BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Umbrella Academy

 
  

Page: (1)2

 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
14:54 / 18.09.07
The first issue of Way & Bá's Umbrella Academy: The Apocalypse Suite drops like a bomb this very Wednesday, so I'm firing up the thread-making engines to give it its own little frequency amid the Barbehum.

Preview of the first issue here.

I am at the very least loving a little kid gang of super-children in domino masks and private school uniforms. And numbers for names! Dehumanizing childhood trauma a-go-go!

Is anyone else planning to pick this up? Because between the oncoming rush of Madman Atomic Comics #4 and this baby, I can almost manage to make it through my Tuesday without sinking into the deep and overwhelming seas of despair or such.
 
 
Essential Dazzler
15:21 / 18.09.07
I picked up the Free Comic Book Day short story, and really enjoyed it.

It's the first time I've seen Ba's work outside of Casanova, it took me ages to stop missing the green. It is brilliant art, every page crackles.

The writing wasn't perfect, but the ideas were cool, a steam-punky take on juvenile super-heroes, Way has cited Morrison as a major influence. it's been ages since I read it, but I think the plot revolved around a murderous magician attempting to murder a talk show host and it's audience, while they laughed along merrily.

It did introduce one of my favourite new characters of this year, The Rumour, whose powers prevent her from ever telling a lie. It's better than it sounds.

Couldn't find it online, but I did find these other shorts:

Safe and Sound (8 pages)

And this two page piece
 
 
Jamie
18:12 / 18.09.07
When I saw the excerpt in previews where they fight Zombie Robot Gustave Eiffel, I was sold. Hopefully it actually ships this week (I'm still miffed that Suburban Glamour from Image got pushed back to October or November.)

I actually have the FCBD issue, but I haven't read it for whatever reason.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
20:28 / 18.09.07
Thanks for those short comics, Pacific -- they make me that little bit more excited about getting this tomorrow. Sadly, there were no leftover FCBD comics lingering around, certainly not the Dark Horse one. Something about Kraken's costume is quite striking, he reminds me a bit of the old Flash rogue the Top.
 
 
Aertho
20:38 / 18.09.07
The little girl, who's not special... that's The Rumour, correct?
 
 
Mysterious Transfer Student
20:52 / 18.09.07
Funny that PPP mentioned this in the same post as Madman - those two last shorts definitely have an Allred vibe going on to my mind, in atmosphere rather than art style at any rate.

Spaceboy with his Martian gorilla body reminds me of the Headmen, and Kraken has a cool hard-boiled quality... in fact the whole business seems about as far from what you might expect comics written by the singer with a chart-topping *mo band to be like as possible. It's looking good.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
22:40 / 18.09.07
The little girl, who's not special... that's The Rumour, correct?

I would presume as much, and I'm very curious, based on the preview, about where things are going with her - and how her power works, whether truth is an objective thing or if it has to do with what she believes to be true.

Funny that PPP mentioned this in the same post as Madman - those two last shorts definitely have an Allred vibe going on to my mind, in atmosphere rather than art style at any rate.

They certainly have an Allredish touch to the design sense, particularly Kraken. Very primal-feeling super-heroes.
 
 
MattShepherd: I WEDDED KALI!
15:47 / 19.09.07
I read Safe and Sound previously, and it kind of went in one eye and out the other -- pretty, but pretty much Hellboy-lite. I finished it, mentally substituted the red guy in for Kraken, and it was basically a Mignola riff.

(I'm also a bit weirded out that I have a comic launching in less than 12 months called RISE, KRAKEN! and in a fit of abysmal timing this "Kraken" character shows up. Hopefully he won't get a spin-off series before Summer 2008.)

But... yeah. Underwhelmed. Ba's work is gorgeous, but we have a generic super-hero fighting a stereotype gypsy who uses the Tarot for e-e-eeevil, dialogue from central casting, and an ending that makes, well, no sense at all. The car had crashed into the window of a store that had a dozen spheres in the window that all looked exactly like the evil gypsy's soul-holding crystal ball, and even had the same evil green glow? Wha?

Plus the word "brakes" misspelled in like a 28-point font. Nobody's perfect, but that's just flagrant lack of attention from script through editing. I don't demand perfect spelling and grammar from my comics, but when it's the largest word in all eight pages, make sure you spell it right.

Maybe the game is upped in the comic itself; it seems like a kind of neat premise, but I really thought the 8-page short was just scraping the bottom of the Hellboy barrel.
 
