BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Edward Whittemore

 
 
Dusto
13:51 / 23.05.07
I just finished The Sinai Tapestry, which is the first book in The Jerusalem Quartet (published in 1977), and it's pretty great stuff. I didn't know much about Whittemore going in, except that Jeff VanderMeer cites him as one of his three favorite writers (along with Nabokov and Angela Carter), but I'm now committed to reading the entire Quartet. Oh, I did read his first novel, Quin's Shanghai Circus, which is good, but I think The Sinai Tapestry is much better,

This book actually covers some of the same ground as Against the Day, focusing mainly on the the late Victorian period and climaxing around 1922, though the scope is narrower, limited mostly to the Middle East. Also, a sordid affair that would take up a chapter for Pynchon generally takes up a couple pages for Whittemore. The main comparison between the two would have to be in humor and subject matter. Stylistically I'd say Whittemore is closer to Vonnegut, though.

It's a complex plot with many eccentric and compelling characters, such as Haj Haroun, a 3,000 year old resident of Jerusalem dedicated to protecting the city despite his senility, or Strongbow, a seven foot tall English lord who rejects the aristocracy, becomes a holy man in the Middle East, writes a sexual encyclopedia, and is comes to secretly own the Ottoman Empire. He's more than a little "mythic," and by the end you have to wonder whether what you've been told about him is just the exaggerated stories that the more modern characters have heard about him.

The main plot revolves around a book that may be the oldest "Bible" in the world, although it reveals everything anyone thinks about religion to be false, but in some ways this is just a MacGuffin to get at the history of the conflicts in this part of the world. A lot hinges on the Turkish genocide of Armenians, for example. Whittemore was apparently a CIA agent in the 50's and 60's and worked in Jerusalem. Really interesting stuff.

I understand that the three other books of the Quartet aren't "sequels" in the strictest sense, but rather tell the story of minor characters and seemingly incidental plot points from the previous books, changing everything we once thought we knew about what was going on. In any case, I tracked them all down used on the internet and am about to get started on the second. Anybody else ever hear of this guy?
 
 
buttergun
20:44 / 23.05.07
I'd never heard of this author. Thanks a lot for recommending his work -- sounds like it would be something right up my alley.
 
 
buttergun
21:25 / 29.06.07
Ok, so I have read Sinai Tapestry and am halfway through Jerusalem Poker. I also was lucky enough to buy copies of each of the books -- and of course I got the Avon mass market paperbacks for Sinai Tapestry and Jerusalem Poker, because I'm a sucker for lurid seventies cover artwork.

I enjoyed Sinai, but wanted to enjoy it more. The writing was a bit uneven at times, and Strongbow was a great character who disappeared too soon.

However, Jerusalem Poker I think is much better. Cairo Martyr is a great character, and the early sequence with him in the hidden mummy tomb is straight out of Pynchon -- that is, Pynchon at his best.

I'm making this the summer of Whittemore, and plan to read all 4 books before the season is out. It's a shame these novels are out of print. Even the 2002 reissues -- poorly designed as they were (they looked like products of a vanity press!) -- are out of print and outrageously expensive.
 
 
Dusto
02:50 / 03.07.07
Yeah, he's a bit uneven, I suppose, but even when he's off, he's still really up my alley in a way that most authors aren't. I haven't read the fourth book, yet, but so far the second is my favorite. They seem to get a bit less fantastic as they go on, but then that seems purposeful. In any case, a welcome discovery.
 
 
Mark Parsons
16:11 / 08.07.07
the reprinted quintet have been on my shelf for years. may read them when i wrap up John Crowley's Aegypt Quartet, which also sat about for many years until this month...
 
 
Dusto
16:57 / 08.07.07
How are the Crowley books? All I've read by him is a single short story (which was really good) about time travel and the British Empire. I read that for a grad level class on History and Fiction, and he actually came to sit in on the class while we were discussing it, which was cool. I'm thinking of reading Little Big, but may check out Aegypt instead.
 
  
Add Your Reply