BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The College Novel

 
 
--
03:57 / 28.12.06
I often think of my years spent at college as some of the best in my life. I've always had a love for the typical American college campus, because there are always certain buildings that tend to crop up no matter what college you go to, such as dorms, some sort of dining hall/cafeteria, a stadium/gym, a student union, and so on (in this way they are much like spaceships, which also share many of the same features no matter what book/movie they appear in: A bridge, cargo bays, ship docks, and so forth). It is no surprise, then, that I'm a huge fan of the "college novel". Seeing as I'm writing such a book at the moment, my interest in this genre is much more intense then usual, and I find myself seeking other novels that fall into this genre. One of the main criticisms I've seen directed to the college novel is that there are often too many characters, plots that tend to ramble (if there are even plots at all), and so on. But I actually find these qualities quite endearing.

The first college novel I ever read was "The Rules of Attraction", by one of my favorite writers, Bret Easton Ellis. I liked the aimlessness of it, how there wasn't really a story... you could just chill out with the characters in their dorm rooms, hang out with them at parties, and so on (I also liked how the book had it's own soundtrack and musical cues, something that too few novels do IMO). Camden College, of course, is based on Ellis' alma mater, Bennington, which also inspired Hampden college in Donna Tartt's "The Secret History", which was the second college book I read, a book that follows more of a traditional storyline that happens to be set in a college (a very enjoyable book also).

Right now I'm reading Neal Stephenson's "The Big U", which was the author's first published novel. It appears that he's unhappy with it and would have liked it to remain out of print, but when people were spending lots of money on it on eBay he agreed to have it republished. I don't know why he seems to hate it so much, as I think it's one of the best things I've read in awhile now (and the only book by Stephenson I've been able to actually read without getting bored). Even though it's set on a college campus the book has a strong science fiction element to it, and it really is a total information overload. I also adore the location of the book, a fictional place called the American Megauniversity... Six stories tall, plus three floors underground and an elaborate sewer system, and on top of the roof, eight twenty-five story towers to house all of the students. This place sounds like one of the coolest colleges that was never built. Had it existed in real life, I definetly would have gone there... well, either there or Camden.

I guess I'm looking for more novels that fit into the college genre. Any suggestions? I can't help but notice that the three examples I listed are all set in the 1980's and (with the exception of "The Secret History") published in the 1980's. Is the genre not as big as it used to be or something? Also, anyone else here share my infatuation with this genre, and, if so, why?
 
 
ibis the being
12:29 / 28.12.06
If you haven't read them, how about DFW's Infinite Jest and Curtis Sittenfeld's Prep? They're both set in high school rather than college, but they're "campus" novels and I think have a lot of the elements you're after in them.

I think the appeal of the setting (not sure it's a genre exactly) is familiarity... I went to a college in Vermont that closely resembled Bennington itself, so the setting of Rules/History/Prep was quite alive for me.
 
 
calgodot
15:11 / 28.12.06
I guess I'm looking for more novels that fit into the college genre. Any suggestions?

My favorite in that genre: Been Down So Long It Looks Like Up To Me, by Richard Fariña, who is perhaps best known as a folk singer-songwriter (married to Mimi Baez, Joan's sister) who hung out with Dylan and Greenwich Village bunch. Fariña was also the Cornell college pal of Thomas Pynchon (who dedicated Gravity's Rainbow to his dead friend). Fariña's novel is set during the 1950s, at a Cornell which was conservative and thus resistant if not horrified by the acts of the protagonist, Gnossos Pappadopoulis, who is for my money one of the most unforgettable raconteurs in literature.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
17:45 / 02.01.07
Chip Kidd's The Cheese Monkeys was okay, although I think I secretly enjoyed the design that Kidd used for the book rather than the story itself - it felt a little by-the-numbers for the College Novel Genre. I tend to walk away from the majority of the genre feeling like I've just read a rehash of Catcher in the Rye - anyone have any recommendations for College Novels that break that mode?
 
 
Dusto
17:37 / 03.01.07
Giles Goat Boy, by John Barth.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
23:20 / 03.01.07
Track down a copy of 'Highlights Of The Off-Season' by Peter J Smith, if you can. It's not so much a novel about college in the US as the year off before, and I've no idea how accurate it is, but the despairing, doomed in his own mind, proto-goth eighteen year old narrator who moves around aimlessly between well-appointed houses in LA, New York and Cape Cod is pretty much a classic comic study.

I'm going to stick my neck out here and say that it's as good as 'A Confederacy Of Dunces.'
 
 
van dyke
21:50 / 09.01.07
Suggestion: I Am Charlotte Simmons by Tom Wolfe
The differences between academic and sporting achievement and how college girls relate. One of those novels which resonates with whatever you bring to it. In short, it's excellent at more than one level.
 
 
van dyke
21:55 / 09.01.07
Damn! That last its should have an apostrophe in it.
 
 
matthew.
01:11 / 10.01.07
The fucking! The boys! The girls! The language! Shocking!

