BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Alan Moore and Promethea

 
 
archim3des
12:52 / 26.12.06
One of my intitial contacts with Magick, before i even started reading about Chaos Magick and Magick as it exists today, was john Constantine. Since that really impressionable age where I venerated John Constantine as the virtual archetype of the modern magician, ( and began smoking, mto my bad luck), and have held a certain love for the comic book magician. From Doctor Strange to Zatanna, to Timothy Hunter of The Books of Magick, and King Mob and his rabble of Invisibles, I've idolized them all.

About a year and half ago, coinciding with what I consider my serious practice of magick I read a wonderful story called Promethea, by the ingenious Alan Moore. The story is about a young woman, named Sophia Bangs, who lives in a contemporary/near-future techno-dystopia, set in a mythical pseudo-american city. The protagonist Sophia begins researching a mythical heroine named Promethea, who turns out to by much more than a Myth. Promethea seems to represent, in her own continuum, Imagination itself, and the creative capacities of the human mind, and as Moore jokes on the comic, "If she didn't exist we would have to create her.

Moore takes the main character through a full magic initiation over the 4 years of the run of the comic, from her initial training with the four base elements of ritual magick, to fully ascending the Qabalistic Tree of Life, and meeting the various gods and goddesses who dwell there. She also receives a pretty well rounded and relatively scandalous training in Tantra. Aleister Crowley and Austin Osman Spare all play lead or supporting titles throughout the entire series.

The Last trade paperback in the series is probably one of the best single pieces of literature I've ever read. In that story, Moore seems to use both his full training as author and magician to actually cause the pages themselves to be possessed by Promethea. She springs to life on the page, as she brings the Apocolypse to the world, and you realize that's not that bad.

Anyone a fan of the series?
 
 
calgodot
13:55 / 26.12.06
I, too, carry an obsession with magic-themed comics. My favorite as a teen was Dr. Strange - I grew up to become a bit of a Constantine myself: rail thin body, habitual smoking, shabby overcoat, rampant cynicism, air of doom... (Now that I think of it, it seems I was a Warren Ellis character for about ten years....) Also: womanizing, late nights at library studying occult tomes, demon-hunting, and fighting for the balance. (Aaah, the good ole days....)

Anyone a fan of the [Promethea] series?

Me, and a huge fan at that. Along with The Invisibles, it's the series I most evangelize to people - non-comics readers as well as comics fans. I also keep a statue of Promethea (goddess of imagination!) on my writing desk.

My favorite single issue in the series is the Tarot segment: the rhymes of the caduceus snakes are a pretty good memetic for learning the Major Arcana, and are nice to throw into a reading for some "color." The kabala issues are also outstanding lessons on the various spheres, while also telling a good story. (I would refer to issue numbers, but I'm in the midst of moving and my comics are boxed away! )

The final issues are indeed some of the best writing done for comics. Character resolutions, as well as the tone of the apocalypse, were all very surprisingly upbeat. I expected at least one person to "go evil," but was happy to see that even the FBI agents were transformed by their encounter with the daimonic.

And the art - WOW! J.H. Williams became my favorite artist after that series. I now pick up every damn thing he does, and am awaiting the chance to own some of his originals. A friend of mine has the two-page Moebius strip scene, which almost causes my heart to burst with envy. That is one of the most clever two-page splashes ever done - you can begin reading that conversation from anywhere on that loop, and it is just as coherent (or incoherent) as any other starting point.

If the series went "wrong" for me it was when Stacia becomes the channel for Grace's Promethea. The whole sturm und drang of the conflict (Stacia's latent lesbianism, Grace's psychopathy, Sophie's temerity) seemed like something that would show up in the pages of The Avengers. Maybe Moore had a magic lesson in there for us - if so I don't perceive it. And the idea that the new world born from the apocalypse won't need a protector? Well, the final panel gives us a bit of a cliffhanger on that.

I also love reading those letters, especially the people who complain about how "philosophical" the comic becomes and how much Moore "lectures" the reader. Moore's reply to that pretty much sums it up for me: there are a thousand comics without a philosophical lecture in them, and one that contains said philosophical stuff. Why should that one comic be a problem?
 
 
Jack Fear
13:59 / 26.12.06
Well, yeah—but there is a section of the board devoted to comic books; and there are many, many Promethea threads already in existence there, including issue-by-issue discussions of breathtaking erudition. Get thee hence, and happy hunting.
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
12:43 / 28.12.06
Which is not to say the conversation in this thread has to stop. I'll move it to the comics forum and we'll pick it up there.
 
 
calgodot
14:38 / 28.12.06
Thanks for the fair thread move, Our Lady.