 
My Mom Thinks I'm Cool
16:41 / 19.09.07
picked up #1 just now. the preview above shows most of the action in this issue - the rest is just setup. a lot of it seems like panels just to show off how cool things look, which is excusable since they look cool.

enjoyed it overall, looking forward to more.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
21:35 / 19.09.07
First off, let me say that this has one of the best, crispest splash pages I've seen in a while. Bá delivers a really gorgeous image of pulp sci-fi super-wrestling. Groovy. It recalled me immediately to Terminal City, Kid Gloves fighting his way "up the evolutionary ladder" against apes before fighting Science, as represented by robots. I like the retro pulp trappings that would normally be a "secret history" along the lines of Planetary being put up front, for all the world to see, regular schmoes betting on a wrestling machine between a man and a space monster. That said, half the voice-over for that first page is a little muddled, a little grammatically dissonant for a moment. Did anyone else find that? I got what was being said but it was phrased oddly.

The backstory that Way sets up is fairly zeitgeisty fare, built on a solid Midwich Cuckoos foundation with some Charles Xavier thrown in. We're left with a background mystery even as the backstory is set up, a mystery that will probably seem irrelevant at first but eventually tie into the foregrounded mystery.

It's a first issue. Let's be clear. Like RED says upthread, well, there's a lot of set-up and not a lot of action, per se, but Bá delivers some great visuals to carry us forward and Way certainly sets up enough that I'm at the very least interested in where this going. I'm very glad that we have only a minimum of time with the seven as children, because I kept having to consult the text page at the front to remind myself who was whom and even then only 1, 2, 3, and 7 get any real development; 5 disappears for the bulk of the story. Once they're adults, they look more distinct and start to demonstrate the rudiments of personality.

As much as Bá delivers great images, well, in places his work could use some strengthening. I would have liked to see one more person actively fall from the tower to clarify things, althoug the scripting with the gendarmes was partly to fault for this.

Number 7 -- the "unspecial one" -- isn't the Rumour. I like the Rumour already, and 7 is being drawn more clearly as a possible villain.

Grown-up Spaceboy is more exciting than the little kids, and I'm looking forward to more development from him. There were some good transitions there.

I worry that Way's trying to hit all the expected beats a bit too hard -- talking chimpanzee? Check. It's predictable that one was included and it made me a little sad. Why not a talking duck or a dog or just no talking animals?

Text pages were interesting, hard to believe it's been - what? Twenty-something years that the Watchmen text page approach has been around with any force? I would have actually preferred some backmatter a la Casanova, but I'm rather insidious with my desire to listen to writers and artists discussing their process.

It's nice. It feels like a Silver Age comic without being too derivative of the obvious sources like the JLA, sinking more into a pre-DC Silver Age 1950s territory. Doesn't feel like Hellboy at all, actually. It needs an issue or two to really get going, though. But I'm looking forward to it.
 
 
Jamie
23:55 / 19.09.07
The opening splash page one of the highlights of the book (along with the reveal of the first villain.) It reminded me of the recent Japanese film The Calamari Wrestler, which featured a pro wrestling giant squid, and it immediately hooked me. Maybe I'm a sucker for pro wrestling sea creatures...

I am, however, a little disappointed to see that we have now jumped forward in time -- there aren't enough tween superhero teams out there, and the Charles Addams meets Power Pack vibe they had going was pretty keen. Jump forward two decades, and they lose some of that distinctive flavour. But I like the art, I like the writing (which surprised me), and I like the presence of a letter column.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
15:24 / 20.09.07
Jamie: I am, however, a little disappointed to see that we have now jumped forward in time -- there aren't enough tween superhero teams out there, and the Charles Addams meets Power Pack vibe they had going was pretty keen. Jump forward two decades, and they lose some of that distinctive flavour.

It looks like Number 5 is going to be a tweener in the present / future, and I'm assuming we'll probably see some use of flashbacks as they try to fill us in on what came before.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
21:23 / 20.09.07
Apologies for any poss threadrot, but shouldn't Gerard Way be hunted down and butchered as a matter of principle?
 
 
Haus of Mystery
20:24 / 25.09.07
Maybe regarding his band, but this is his comic, and it's surprisingly good. Very very un-emo (go and buy your Penance comics for all that shit, kids), and boldly written.
 
