BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Plausability Test Thread

 
 
All Acting Regiment
22:52 / 20.06.06
Sometimes you have an idea for some sort of creative projecy and you don't know if it'll work. You might waste a lot of time and effort- if only you could've got an opinion first! Well, now you can. That's what this thread's for.

I'd be grateful if anyone could read through the following synopsis and pick out any obvious flaws:

I have a character, active in London in 1938, whose great grandfather laid some sort of legal claim to an island in the East Indies. My character has never been there, having lived in Britain all his life, but wants to go there.

He needs money and a group. He corrals three rich young London men, whose fathers each have plenty of wealth, and (he's a very charismatic/frightening man) press gangs them, using their money to book the passage to the east.

They go by boat from London, down past Spain, through the gap of Gibraltar (is this what it's called?) and across the med to Egypt. They go across land to the Red Sea and then get in another ship bound for the East Indies.

So that's the basic story. In the event they find one island populated by "savages" and see a ritual piercing ceremony, they run in disgust to a "White Island" a la the Pitcairns but find worse things happening there- a burgeoning Fascist state. They return to the "savages" and undergo a sort of baptism by fire, they have to get used to the alien.
 
 
Whisky Priestess
23:22 / 20.06.06
Strait(s) of Gibraltar, I think. Dire ones.
 
 
TeN
01:44 / 21.06.06
great idea for a thread
I'll probably wind up posting some things in here sooner or later

I think your story could work out very nicely if you do it right. It's your last paragraph that makes the whole thing interesting for me. For some reason I can't help but picture it being a sort of cross between Heart of Darkness and Candide. I think if you could sort of strike a balance between the political humor and satire of the latter and the psychological, sociological, and moral explorations of the former ("savegery" vs "civilization" - are they really that different?) you could have something really interesting and enjoyable. Oh, and don't get too bogged down in the technical stuff about seafaring and whatnot, but make sure to include enough to make it believable. If you keep it comical, no one's going to mind if you fool around a bit with the geography and history. Looking forward to seeing how it turns out, make sure to post some when you've made a little headway.
 
  
Add Your Reply