(And as to the tip, Jack: I'm looking at those threads, and they are all quite specific. There doesn't appear to be a general Promethea thread - you know, one where we can discuss the series in total, its place in the world of comics as well as magick (and comics about magic), which is I think the intent of this thread.)

One thing that stands out in Promethea, when compared to the two other "big" magick-oriented titles (Dr. Strange and The Invisibles) is that Promethea does very little magick as we know it. She casts few spells, calls upon no powers, doesn't even whip out a sigil. She goes to Jack Faust for "magical instruction" but gets little more than a few bits of advice, some basic introductory lessons (although more may have occurred off-panel).

Promethea's power seems situated in either her status as a demi-goddess or her caduceus (the demons seem more afraid of the staff than the being - the staff is a symbol of great power). Her magick appears to be a force that results from her will - she simply thinks of a "magical act" and it happens. The post-Crowley understanding of magick is that it is an act of will and not the result of magical formulae.

The most obvious spell-work in Promethea is the incantation (which varies) used by Sophie to become Promethea - or transform others into Promethea. These "spells" take the form of poems, which are at first very awkward but later gain more eloquence. This suggests to me the proposition put forth by Robert Graves and many others - that our arts began as magic. Incantations become poems. Paintings on cave walls eventually transfer to other mediums (and hang on museum walls).

In The Invisibles, Grant Morrison actually demonstrates a few magical techniques - Mad Tom's lessons are very good, and various sigils and spells are concocted for us. (Grant even provides a sigil lesson in one editorial.) Doctor Strange of course calls upon various powers for his magic - while his methods are clearly based on traditional ceremonial magic, the powers invoked and spells spoke are invented for the comic (and sometimes as silly as something you might find in Simon's Neconomicon. Though Promethea is clearly informed by Moore's acquaintance with and practices in "high magick," there's not much in the way of recipes for the curious.

However, as I said above, the series contains one of the best introductions to the Major Arcana ever written (issue #12). Several issues (nos. 14-23) are utilized for lectures on the various spheres of the kabala, with a little planetary magick added for flavor. Without sacrificing the pace of his adventure (many would no doubt argue with me on this point), Moore provides good lessons on two of the more popular and esoteric "schools" of magick. (Aside: would it be proper to refer to Tarot and Kabala as "schools?")

I wasn't reading The Invisibles or Promethea while they were being published. Instead I got to experience them as whole works, rather than waiting for each issue. (The waiting was the hardest part w/r/t Promethea, I'm told.) Each time I return to them, I am impressed with the breadth of each writer's imagination and knowledge. These are the titles (along with Transmetropolitan) which restored my love for the form & my respect for its potential, and engendered my belief that sequential art is perhaps the ultimate medium for storytellers. Many presume cinema to be the pinnacle of narrative expression - and perhaps someday, as the tools of cinema are more and more democratized, it will reach its place as the ultimate mode of narrative expression. But for now, of the two mediums, only in comics is the storyteller's imagination unrestrained by budgets or the limits of technology.
 
 
doctorbeck
14:45 / 28.12.06
am very pleased to see a thread for the whole of this series myself, thankyou.

i reread this recently, just a few months after the birth of my first daughter and had a completely different take on it, not surprising really but it seemed to me all about fatherhood, the desire to protect but also give your child something to take out into the world and change it in a way you would have liked to given the breaks, the reunions between stacy and her father and promethea and hers seemed massively poignant and the whole magic thing just fell into the background, seemed more like a metaphor for the hopes we have for our kids and the tools we try to give them to realise those hopes

i also read it after smoking some really good weed and decided to read it without looking at the words, just visually, got through the second trade that way anyhow and really enjoyed the time to just look at the richness of the panels and storytelling going on, brilliant.
 
 
PatrickMM
16:41 / 30.12.06
I'd agree that Promethea is the best comic series since The Invisibles, and probably the best thing Moore has ever done. I found the 'lecture' stuff fascinating, and the final few issues are just fantastic.

JH's art is the best ever done in comics, and also just fantastic on its own merit as a piece of visual composition. The intricate symmetry of every page and the shifting styles are unbelievable. Even if you didn't dig what Moore was saying, the Kaballah issues are essential just for what Williams was doing with the images.
 
 
matthew.
21:16 / 30.12.06
I love how in issue 32, everything ties up in this celebratory, fun and easy to read monologue from Promethea. Pretty much the entire series summed up in those pages. And I read it in trade form, so it was like, okay. But then I bought the single issue, carefully took it apart and put all the papers on the ground. Beautiful, just beautiful. I love you, Promethea.
 
