BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Fiction or non-fiction?

 
 
jmw
15:04 / 29.04.07
What do you read more often? Fiction or non-fiction?

Literary fiction, genre fiction or "trash" fiction? Serious academic non-fiction or biographies and popular non-fiction?

And why do you read more of x rather than y?
 
 
matthew.
19:11 / 29.04.07
I'd rather read z.
 
 
All Acting Regiment
08:19 / 30.04.07
Interesting question. It's made me realise that I tend to think of the two, despite both being books, as being different things altogether.

Where does poetry and criticism come into this?
 
 
gridley
15:21 / 30.04.07
During periods when I'm trying to write fiction, I mostly read non-fiction. Mostly because I like to research what I'm writing about, but also because I'm a little worried about unconsciously borrowing another novelist's voice.

When I'm not trying to write, I tend to read a mix of modern literary stuff and whatever old sci-fi paperbacks with funky covers I can find in the used bookstores.
 
 
hvatsun
15:24 / 30.04.07
I pretty much tend to read fiction most of the time, aside from art book and essays. I really value the strength of a good story, and because I enjoy it much more than reading non-fiction.
 
 
sleazenation
21:14 / 30.04.07
I'm not sure what would fit into the categories of Serious academic non-fiction or biographies and popular non-fiction?

How popular is 'popular'? What is 'serious accademic'? Where does Colin Tudge's emensely readable book on taxonomy fit? Is it too niche to be popular? Is it not serious enough to be accademic?
 
 
This Sunday
21:22 / 30.04.07
I read a lot of narrative/story-based fiction and nonfiction, into which I'll include poetry. I read a lot less technical or academic material. Most of the technical stuff catches me by surprise. I stumble on an interesting book or need a magazine to pass the time in a waiting room. And then there's the stuff I need to research for whatever reason. But story-stuff I consume continually, regardless of format.

Does anybody remember this (Oxford-arranged?) big examination a few years ago, as to what men and women tended to read, in different countries and so on? There was a quiz you could take to help the study, and then, when the study was done, they made a little computer thing to test yourself with. My mom and I took it, and it flipped out genders by tendencies of the English-speaking world. Which explains why most reviews of her work compare her to various nameable men, but never other women, I guess.

Anyhow, most men were supposed to be heavy into nonfiction/technical reading, and most women into fiction/story. Also, women were more likely to consider how a book/writing reflected their own life, while most men quizzed apparently read stuff specifically to disengage it from their lives.
 
  
Add Your Reply