 
Haus of Mystery
20:33 / 25.09.07
Actually I think I'll expand on that; this is almost a very good comic. It certainly has some good moments and a heady surreal atmosphere reminiscent of Mignola's 'Screw-On Head' one-shot, Casey's 'Godland', and I suppose 'doom Patrol'. It's whimsical, funny, and a bit creepy. It's an impressively confident piece of work from someone with little published comic writing experience, and if it's guilty of trying to run before it can walk then so be it.
Lovely, lovely Ba artwork. I prefer the fully coloured stuff to what I saw of 'Casanova', and his loose cartoony style is the perfect fit for the tone of the book.
Like I said, it's not quite brilliant but it is very endearing and offbeat, and certainly far better than I think anyone had the right to expect.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
07:10 / 26.09.07
Amazing Screw-On Head is, I'd say, a perfect example of the kind of comic Umbrella Academy is trying to be, the primary difference being that Head manages to compress all the significant set-up necessary down to an infinitesmal point in space without losing any meaning, while Academy tries to both overexplain everything (yes, we get it, babies born in synch, one page could be a panel) while at the same time hitting the expected/"perceived as desirable" fanwank beats (talking chimps). Way hasn't gotten a handle on pacing and that so clearly shows itself here.

Which isn't to say that this isn't an enjoyable comic; that transition from Paris to the Moon, past to present, 0001 to Spaceboy-- inspired. Probably my favourite moment. But of course, Academy has an advantage that Head didn't; simply, it's a series and there's going to be more room for it to hit its stride. Way hasn't had the time to develop his craft like Mignola has.
 
 
My Mom Thinks I'm Cool
14:29 / 26.09.07
yeah, pacing is probably a good way to describe what I was feeling - did it really need to take four pages for Spaceboy to get a phone call and come home? yeah, it all looked cool, but that could have been some actual story going on instead.

or at least another fight.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
15:33 / 26.09.07
Everything about Bá's artwork and the nature of the characters/situation practically demands compression, but of course there's still that love affair going on with decompression (to some extent, at least).
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
04:25 / 16.10.07
Perhaps only I am left, a barren traveller in a wasteland with whistling wind tunnels and the distant promise of a house, up on a dune, where sand crusts the windows and there's nobody waiting to answer the door, but I am looking forward to the fact that Umbrella Academy #2 is scheduled to come out this week, possibly because I really enjoyed the Free Comic Book Day preview once I finally got to bathe in it.

Bá's art may be the only thing propelling me forward through my Infernal Tuesday.
 
 
Jamie
13:37 / 16.10.07
No, I'm looking forward to it as well, although I was cursed with false hope when I saw what appeared to be issue #2 a week early. It transpired that it was just a second printing of #1, with a new cover.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
23:18 / 21.11.07
Third issue is out this week, and it's a pretty sweet little entry, the series is starting to feel like it's hitting a stride, and Ba's artwork is crisp as ever. Not entirely convinced of Vanya's motivations, though. Anybody?
 
 
Alex's Grandma
19:35 / 24.11.07
A bit surprised that more people don't seem to be enjoying this; in spite of huge reservations about Gerard Way's musical career (which shouldn't, in any case, really matter; I don't suppose anyone would have guessed Alan Moore had 'Watchmen' in him, based on a listen to his work as Sinister Duck) it's about my favourite thing around at the moment, like the Royal Tennenbaums meets George's run on the Doom Patrol, with elements of LXG (the sense of back-story, plus a certain, pitiless. narrative edge - nothing good's going to happen to any of these people) tossed in. Plus the art's fab.

I'd go so far as to say that anyone who gives this a whirl and doesn't enjoy it has a free pass to me call a terminal fool here, live on Barbelith, and I won't say a word back. Not a word.
 
 
Jackie Susann
21:32 / 25.11.07
Yeah, I think this is really great, too, and I'm surprised more people here aren't into it. It kind of makes me want to find out what the dude's band sounds like.
 
 
Triplets
22:39 / 25.11.07
They're pretty good, you know.

Just wanted to throw a "me too!" into here. The first issue was good in a hits-my-pulp-action-buttons way - the same as Grant's Batman - with added weirdness.

But it was also a negative, as it seemed Way (as someone mentioned above) was deliberately trying to go for maximum fanservice with things like the talking chimp. It seemed forced.

Also, can't help but feel Way has cribbed a lot of the feel/style of the first issue from Kids Next Door (a cartoon) which features, among other things, codenumbered kids fighting strange (adult) menances. Not a bad thing in itself but was odd to see the KND in an emo/gothic style.

Anyway, I'm going to stick with this series as I think, when he's not being too heavy handed, that Way and I are on the same geekwave and that he could bring a lot of enjoyable stuff to the table. Now I just need to get my lazy arse to the local comic bookery.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
21:26 / 21.12.07
Gadzooks!

First thought on reading Umbrella Academy #4 -- Holy Man Ray!

More in a while, when I've digested. I don't think six issues will be enough room for this, but this comic is definitely hitting a stride.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
04:37 / 22.12.07
Further thinking.

