BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Why am I right handed?

 
 
Ellis
16:07 / 07.09.01
And why are fewer people left handed that right handed?

Is it genetic/ inborn or is it caused by external factors, like watching left/ right handed people on TV (or something... )

Is it a random genetic thing or does the parents "handed-ness" come into it?
 
 
Ethan Hawke
17:35 / 07.09.01
I don't know the answer to your question, but this month in Harper's Index, they had the statistic (this is from memory, so it may be slightly off):

Chance someone born in 1920 is left handed: 1-100.
chance someone born in 1990 is left handed: 1-7.

So, left-handers are increasing in proportion.

(I'll check those numbers when I get home tonight. This also sounds like something they may have been in "Genome" so I'll give a look to the index.).
 
 
nul
17:45 / 07.09.01
11% of Americans and Europeans are left-handed. A study by Gilbert and Wysocki discovered that men (12.6%) are more likely to be left-handed than women (9.9%), whites, black and native Americans are slightly more likely to be left-handed than people of Asian or Hispanic descent.

There are various theories as to why this is, from genetic factors to enviromental reasons. Thus far it's unknown why some people are left-handed and some people are right-handed.
 
 
Spatula Clarke
18:57 / 07.09.01
When did schools stop trying to force children to 'learn' to be right-handed? That's got to have a major influence on the numbers of left-handers in certain generations.
 
 
mondo a-go-go
20:27 / 07.09.01
statistically, i know more left-handed women than men. and i didn't inherit left-handedness from either parents or grandparents...
 
 
..
20:52 / 07.09.01
Is there any connection to handedness and hemispheric dominance in the brain? ie- are right handed people left brain dominant, and are left handed people right brain dominant?
I've always wondered that...

And then there's the question of whether ambidexterity can be learned, and what effect that might have the brain.
 
 
Saint Keggers
01:33 / 08.09.01
From what I've read Aleister Crowley made his students learn to write equally well with both hands. Robert Anton Wilson had said that this was to kick start the oposite hemisphere of the brain which isnt usually accessed as much when writting with the natural hand...Ive also heard that more gay people are left handed than than straight and there is a higher percentage of artist who are left handed than right when compared to other disciplines...odd.
 
 
nul
03:43 / 08.09.01
Statistically, I know more white people than Asian people. I guess that means there are more white people in the world.

Ambidexterity can be learned, if you are inclined to force yourself into a strigent program by which you strengthen the left hand (or right hand, as the case may be). It takes a long while, but it is possible.
 
 
Lionheart
16:11 / 08.09.01
You are right handed because you're inferior.. Southpaws will rule the world!!!
***end of joke***

I've heard that left-handed people are naturally more ambidexterious(sp?) than right-handed people. Being left-handed, I believe that this is true.
 
 
netbanshee
17:34 / 08.09.01
I agree from personal experience with artists being left-handed more often than people of other fields. And it seem that ambidexterity may be more common to left-handers since they're around right handers all the time...a behavior thing? Gleaning from common practices, like say preferences in hand shaking being an influence.

Tried the equal handing thing when in karate cause twirling two clubs is bad-ass and safer when you get the motion down. But never quite got it down...ooff...
 
 
nul
17:50 / 08.09.01
I've broken my right arm three times in my life, and as a result had to learn to use my left hand to some extent or another. Therefore, based solely on my personal opinions and experiences, I conjecture that right-handed people are more likely to achieve ambidexerity than left-handed people.
 
 
Autobot
12:37 / 16.09.01
quote:Originally posted by tiger's mouth:
And then there's the question of whether ambidexterity can be learned, and what effect that might have the brain.


I don't know if this will answer your question but I hope it might shed some light on it. I play drums and for most of my druming career I've been right handed and right legged, exquse the lack of eloquence, it's been a long night:/ Anyway, I have stumbled upon this amazing book from a drummer by the name of Gary Chester. He was mostly a studio musician and was the drummer in many famous recordings like Brown Eyed Girl, Under the Boardwalk, Spanish Harlem and so many more that are all classics. So this book he wrote is called "The New Breed" and there is the sequal called "The New Breed 2" which he had the information compiled in notes but other people finished after he died.

