BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Doping in Tour de France & sports in general

 
 
Closed for Business Time
15:23 / 26.07.07
What with the daily exposes of doping in the Tour these last weeks some questions I've asked myself in the past have reappeared:

Why are sporting orgs forbidding the use of otherwise legal (and sometimes therapeutically beneficial) drugs and biomedical methods in the first place? Of course, all drugs prohibited in criminal law are also no-no, however hilarious the effects of their use in a competitive setting would be. Think cannabis, heroin, LSD and a host of narcotic and psychotropic substances.

So why aren't we giving carte blanche to athletes to dope away as much as they want?

What are the arguments pro and contra a laissez-faire doping regime?
 
 
jamesPD
15:39 / 26.07.07
I don't have much time to write a response at the moment, but the general argument is that sports would then become a competition between pharmaceutical companies rather than between individual athletes. If people were allowed to use drugs to improve their performance then the demand and hence price would increase, which would probably be fine for some Olympic teams, but would signal the end of qualifying for poorer countries.
 
 
Triplets
15:48 / 26.07.07
I'm going to look at Steve Lomard-esque "performance enhancers" here. Although, I admit, seeing a school of cyclist ripped to the tits on speed would be ace.

What you've got to remember is excess. While the most visible reason for prohibiting performance enhancing drugs is that is creates bigger imbalances in performance potential you've got to remember that we're all human, and humans can take things way too far. If you opened the floodgates to performance boosters you'd get athletes, either through ignorance or going with their competition-junkie nature, going completely ape with the 'roids and any other plus-drug you can name. The last thing any sporting body wants is a sharp increase in the number of dead bodies associated with it. Which brings me to another point; increased chances of litigation if a sporting org allowed prohibited drugs. "I was PRESSURED to take drugs to stay in the game!" etc.

Funnily enough, I was pirate-reading New Scientist today about superathletes and how a lot of it is just down to getting the right genetics. Being an athletic mutant, basically. However, they did allow that with the right training, diet and gadgets one can, for a little bit, be Batman. Then they started talking about DARPA superfoods (they're trying to create a fourth food group for energy production) and I had to leave the shop.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
22:07 / 26.07.07
Isn't this the kind of thing Games & Gameplay might be missing?
 
 
Alex's Grandma
22:26 / 26.07.07
If you mean speed, LSD and steroids, I think you're right, Mr S.
 
  
Add Your Reply