BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Sergei Lukyanenko: Night Watch, Day Watch, Dusk/Twilight Watch, Final Watch.

 
 
Feverfew
11:14 / 25.09.07
We have a thread on Night Watch as a film, and also a thread on Day Watch, but I am jiggered if I can find anything in B, C&W with regard to Lukyanenko's Watch tetralogy, so I thought now was as good a time as any to start one.

For details, you can start here, and work your way in. Day Watch is being released in cinemas in Britain on October 5th, apparently, and the DVD comes out in America on October 31st, but it's not, to my knowledge, getting much press.

*

On a personal level, I'm fascinated by the novels, most prevalently the structure and phrasing that seems to come out in the translation. I love the charicterisation of Anton Gorodetsky in the books, and I think the transition to film hasn't been done badly so far.

In terms of literary style, it feels to me almost like a clean read - something like, to me, the way Death and the Penguin reads, although that feels like a too obvious comparison, somehow.

Oh, and "Dusk Watch" is now "Twilight Watch", apparently. Try not to pay any mind to the cover quotes referring to a "J K Rowling, Russian Style".

Is anyone else a fan of this series? Are there any other recommendations re: the author's other works? And does anyone know when Final Watch is being translated?
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
15:20 / 25.09.07
I've read Night and Day, and have Twilight ready to go. I'm really enjoying the series so far. I was expecting something a bit more slam-bang after watching the Matrixy movie, but overall I think they read much more like a classic Cold War spy novel. In large part I think they only work BECAUSE they're Russian- the Cold War parallels are all too easy to see, and coming from the country that "lost" that particular (non-)engagement they have a very specific feel to them, which only really works coming from the post-Communist Russia.

My only problem is that I find a lot of Zabulon and Gesir's machinations go right over my head, and a lot of the tying-up of these at the end of each section seems a little rushed; but when I'm having that much fun with a book I can forgive shit like that.
 
 
Feverfew
22:36 / 13.10.07
Just to say that I've just finished Twilight Watch, and the ending has, in an unexpected way, floored me. You have a lot to look forward to. It also picks up on the Gesar / Zabulon machinations and the reasoning behind them, which is a plus.

Final Watch is apparently out some time in june/july next year, according to pre-order. Which kind of pisses on how all the reprints list them as 'part x in the Watch Trilogy", but since they insist on putting a quote saying "Russia's J K Rowling" on the front, I have no sympathy.
 
 
Haloquin
15:22 / 27.10.07
I really enjoyed Night Watch, haven't read past the first one as I've been being good and waiting for them not to be oversized expensive paperbacks... which is taking forever!

The film managed, IMO, to miss really interesting relationships between the characters but made it very pretty... but I like the depth of interaction in the book. And it reads very easily, smoothly.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
17:56 / 07.11.07
Reading Twilight Watch now, and is it me, or is Anton developing a habit of inserting his political views into everything now? Did he always do this and I just didn't notice? Are they his, or Lutyanenko's? Some of them seem a little dodgy.

Other than that, yeah, I'm loving it. Halfway through Story Two, and I'm really, really glad there's gonna be another one after this.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
15:17 / 09.11.07
Just finished it; it would appear my fears were unfounded. In fact, what I think I like about these books is the way they look at the ugly ideology which underpins something like The Matrix (we're special, you're not, your lives don't matter you foolish sheeple) and actually admit to what that really means- this is pretty much what Anton's internal monologue is about throughout. I think this is why I was a little too quick to be dismayed by what I saw as the interjection of nationalism.
 
  
Add Your Reply