BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Why do girls periods synchronize?

 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
 
methylsalicylate
11:08 / 07.09.01
It might be worth noting that periods are far more regular now, for most women, than they were in the past - this is thought to be because of dietary improvements.

A more likely scenario is that women's periods are more regular now because of several factors:

1) women in the developed countries get their periods earlier than they used to (this is possibly because of higher caloric and fat intake).

2) women have their first parturition later than they used to, but most significantly,

3) women tend to have fewer children than they used to and breastfeed a shorter time if at all, and pregnancy and breastfeeding interrupt the cycle.

The average lifetime fertility of a woman under pre-modern circumstances is 5 live births. If each of these requires 9 months of pregnancy and 2-3 years of breastfeeding, and she was in menses from age 15 to age 50, that's a shockingly sparse 15 years of menstruation. Which, being a woman of the modern world, I will have attained by age 27 (in two years). With the attendant increased cancer risks that go with these 'advancements.'

All in all, it is extremely unnnatural, from the evolutionary perspective, for a woman to have decades of regular, uninterrupted menses. To be 25 and have had more months of my life with bleeding than without is really quite an odd thought.
 
 
Kit-Cat Club
12:09 / 07.09.01
That's interesting - what do you suppose would have happened to women whose babies were fed by wet-nurses? Would they have had a menstrual lifetime more like ours, or would it make relatively little difference?
 
 
Ronald Thomas Clontle
13:48 / 07.09.01
I just read this thread thinking about how the place where I've been living in now has 8 (sometimes 9) girls living there, and how whenever they decide to synchronize will not be the happiest time in the world for the last remaining boy staying there...
 
 
mondo a-go-go
20:24 / 07.09.01
pff! get over yourself, love.

be ob hand with backrubs and chocolate and kleenex, and you will be the most appreciated and loved man in your town.

you try living with the backache and the headaches and the womb ache and the not sleeping because of pain, and trying not to overdose on painkillers that don't work and the lack of energy and va-va-voom that hits you and makes you feel nauseous and uncomfortable, and the single lone man whining because someone shouted at him...

(hey, i'm suffering right now, so why should i suffer alone? still, it's better than being pregnant)
 
 
Saint Keggers
01:50 / 08.09.01
Haus OF WIllow:
Why do you hope im joking???
 
 
Gypsy Christ
05:07 / 17.09.01
quote:Originally posted by Lionheart:
Maybe we have kids so we can eat them when there's nothing else available. Gives a new whole meaning to the term "baby farm".

It's babylicious!


hmmm.. kinda reminds me of that saying if Olive oil comes from olives were does baby oil come from...hmm...
 
 
Autobot
13:40 / 17.09.01
kooky has go-go power I will give you backrubs anytime you want. my eused to have me sit on her stomach or lie on it cause I was nice and warm I still am last I checked:P
 
 
Chuckling Duck
16:24 / 18.09.01
I had five older sisters. Careful observation of them and my mom leads me to the conclusion that women’s periods synchronize because God hates me.
 
 
mondo a-go-go
16:35 / 18.09.01
quote:Originally posted by Autobot:
kooky has go-go power I will give you backrubs anytime you want.


that's so sweet 'bot.

quote: my eused to have me sit on her stomach or lie on it cause I was nice and warm I still am last I checked:P

err...okaaay...
 
 
Naked Flame
20:13 / 18.09.01
you know, there's one thing you're missing here.

why are you expecting anything remotely to do with sex to make sense?

i don't know why this scnchronisation thing works the way it does but the implications are fascinating. Seems to be a way that women have to connect with women that men don't have any kind of equivalent for.

(ducks hail of rotten tomatoes from lurking gender theorists)

*Do* we have an equivalent? please don't say cars. or war. or comics.
 
 
Mordant Carnival
20:53 / 18.09.01
What I want to know is this:

Is there some kind of Darwinian rationale behind the alternation constipation and diarrhea (spelling?)
 
 
surblimity
18:58 / 19.09.01
quote:Originally posted by Mordant Carnival:
Is there some kind of Darwinian rationale behind the alternation constipation and diarrhea (spelling?)


yes! why the hell is that?!? as far as i know, my uterus has NOTHING to do with my large intenstine, so i can't really see why on earth it happens, what purpose it serves, etc. why don't our mothers warn us or teach us about that? it's one of my least favorite parts of the whole inconvenience.
 
 
Mordant Carnival
19:09 / 19.09.01
A muscular thing? Hell if I know.
 
 
Tom Coates
19:32 / 19.09.01
One reason I can think of is that perhaps period's synchronising is a way of maintaining community bonds between women. I know that sounds ridiculous, but it makes a CERTAIN amount of sense in that it might provide an evolutionary advantage - primitive near-social humans whose periods synchronised might find social living more simple. But that's off the top of my head. Hope that doesn't sound too tacky.

Alternatively of course, the whole thing may be simply about having a rhythm and maintaining it - apparently it syncs with lunar cycles in the abscence of man-made light. That being the case, it might simply be a regulatory mechanism for the optimum cycle.

There are lots of interesting, but not specifically relevant facts here.

Again - man here. Not the slightest idea really.
 
 
Naked Flame
20:14 / 19.09.01
tom! you found the clitoris!

interesting that that site should mention a definite physiological reason (pheremones in sweat.) The question is, has whatever (darwinian) evolutionary purpose this served been surpassed by a kind of social evolution? I.e. the body of mythical and magical thinking that's grown up around menstruation... also thinking here of what implications the various means used to control menstruation have on this.

(tangent- I've been reading 'Collapsing Chaos' by Cohen and Stewart and they've got some really interesting glosses on evolution and the ways in which our basic DNA could express in lots of different ways as our organisms develop. Don't have a useful conclusion to draw from all that but this seems an example of 'reprogramming' the body that I find kinda interesting.)
 
 
Gypsy Christ
12:18 / 20.09.01
this for all you ladys that whanted to put your tampons in a museum...kinda off topic but it has to do with menstration..well the artsy veiw anyways,also provides some cool infromation about syncornizing ..not to mention the "self-Dye's" Designer shirts..OOH! and then theres the Red Spot think of "Are you there god it's me margret" only on crack and packed full of fudgy goodness it's the Good choice
 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
  
Add Your Reply