The books teach something which is called independant drumming which is incredibly hard to learn (I find) without someone there to show you what to do. The idea behind it is that most drummers are either right handed or left handed and thats the way they are for life, but with enough practice you start to use all 4 limbs with equal control. It's extremely hard at first and requires so much concentration. Basically you'll have 3 limbs playing a rythm and then your 4th limb plays the melody. I have not come close to mastering this (but i'm working very hard at it), but from everything I have read they say that the limb(s) that were previously your weakest ones will then become your strongest ones. They are easier to work with when it comes to improvisation. So I believe the answer is yes you can become ambidextrous, it just takes alot of work.


Hope that helps
 
 
Autobot
12:42 / 16.09.01
Oh and as to your answer on what effect it has on the brain... I'm not sure about that. I know that if you do become practiced in this independant drumming then creating music becomes so much easier. You gain a freedom which you would never have been able to reach. Imagine a high jumper with some ankle weights, he can still jump, but when he takes them off he can run faster and jump higher.
 
 
Clavis
20:53 / 23.09.01
Here's the deal, so far as I can gather:

Studies of austraulopithecus fossils indicates that the approximate 20%/80% left/right proportion is not a new development. Statistics showing a lower # at, for example, the turn of the century can indeed be attributed to social attempts to discourage left-handedness, for reasons no doubt related to superstition and ignorance.

The social tendencies in all anthropologically-studied cultures to use the right hand for eating, greeting, touching, etc., and using the left hand for poopy and whatnot, are ubiquitous. There is no 50/50 split between cultures that favor the left hand and cultures that favor the right. This indicates something genetic... and it is genetic!

As your brain forms, while you're in the womb, one of the things that is normally, genetically assembled in your brain is handedness, and the part of your brain that would normally control writing is in the left hemisphere -- the half that handles reading, writing, 'rithmatic, and rspeech*. Hence, since it's in the left hemisphere, it is expressed in the half of the body controlled by that hemisphere -- the right half!

Apparently, however, if a certain, relatively common and relatively minor form of brain disruption occurs at a certain point in your fetal development, the section that handles handedness (and some other functions) is damaged, or does not develop properly. Fortunately, the development process is full of backup plans; the handedness is taken over by the right hemisphere -- the imagination, pattern recognition and general creativity half -- and life goes on.

This theory explains why, among other things, left-handedness occurs more often in lunatics, artists and generally creative people -- the creative half of their brain has been given more to do and ends up with a more dominant role than in the usual brain heirarchy. This also ties into the normal function of the brain to make connections between concepts and ideas; a brain that has been through an early trauma, such as the left/right-hand switch, seems more capable of making unique connections -- that is, of having ideas no one has ever had before, or at least combining them in new ways.

DaVinci, Hendrix, Chaplin, Picasso, Paul McCartney, Einstein, Michaelangelo, Benjamin Franklin, W.C. Fields and Bob Dylan come to mind as notable artists (of one form or another) who were southpaws. (Also, presidents Harry Truman, Gerald Ford, Ronald Reagan, George Bush Sr. and Bill Clinton. There may have been others, but because of the old practice of changing handedness, we'll never know!)


Clavis (a southpaw, obviously!)

*Had to make them all "r"-sounds.

[ 23-09-2001: Message edited by: Clavis ]
 
 
..
05:14 / 25.09.01
quote:Originally posted by Autobot:


...they say that the limb(s) that were previously your weakest ones will then become your strongest ones. They are easier to work with when it comes to improvisation. So I believe the answer is yes you can become ambidextrous, it just takes alot of work.



I've had the same experience learning leg ambidexterity, although it hasn't seemed like alot of work to learn (just way too many hours of stoned hacky-sack kicking). I was right leg dominant, but after a few years the left leg became smoother and quicker than the right. And it was a speedy transition (by adding a little martial arts philosophy) from there to where both limbs seem to act on their own accord.

Integrating the use of all four limbs to the point where you can sort of just sit back and watch your body go to work (which it seems to me like the best drummers are doing), would be an amazing feeling methinks.

As for the effects on the brain, I suspect that external integration would at least influence internal integration, if not inevitably cause it. That's the theory that very old and proven systems like yoga and Tai Chi are based on. I started Tai Chi about five months ago now and there are very noticable changes occuring both inside and out. And you should see me kick a hacky-sack now!
 
 
Shortfatdyke
07:32 / 25.09.01
i'm left handed but my identical twin sister is right handed.

a couple of years back i went through a phase of writing backwards. it felt intensely liberating. teachers gave me no end of hassle for writing with the paper the 'wrong way' up.... i am right handed only for certain things (playing cricket, guitar) and it feels 'wrong' throwing darts or playing the drums either way. i've never figured out the twin thing, though.
 
  
Add Your Reply