 
Quantum
22:23 / 30.12.06
The poster from the last issue is great, but which side do you display? I'm going to flip mine to blue this year. It's time.
 
 
calgodot
16:58 / 01.01.07
The poster from the last issue is great...

Did you put the poster together yourself, or were you one of the lucky ones who acquired a fabricated poster?

I bought several copies of the final issues, planning to assemble the poster. But I hit a big wall when I began trying to select the proper materials to attach the pages to one another. Tape? Ugh. Glue? Messy. Staples? Puh-lease! I'd be interested to know (or see,if you have pics) how you managed to put the whole thing together.

The final issue is one of the most strikingly original comic books ever produced. It is a complete work of it in and of itself, and a stunning complement to the series. Williams' art had reached glorious heights throughout the series; here he tops himself, doing things with a page and book that wouldn't seem possible if the evidence wasn't right there in your hands.

No. 32 is not essential to one's comprehension and enjoyment of the series. In fact, a number of people find it unintelligible (reading it gave one friend of mine a headache!). Rather, the final issue is a sort of gift to the dedicated Promethea reader and comics, those for whom a lack of panels and a lecture are treats rather than torments.

Often I amuse myself with the idea of what comics will be studied at university in, say, a generation or two (when the idea of "comics as art" or "serious literature" will be accepted across academia). Promethea is without a doubt a series which would not only bear great scrutiny under traditional academic study and discourse, but would likely, as with most great works, continue to unfold and reveal itself in a myriad of ways.
 
 
matthew.
18:08 / 01.01.07
It's funny. That's what I think a lot of people missed out on when it was running. It's strikingly humourous. There's lots of jokes, and the characters are funny. It's almost like Moore purposefully chose to make another work about comics that isn't so obviously depressing like Watchmen. Promethea is a celebration.
 
 
Aertho
14:53 / 03.01.07
Well, I for one never compared Watchmen to Promethea. But...

Watchmen seemed as though Moore was asking "what is Good?" Like the whore scene right on through to Ozymandias. Superheroes as examined as an additive to "real life". Made you question their worth and their choices.

Promethea, for all its religious and spiritual hangers, answered that question. From Barb and little Promethea's father to Jack in the penultimate issue. And made the reader realize what superheroes ARE in any life.
 
 
NewMyth
04:37 / 05.01.07
Yes, Promethea is truly magical.

I’ve gone back and bought some extra copies of issue 32 to turn people on to, if I think their minds can handle it. (No, I won’t be handing them out on street corners.)

As an adjunct to the Promethea series, there are a couple related things out there by Mr. Moore. His “Snakes & Ladders” spoken word performance piece resonates with much of Promethea’s apocalyptic final issues.

Eddie Campbell has done an illustrated version in comic book form that is tres cool. (eddiecampbellcomics.com and topshelfcomix.com) I first came across it in a Virgin Megastore! And their “The Birth Caul” is great, too.

And perhaps even Moore amazing is the CD of “Snakes and Ladders” with Moore reading -- really performing -- with mood music by Tim Perkins. Issued by, RE: or, Re:Play (Hard to tell the name, Google it, and/or check eBay.)

Also, there's a very cool -- and lengthy -- interview with Moore, “Magic Is Afoot: Comics Author Alan Moore on the Arts and the Occult.” An imposing photo of his hirsuteness fills the cover. This was an issue of Arthur Magazine, issue No. 4, May 2003. A local free(!) weekly in the Southern California area. But I believe back issues are available via arthurmag.com for a nominal price. http://www.arthurmag.com/store/index.php?ID=12

I know he actually does a lot of interviews, but for A LOT of his thoughts related to Promethea, this is the best I've seen.

This exposition by him, as interviewed by Jab Babcock, single-handedly turned me on to magic/the occult/hermeticism. (And last month they ran a long article by Moore on the history of pornography.)

Someone gave a bunch of great Google links above. I remember this guy, eroomnala (Alan Moore backwards,) did a cool online site annotating ever issue of Promethea. I think it’s still there. He was planning to do a “Guide to Promethea” book a la The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, and Sandman Companions, but he seems to have dropped the project; let's check.

I’m not receiving any remuneration for the above recommendations, other than hopefully some good karma.
 
  
Add Your Reply