begins to look at the events of life around him with his freinds outlook of every random thing meaning something and thus losing his life when confronted with insensible reality but I'm not sure I really like the piece. Damn that's an awfully long sentence.

It doesn't read like Watson to me and in a piece like this that's a major problem.
 
 
Spaniel
15:47 / 31.10.07
More please. Morepleasenow
 
  
Add Your Reply