BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Fat Kids Can't Hunt

 
 
Liger Null
23:37 / 25.05.07
Didn't see a thread on
this one
here.

I think it is absolutely horrid. I don't really know where to begin: the whole "let's pick on Fatty" mindset, the fact that the participants are minors, the utterly ridiculous claim that the show will "help" kids, the intended exploitation of Aboriginal culture...

It makes me want to buy a plane ticket to England (or Australia or wherever the ad wizards who came up with this concept are hiding) and knife their collective faces.

Slowly.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
23:52 / 25.05.07
And even, without all that, there's the "killing animals in the name of light entertainment" thing.

You're right. This (or "this, as it appears to be from that article"- sorry, I'm sure it's accurate, but I no longer believe ANYTHING written about a show before it starts) is several shades of wrong.
 
 
Liger Null
00:35 / 26.05.07
Agreed. While I personally don't believe that killing animals for food is immoral per se, I think that Western culture puts entirely too much emphasis on animal-derived foods.

If the producers were sincere about wanting to teach young people good eating habits, wouldn't it be better to put them on an organic farm? There kids could grow and cook their own veggies and fruit while getting exercise. They could learn meaningful skills (such as gardening, meal preparation, and environmental responsibility) that they could easily take home with them.

But I guess that's just not "Fear Factor" enough.
 
 
This Sunday
00:40 / 26.05.07
I think I have a different relationship to plants and killing them, than some people, but that aside... there's nothing not-offensive in this thing if it goes off like the article leads on to envision. From the fat=laughs to the cultural appropriation and exploitation, to the whole inanity of the thing, it's just offensive. Jenny O'Dea seems to be the one reasonable thing included, and she might be understating the psychological impact, there.
 
 
Liger Null
00:44 / 26.05.07
I think I have a different relationship to plants and killing them, than some people, but that aside...

That statement intrigues me, could you elaborate?
 
 
This Sunday
00:53 / 26.05.07
A brief interruption of the PSA explicatory type:

Culturally, Tsalagi/Cherokee tend to put a lot of emphasis on plants as living, so it doesn't really feel different to me to kill or mutilate plants than it does to do so to animals, in a lot of ways. Singularly, as myself, I can't get around that, either. The only real difference would be the lack/presence of screaming, but I try to avoid causing pain killing an animal, and try to be as respectful of something losing something for me on either front. Corn or strawberries are alive, after all, and it may be silly deeprooted animism, but I can't let myself not feel that - and the resultant twinge of guilt/recognition - that I also feel butchering a rabbit or sitting down to a TV dinner with a nondescript BBQ meat patty.

I now return you to your regularly scheduled program already in progress.
 
 
Liger Null
01:24 / 26.05.07
You might be interested in the work of Dr. Jagdish Chandra Bose.

I'll stop rotting my thread now.
 
  
Add Your Reply