Okay, Vanya and the Man Ray action.

Doctor Pogo, the talking chimpanzee. Look, I was skeptical -- it's such an obvious "weird comix" trope to invoke, it's almost tired. BUT. But, Way manages to make me go from being extremely skeptical of Pogo to really adoring him in the space of three pages with the opening of the fourth issue and his encounter with Vanya.

I love the angularity of the speech bubbles.

Pogo continues to be a touchstone for me this issue; I love every scene in it, as he beseeches Number Five to see reason and Number Five responds with some really great logic; love the odd dissonance with the image.

Vanya's life-changing experience = Ba turns in some beautiful work.

On the one hand, I'm really sad that they went to the well of pseudo-forbidden pseudo-incest implied between non-blood siblings, but on the other hand -- it rocks very much the vibe that the comic has going, that this is The Royal Tennenbaums in X-Men or Doom Patrol drag.

Did anyone else pick this up this week?
 
 
Alex's Grandma
12:00 / 22.12.07
Yeah. Still enjoying it. The art's been accused of being a bit derivative elsewhere (on Millarworld, and other such louche places,) but after the transformation scene here, that seems willfully unkind.

It strikes me that while there's no particular reason to read this as a monthly (for all its strengths, I don't know if it's gripping, exactly) it's going to do well when it comes out as a trade.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
16:23 / 22.12.07
Who, exactly, is he supposed to be derivative of, according to these people? And isn't art of any stripe or variety derivative of something, depending on the influences of the artist?

Your point about the collection is taken and agreed with; the pacing still doesn't seem quite right for a monthly comic, but that seems more a result of the trend toward trade-writing that hasn't quite overpowered the Monthly Comic Business Plan. As it stands, I really don't think six issues is enough space, based on how Way seems to plot and write, to really develop these characters or this world enough. But it seems to be following, based on the lettercol, the Hellboy School of Mini-Series Adventures.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
17:52 / 24.12.07
Who, exactly, is he supposed to be derivative of, according to these people?

Mike Mignola, apparently, though I don't really see it myself. Mignola's an influence I suppose, but then again, so, arguably, is Kevin O'Neill, or anyone else who's had an interestingly cartoony style in recent years.

The six issue format seems a bit off, I agree, but it was probably unavoidable, given Gerard Way's other commitments. Which some might say are regrettable in themselves; on the other hand, at twenty six, or whatever he is, he's probably a bit too young to give up the life of an international rock star.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
04:07 / 25.12.07
We're all too young to give up the role of international rock star, Grams. Do you know how much hairspray I apply to my hair everyday before going on stage?

I suppose I can see the potential for the Mignola criticism (Ryan Sook does pretty well, considering he's very much a Mike Mignola cover band schooled in the Dark Horse House's style, without it being considered a crime against nature -- why not Bá?), but Bá's sense of anatomy is a lot slinkier in comparison to Mignola's stocky figures, and his lines in general are a lot more kinetic.
 
 
The Falcon
08:51 / 26.12.07
Sook has long since shaken his Mignola-lite tag, though; it's unquestionable his work on, ah, it was the Spectre, wasn't it? was totally Mignola to the bone, down to those little battle-damage scrapes double M does but I really can't see it in his Zatanna work or those phenomenal covers/posters he's been doing for DC - sort of veering out into Adam Hughes territory almost now.
 
 
Haus of Mystery
08:58 / 26.12.07
I like this book more than virtually any other on the stands at the moment. It captures the spirit and vibe of Morrison's 'Doom Patrol' like nothing else. It's effortlessly fun and weird, with a lovely dark streak and gorgeous artwork.
 
 
Triplets
14:37 / 27.12.07
Way's about 30, Granny. Time for him to put down those vanilla slices get a real job.

Anyway, have just read issue 4. Comparisons, in terms of tone, with Doom Patrol are pretty spot on. Umbrella Academy is just trying to be a fun, little pop comic, and it succeeds very well. Interested to see where 07 takes the Orchestra of Doom and why Hargreaves thought it'd be best to smother her incredible power in resentment and an inferiority complex the size of Bristol.

The cover's gorjuice too.
 
 
Mark Parsons
01:08 / 28.12.07
Way has made an amazingly solid debut (unless I've missed prior comics work). UA is a pleasure and Ba's art is wonderfully evocative and charming.
 
 
Internaut
21:55 / 05.01.08
im not sure that it's the Rumour that's powerless, its Vanya.

i think that whatever she speaks while assuming it to be true automatically becomes true.

having not read the Umbrella Academy in a few weeks, im not sure on the specifics.
 
  

Page: (1)2

 
  
Add Your Reply