BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Memory Pills.

 
 
slinky
09:06 / 18.07.06
Memory Pills for the Forgetful

VERSUS

Pill could make painful memories a thing of the past

While I'm all for remembering where I left my wallet, I'm more concerned with the ethical and psychological implications of 'forgetting' an event. After all, memories are what shape us and make us the diverse and fascinating individuals we are today.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
12:14 / 18.07.06
I think it would be a very bad idea. There are all sorts of painful things (break-ups, bereavements, moments of public embarrassment) which at the time I would have given anything to forget. With distance, I'm glad they're there (apart from some of the "public embarrassment" ones).
 
 
gyrus
10:05 / 19.07.06
Interesting bit from the Guardian piece:

"If you reactivate the trauma in somebody who has PTSD and that memory returns back to an [unstable] state, then maybe it means that memory can be manipulated," said Dr Nader.

Sounds like the principle of "re-imprinting" with psychedelics or whatever. Of course in this "manipulated" usually means "integrated", with a conscious attitude of acceptance and re-framing. Here they're talking more mechanically, about "turning it down a bit". I guess that's the overtly mechanical effect of "integrating" a painful memory, that you're less overwhelmed by it. Is there a difference between the processes here, or is the difference just in the description? My feeling is that a purely neurological, mechanical approach won't be as effective in the long term as one that takes the interior psychic experience on board as well. Or, if the mechanical, totally exterior approach is as effective, it'll probably be paid for with longer term psychic losses. As Stoatie says.

Jesus, haven't these people seen Eternal Sunshine?
 
 
Mister Saturn
08:06 / 25.07.06
There's a comic (now a movie) that reminds me strongly of this topic - it's french, called The Carnival of Immortals (or La Foire aux Immortels).

It's a beautifully drawn, erratically written story set in the future. It centres around two people, and one of them is a chalk-skinned, blue-haired woman who goes off the rails when her lover is brutally murdered. She steals her dead lover's pills, red pills for forgetting, yellow for remembering - and she starts to overdose on the red pills after each horrifying event in her life.

I think the idea of having pills on hand to forget or remember is playing die with the devil; as some psychologists said, the human brain is an amazing organ, capable of even protecting the psyche by manifesting "disorders" (multiple personalities).

Some people may not be ready for the torrent of memories a simple pill could bring. And some may not be ready for a part of their life to go missing.

The thought process is very important, as someone grieving goes through a variety of stages to move on and mature mentally. Although, in some extreme cases, I suppose it could be sanctioned, but with counselling.
 
  
Add Your Reply