BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Alternate History of The Yiddish Policemen's Union [SPOILERS, more'n likely]

 
 
grant
15:39 / 02.06.07
So, I lucked into a copy of The Yiddish Policemen's Union which I just finished last night. It's a great book - something like Fargo reimagined by Tom Clancy while listening to a lot of Gogol Bordello. Only very, very Jewish.

That's why it's set in Alaska.

Murder mystery leads through the world of chess masters, CIA operations and ultra-orthodox crime families. At the same time, there's a little romance and a lot of world-building.

It starts with a hard-boiled detective waking up in the flophouse he calls home, pulling on his hat and tie to answer a late-night call. Here's a print-ready version of some selected excerpts. One of the pleasant things about reading the book is the gradual way you're led to realize this isn't the 1940s, but the present time - in a world where things unfolded slightly differently. I have a hunch about what happened differently, but I'm not sure there's enough evidence in the book to support it.

If anyone else has read the thing and wants to play, though, it could be fun.

Here's a list of clues:

[+] [-] the clues

There's an interesting note related to that in this NYT article describing how Chabon got the idea for the novel.

I also think the ending owes a debt to the last frame Watchmen, but I would.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
21:53 / 03.06.07
Going through an interview with him recently, I was surprised by what a comics fan Chabon turns out to be. I'd also had no idea that he'd written at least some of the script for Spiderman 2 (which I found a bit depressing, but that's beside the point.) The point being that he could easily be referencing the last scene in Watchmen at the end of his new book, which I'm looking forward to.
 
 
Mark Parsons
16:18 / 10.06.07
Chabon also did an outline/treatment for an X-MEN movie. This was prior to Singer et alia. It was rather dire. I used to read scripts for a living, and one bit of conventionla wisdom is that prose authors make terrible screenwriters. Ellroy was infamous for writing a stodgy, "unfilmable" screenplay.
 
 
Feverfew
11:07 / 04.03.08
something like Fargo reimagined by Tom Clancy while listening to a lot of Gogol Bordello. Only very, very Jewish.

According to the latest issue of Empire, the Coen Brothers are filming this as one of their next projects. See Here, should you want to squee.

I've just picked this up in paperback and I'm loving it intensely, but I'm going to finish it before I come back here and post more.
 
 
grant
16:18 / 04.03.08
OH, wow.

It'll make a great movie - so much of the fun relies on picturing these guys in fedoras like it's the 1940s, then realizing that it's *now*, sort of.
 
 
Jester
10:08 / 06.03.08
In case you're interested, you can read the very brilliant essay that was the inspiration/precursor for the novel here.
 
 
grant
18:26 / 06.03.08
Oh, that's perfect.

When I first came across Say It In Yiddish, , on a shelf in a big chain store in Orange County, California, I couldn't quite believe that it was real. There was only one copy of it, buried in the languages section at the bottom of the alphabet. It was like a book in a story by J. L Borges, unique, inexplicable, possibly a hoax. The first thing that really struck me about it was, paradoxically, its unremarkableness, the conventional terms with which Say It In Yiddish advertises itself on its cover. "No other PHRASE BOOK FOR TRAVELLERS," it claims, "contains all these essential features."


leads eventually to

I can imagine another Yisroel, the youngest nation on the North American continent, founded in the former Alaska Territory during World War II as a resettlement zone for the Jews of Europe. (For a brief while, I once read, Franklin Roosevelt was nearly sold on such a plan.)... It is a cold, northern land of furs, paprika, samovars and one long, glorious day of summer.... This Yisroel--or maybe it would be called Alyeska--is a kind of Jewish Sweden, social-democratic, resource rich, prosperous, organizationally and temperamentally far more akin to its immediate neighbor, Canada, then to its more freewheeling benefactor far to the south. Perhaps, indeed, there has been some conflict, in the years since independence, between the United States and Alyeska.


So that's how it happened.
 
 
JaredSeth
19:52 / 06.03.08
Just read an interesting article by Chabon on the New Yorker site a couple days ago. Comic book related, little surprise.

Ah, here's the link.
 
 
woodenpidgeon
02:02 / 20.03.08
Just finished this novel: fantastic. It's equally good for lovers of literature and the detective fiction. If you have any inklings of reading it, by all means -- avoid all reviews, articles, and criticism. This is a good book to walk blindly into.

*****Spoilers (do you even need to be warned?)*****
There's a lot of interesting information on the Wikipedia page about the alternate timelines in the novel. Some will take a while to ferret out. (Partial Holocaust avoided? Hitler replaced? Soviets defeated? Berlin nuked in 1946? Manchurian astronauts in present day life?)

HEART OF DARKNESS
I had to look up the references to Orson Welles' Heart of Darkness mentioned in the novel. There's a really interesting article from the Guardian about the making or unmaking of the film.(http://film.guardian.co.uk/features/featurepages/0,,1429851,00.html)

Interesting points in relation to Chabon's Book:
--In Chabon's alternate history Welles did in fact make this film. It was Welles' ill-fated first film in actuality, but it stalled out due to studio pressures and indifference.
--Welles was interested in addressing rampant fascism through the character of Kurtz.
--Welles was probably going to make a very arty (1st person point of view for the entire film) and not very watchable. Both Bina and Meyer are not really into the film (still looking for the reference).
--Kurtz's dying tirade in Welles film: "There's a man now in Europe trying to do what I've done in the jungle. He will fail. In his madness he thinks he can't fail - but he will."

Given the fact that the entire Alaskan Homeland for the Jews comes down to a congressman chasing a rum-bun into the street and being hit by a cab, can we also infer that Welles film does have an impart on audiences at the time, and has some affect on the alternate history timeline? The film was going to come to fruition prior to the war. However successful or influential, it's still watched many years later by Meyer and Bina.
 
 
grant
13:25 / 20.03.08
I remember thinking I should look up that Welles film, then got swept up by everything else in the novel.

And I can't believe I haven't thought of looking at Wikipedia's version of the alternate history.
 
 
grant
18:07 / 15.04.08
I just had a thought - one of several "reveals" in the book's first half is that the characters aren't actually speaking English - they're speaking a flavor of Yiddish, aren't they? (I think the reference is when the federal officers turn up speaking American.)

Anyway, I’m wondering if the Coen brothers would dare make a Passion/Apocalypso-style subtitled movie out of this novel.

That would be like a dream, wouldn't it?
 
 
grant
15:27 / 06.05.08
I'm not familiar enough with Alaskan geography to know if this is relevant to the book or not, but if you're into Google Street View (an amazing tool), check out the street-level photographs of a town marked as "Alyeska".

Is this an in-joke?
 
  
Add Your Reply