Tom Wolfe unfortunately writes the flatest characters on the planet.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
09:20 / 10.01.07
Well yeah, but isn't the flatness of the characters sort of the point? Going through 'I Am ...' I sort of felt that Wolfe had finally found a subject that was actually worthy of his lofty, mean-sprited, patrician disdain. In a way that the hippies, and the yuppies, even, really weren't.

The plastered, abusive frat boys (presumably drawn at least vaguely from life, seeing as this is what Tom does,) seem like the kind of characters he's been looking for all his life (privileged, with no redeeming features whatsoever) in his ongoing efforts to be this or that generation's J Swift.

Ok it's a potboiler, but it's also far and away the best thing he's written, in my humble. A lot of it stays with you a long time after - the miserable, almost forensic detail in the scene where Charlotte finally 'gives it up' (which I will not revisit here, except to remind everyone who's read it that 'Hoyt had to knock the dust off') stands out, for example - and I do think that as a vision of college in the US as a form of Hell, it'd be quite hard to beat. The sense of seething, underlying despair reminds a bit of 'Middlemarch.'

Basically, the colleges in 'The Rules Of Attraction' or 'The Secret History' sound like fun, but there are consequences, whereas in Wolfe's place it doesn't, and there aren't.

As someone who's never going anywhere near an Ivy League college in the States after reading this, even if I was invited, I respect Wolfe for his (possibly unfounded) brutal honesty.
 
 
Phex: Dorset Doom
15:32 / 10.01.07
(side note: The scene in Charlotte Simmons which we shall not revisit won the Bad Sex in Fiction award. A film is being made and will be released in 2007)
 
 
Dusto
16:01 / 10.01.07
I haven't actually read most of Charlotte Simmons, just a few choice scenes, but from what I have read and from all I've heard about it, it doesn't seem so much like "brutal honesty" as it does a distortion of the truth through highly selective use of detail. It's more like a worst case scenario. I've known girls who went to Ivy League schools whose experience didn't match with the book in the slightest. My own U.S. collegiate experience at Berkeley (admittedly, a totally different sort of environment than the Ivy Leagues) left me with the impression that while there is definitely a good deal of stupidity and reprehensible action to be found among frat boys, the majority of them are actually normal, decent people. I wasn't in a frat myself, of course, so perhaps I didn't see all that went on behind closed doors, but it just seems to me that you could make any environment look like hell by focusing only on the most extreme negative aspects of it, which is my impression of what Wolfe has done.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
17:52 / 10.01.07
Isn't that a bit like saying that Merrill Lynch is a good firm to work for, and that you shouldn't be put off by 'American Psycho'?

(To be clear though, 'American Psycho' is the better novel, by a stretch.)

I'm perhaps a bit guilty of bigging up 'I Am ...' too much.
 
 
Dusto
18:03 / 10.01.07
Yeah, I probably shouldn't be criticizing since I haven't actually read the book, but I just recall the Slate book club discussion and the reviews I read, and even the people who liked it seemed to fault it for oversimplifying and relying on "types" rather than realistic characters. I don't know. My impression of it just seems like Tom Wolfe being crotchety and saying "Can you believe what kids are up to these days?" when he doesn't have a very clear idea. I mean, I teach at (and attend on the graduate level) Indiana University, which has the biggest frat/sorority population of any U.S. university, has an avid basketball following, etc. but my impression of my students is much closer to dumb college comedies like Van Wilder than it is to what I know of "I Am..." Which, admittedly, is almost all second hand, so maybe I'm wrong.
 
 
--
15:45 / 25.01.07
Well, I don't know about what colleges Wolfe went through but my only college experience was great. Though I went to a pretty low-key college that had very little frat boys.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
01:38 / 26.01.07
No looking back though, Sypha.

No looking back ...
 
 
delacroix
09:48 / 26.01.07
_As She Climbed Across the Table_, by Lethem; it reminded me very much of UC Santa Cruz, what with the hysterical war between the social and natural sciences causing real human problems in order to prove completely trivial points.
 
 
Dusto
18:53 / 26.01.07
Oh yeah, As She Climbed Across the Table is great. I'm reading The End of Mr. Y, by Scarlett Thomas right now, and it sort of reminds me of that one, actually.
 
 
semioticrobotic
01:11 / 03.06.07
I'll add Special Topics in Calamity Physics to the mix. Just finished it and found it astounding. Form (it contains rather snarky in-text citations and a Final Exam) and content (it's the story of a transient pair -- precoscious daughter and heady father, a poli-sci adjunct -- whose travels across the country produce a surprisingly shocking mystery) make it a fine example of the genre.
 
  
Add Your Reply