BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Critique of poetry.

 
 
Dutch
02:05 / 15.03.07
Well, I think I finally got up the courage and bloody thumbs to post my first thread.

Here's a poem I've written a year ago, I've rewritten it several times, but I'm not sure if it's a complete failure or pretty good.

The first and the final:

She was the first, she became through dark a being

Where there was nothing her nothingness drifted
forever it seemed, although she never was before her time.
When the first dawn graced her and life finally faced her
thoughts came to flesh and bone but no breath yet was taken.
Wonder filled her senses and her mind,
her eyes still could not peer beyond what she owned.
Was she to remain alone, to hurt in all of reality
in nothing extended yet beyond herself?

She thought upon her existence
and found it impossible she'd come to be
"Something should be here", she pondered,
"I should not be alone"

There was nothing yet for her to call home
but the body she inhabited
Then a thought at first came wandering alone:
"What are the words for creation?"

He would be the final, he would become dark through being

Wherever there was anything, he had drifted
forever it seemed, he had existed through space and time
When the stars were born, and life tore itself from ashes
thought came to many creatures, even worlds; all were now taken
Wonder no longer filled his senses and his mind
his eyes had seen everything too long ago
Was to be so, the end of hurt and reality
nothing to remain extended, not even himself

He thought upon the last of existence
and found it peaceful that he was no longer to be
"Nothing should be here", he pondered,
"I should not be alone"

There was nothing left for him to call home
but the body he inhabited
Then a thought at last came wandering alone:
"What are the words for salvation?"

...


I'm wondering if some of the barbelithers could critique it for me, in terms of rhythm, writing style, value of content, etc. Tell me if it's good or just plain rubbish, because I need to know what the value of my writing is.
 
 
All Acting Regiment
14:52 / 21.03.07
Well, no poem is plain rubbish. There's definitely some worth here - but before I commit myself, maybe you could take us through the poem and tell us about it?
 
 
power vacuums & pure moments
12:45 / 23.03.07
I like this alot. Its like the thoughts of Consciousness in a pantheistic sense, between 'first' and 'final' is the history of the universe, dualistic chaos&pain between monads, the experiment comes to the end of a cycle and back on itself.

Could well be entirely projecting my own interpration, but i definately got something from it.

Im not sure about the phrasing of the very first line, but I cant see any other way you could put it and retain the symmetry with the 'He was the final' bit. Other than that the style and rhythm are fine, the concept takes the centre stage but it works well.
 
 
All Acting Regiment
13:40 / 25.03.07
I think that's a good assessment of the poem's good parts. If you're going to write more, and I think you should, can I also reccomend (in a non-snarky way, it's something I found helpful) Ezra Pound's 'A Few Don'ts'
 
 
Dutch
17:08 / 25.03.07
thank you power vaccuum, you managed to write in a few sentences mainly the gist of what took me an entire page yesterday, trying to clarify what was it that moved me and inspired me at the time. I was studying philosophy at the time, and the question; "why is there something, rather than nothing?" was a big one in my mind.

I tried to use human concepts, images and relations to try and describe what is basically beyond our experience ; the beginning and the end of being. I thought we knew neither of the two up close and personal, since we are per definition "being", not before or after. Therefore; the female as being the creative force, and male the destructive force. Although stereotypical, I couldn't find a better way to try and work the thoughts on creation and the end of existance into a poem.

The problem was probably, I might have been telling too much, and not showing enough. Because the concepts seemed so distant and abstract, it always struck me as somewhat lacking in depth/colour/atmosphere, did you notice that as well?
 
  
Add Your Reply