BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Silence is golden: Black Bolt is very angry with you.

 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
05:37 / 08.04.07


The other day while I was at the shop I happened to pick up Silent War. Well: the third issue, with Crystal on the cover looking powerful with that twit of an ex-husband grasping listlessly at her leg. And I looked inside and said, "Shit, Frazer Irving art," and I saw he'd drawn Black Bolt, and I'm a sucker for the Inhumans so I grabbed the other two comics.

First of all: beautiful book. Occasionally, I find Irving's figures a little awkward -- this usually has to do with the characters in question not quite fitting his style and there being a tension going on underneath, but, for the most part it's beautiful. I'm especially taken with his renditions of Black Bolt and Medusa. The Inhumans are evoked and depicted almost as a contrast to witch-folk of Limbo-Towne, and I think I like when Irving's drawing images of exclusive super-species who live away from mankind.

Continuity miasma - it takes us a while to clearly establish that Attilan is on the moon; while this is no big deal for the seasoned nerd with a wikibrain, in terms of structure and clarity of information for a newer reader, it could have been made more explicit earlier. I actually forgot they were on the moon for a while.

And, damn! Hine manages to write the Sentry so I don't want to knock myself out with chloroform when he shows up.

I'm not sure how I feel about the terrorism angle being applied to the Inhumans. I seem to recall there was a tension to the Inhumans series that Jae Lee pencilled, much the same way - incursion a possibility. I think it's more a reaction to terrorism in general showing up in comics - it seems very forced, imposed from on high, and doesn't always seem natural to the text. Black Bolt's actions are a bit dubious but he's clearly being manipulated, and at least we're not kept too heavily in suspense over the fact - we know something's wrong, even if we can't put our fingers on what, exactly. Beyond Maximus.

I'm beginning to wonder if Luna Maximoff grows up to go back in time under the alias "Layla Miller." Layla hates Pietro and coaches in it terms that might apply to an angry daughter. Hine manages to get Crystal's voice to sound quite natural as narrator even with the goofiness of the time travel stemming from Pietro's new powers.

And Pietro, well, he's creepy.

I wanted to call bullshit on Luna's abilities and her training session with Karnak, it seemed so explicitly cribbed from Cassandra Cain, or River Tam syndrome, and I'm hoping they develop her character a bit more independently. I'd love if the story ended with her taking off into the streets of Earth to end up with a certain gang of Runaways...

Has anyone else picked this mini up so far? It's shaky, certainly, in terms of characterization, although not on the level of Civil War; there's more of a clear sense that something outside the depicted events so far has been influencing things, and this sensation mashes up against the awkwardness of using terrorism as a concept so forcibly, but it's certainly clicking with my head at the moment.
 
 
Mario
12:27 / 08.04.07
I was going to check it out, but there were signs in the first issue of marital tensions between Blackagar and Medusalith... and I, for one, am SICK & TIRED of stable marriages being sundered for cheap melodrama.

And now, Black Bolt, once described as one of the most feared monarchs on/near Earth... is jobbing to the Hulk.

Meh.
 
 
Triplets
13:54 / 08.04.07
Just to go off-topic for a second, I would love, Love, LOVE a parody comic to be done which took the piss out of modern publishing practices. One issue would be 'Black Storm and Blackest Panther: RECONCILE THEIR DIFFERENCES', issue two would be the Anti Summer Event in SUMMER OF MODERATELY SMALL DISCONTENT where, perhaps, Surfman foils a plot by the Beach Bums in a very, very laidback party adventure. The third issue would be FINITE EMERGENCY! wherein everything steadily goes from bad to worse until it's revealed that it's all a rejected script from G!Js!

Excelsior!

And back to your scheduled thread...
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
16:07 / 08.04.07
Mario: I was going to check it out, but there were signs in the first issue of marital tensions between Blackagar and Medusalith... and I, for one, am SICK & TIRED of stable marriages being sundered for cheap melodrama.

Well, the tension is clearly because one or both(!!) of them are being controlled by something or someone very bad, and I don't think this story is going to end with a Big Old Inhuman Divorce, because they've already covered that with Crystal and Pietro the Big Jerk. The tension here seems more geared toward demonstrating that SOMETHING IS WRONG rather than random out of character behaviour.
 
 
Spyder Todd 2008
18:42 / 08.04.07
I bought the Son of M trade after I saw the page where Black Bolt says "war" and the shit hits ze fan. I found it to be a little disjointed, but a fairly enjoyable read, and the concept was certainly interesting, so when Silent War started I hopped on to see where it went.

Over all, I've enjoyed Silent War so far, especially this last issue (though I'm sure that comes from me greatly enjoying what's going on over in X-Factor right now). Although I like Irving's artwork, at times it feels out of place to me with regards to the content of the story. But it is very pretty.
And there seems no pleasant way to resolve all this, which is a good thing, I think. I don't believe there's going to be some spit-polish way to make everyone love the Inhumans again, but the Inhumans are clearly the ones who have been wronged here. It's an interesting story, and I like it.
 
 
Mark Parsons
19:00 / 08.04.07
I though Irving's art looked a little rushed in issue three (1 & 2 were spectacular). Also, I was not as wowed by the story as I was in prior issues. Not sure if this one has jumped the shark for me, although I'm sure I'll stick till the end. I'd love to see more INHUMANS minis or an ongoing, although without Civil-Silent-Dissassembled-Massacre-Initiative-War ties.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
20:08 / 09.04.07
Furioso:

I'd love to see more INHUMANS minis or an ongoing, although without Civil-Silent-Dissassembled-Massacre-Initiative-War ties.

Typically, when the Inhumans are treated as the focus of a story they're presented as being in conflict with the outside world, or with Earth. Which is a natural theme to take with them, being an elitist and moderately xenophobic society cut off from the majority of humanity - enclosed by the walls of Attilan because they were originally a Kree experiment. The Jenkins/Lee series took this tack, and Silent War is following suit but reversing it so that the Inhumans are "invading" Earth as a result of precious terrigen crystals being stolen.

The problem is, well, this isn't the only way to deal with the Inhumans and Marvel's getting dangerously close to rendering that particular plot type inert through overuse.

I'd like to see them do an opposite take. Typically, the Inhumans are part of the Fantastic Four extended family but would make a lot of sense when connected to the X-Men - I would imagine that a civilization based upon mutation (artificial though it was, initially) would hold a lot of interest from Xavier with his overtures of Mutant Utopia; why wouldn't he send an ambassador into Attilan to make contact, establish diplomatic ties, and form the basis for blueprints in the direction of the X-Utopia? Particularly, I'd look at terrigenesis as what it is: initial mutation manifestation structured and mythologized into a ritual, something which could be used to further bind the human mutant population more closely together.

...which is part of the reason that Mark Millar (oddly) did a good job when he tackled the Inhumans in the Ultimate Fantastic Four story; it centred around the ritual of terrigenesis that was also explored in the Jenkins/Lee mini near the beginning -- sure, it's still essentially a reaction to the FF's incursion but explored more of Attlian's backdrop and rituals.
 
 
Mark Parsons
07:15 / 10.04.07
I did not mean to harsh on SILENT WAR's themes of conflict, but rather the whole CIVIL WAR gestault-thingie, of which I am a tad weary.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
13:34 / 10.04.07
I know, just having some random thoughts about the Inhumans. Don't mind me.
 
 
Mark Parsons
20:23 / 10.04.07
Questions to papers and all:

How was the second mini, drawn by Ladronn, IIRC?

How were the old solo IHUMANS Marvel tales, from b4 their breif 1970s series? And how was that series? Masterworkable, maybe?
 
  
Add Your Reply