BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Lady In the Water (Spoilers/post release thread)

 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
 
This Sunday
22:53 / 26.07.06
Again, though, were the fairytales just not scary, or were they poorly told? There are a number of stories in the big old Grimm's or similar collection(s) that properly unnerved me as a kid. 'How the Children Played Butcher', 'The New Mother' and even 'Snow White' had that nailed-in-a-casket-and-down-the-river bit. The princess being impregnated while asleep, in 'Sleeping Beauty'.

To update to films and 'original' stories that are still operating as fairytales... the execution by bird in 'Barbarella' still kinda gets me. The way children are presented/treated in 'Forbidden Zone' even, is frightening and that's out and out farce. Sadism only works if it's actually sad, after all. And I could go on and on for ages about how great 'Utena' was/is - but nobody wants to have to scroll past all that again.

As to Dahl, the early bits of 'James and the Giant Peach', where he's basically put on, disempowered, and hungry all the time? That's scary as a kid, especially if you spent any time poor (and thereby hungry in the seriously-got-no-food way). Actually, Dahl's kids do tend to suffer in ways a lot of children's book protagonists never do. Maybe it's because they haven't got nannies and all... maybe, not. Maybe it was a marketing thing....

We should have a fairytale thread, instead of this, yeah?
 
 
Kali, Queen of Kitteh
13:19 / 27.07.06
There should be a separate fairy-tale thread because this one keeps getting way off topic.
 
 
Mark Parsons
03:03 / 28.07.06
I read a positive review by a writer I admire and went to see it. Was pleasantly surprised (hated the last two MNS movies).

It's a fairy tale, it's sweet, enigmatic, but not especially challenging. The joy is in the unfolding story and the discovery of the supporting cast. MNS has a role, bit I did not recognize him at first. He's good: nothing flashy.

Paul Giamatti's performance is first rate. If for no other reason, check out the movie for that...
 
 
Kali, Queen of Kitteh
18:19 / 28.07.06
More and more Paul Giamatti starts to resemble my ex-boyfriend....

I had no problems with MNS's acting, it was the role in which he chose to cast himself that I had issues with.
 
 
EmberLeo
01:20 / 04.08.06
The magic of the scenes felt like the rituals that children at play make up in the middle of an improvised game and I think, thematically, it is very up front about the need to regress to a childlike state so that wonders and miracles are possible.

I've lost track of who said this, but I agree with it a great deal. And I think that's pretty much why the names "Narf" and "Scrunt", though awkward, don't bother me. They sound like names he let his children make up. That makes sense since he said it was a story originally for his children.
 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
  
Add Your Reply