BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Verdict

 
 
Benny the Ball
08:00 / 13.12.06
Just looking at the Guardian site this morning, i read the following article;

The Verdict

Is this for real?

Does anyone else find this a little distastful?
 
 
Thorn Davis
08:30 / 13.12.06

I'd have to see the programme itself, to judge whether it's distasteful. I don't think it's inevitable. Obviously if the programme's all fast cut 'Tomorrow! On Celebrity gang rape! The victim's topless photo's! Cause a stir in the courtroom!' cut to footage of the victim looking foxy in a suit and crying into her hands, then yeah the programme obviously is going to be grotesquely indefensible. But, that's not really BBC 2's style. I think it looks interesting and as well as providing an insight into the jury process, it could well elevate the public debate surrounding rape. I believe a recent study mentioned in the switchboard forum flagged up attitudes that people found problematic - comments that sleeping with someone unconscious made you only a bit guilty, that kind of thing. A platform like this could address that kind of - uh - intellectual bereavement with the kind of discussion they're presumably looking to engender (judging by the mix of wife beaters and crime victims). Of course it might be ghastly, but it could be worthwhile.
 
 
Benny the Ball
08:47 / 13.12.06
This is true - perhaps a knee jerk reaction - although, the following sentence didn't help matters;

After each programme, viewers will be encouraged to switch to BBC3 where they can watch footage of the jury debating the day's evidence over dinner at the five-star Conrad Hotel in Chelsea, where they stayed after being whisked from Kingston county court in Surrey in a fleet of black Lincoln limousines equipped with champagne chilling in buckets.

drunk celebrities and their insights, always nice...
 
  
Add Your Reply