I'm resurrecting this thread like a corpse bobbing to the surface of a murky pond, because this is the thread that brought me via google to barbelith. This is one of my favorite bands (or as many of you like to put it, favourite). I seem to have a penchant for emotive music, and this certainly is in that category. I understand the sentiment
The whole band's sound is pretty much driven by vocalist Mimi Goese's voice, which to me sort of rings of artificiality; of composed, theatrical emotion rather than an outpouring, on one level. This is a good thing though, absolutly - it's beautifully detached from my head as it gets into it, in a way, keeping distance through said artificiality while still being gorgeous. It hovers pleasantly, while threatening to pierce (wank, I know...).
Her voice is beautiful, dramatic, and emotional. When I finally heard an interview with her, she seemed kind of flaky, intense and awkward in an uncomfortable way, which explained alot. Still, immense talent in that flake. Like much of my favorite music, the first time I heard it I was like, "eh, a bit much, I think?" But I was intrigued enough to listen more, and it just got better and better.
While Mimi's voice is the centerpiece, the pared-down but deeply subtle music drives it on. Hahn Rowe's violin is remarkably expressive, alternating between delicate and tearing a new hole in it, and everywhere in between. The bass and guitar, sometimes two basses, while not as...I dunno, vituosic? as the vocals and violin, really fill out the sound. It doesn't sound lacking to me at all.
I'm not sure why most people seem to prefer "Drum" over "Mettle". Maybe because of the Michael Stipe element. I love them both, but I think Mettle is more consistently excellent. A few songs on Drum are a bit flat for me. Years ago, someone sent me a tape with a few unreleased b-sides and some live tracks from a show at Texas Records and KCRW. Some of the b-sides were fantastic, I wish I could find better copies. The live stuff I heard was hit-or-miss, you couldn't always trust Mimi's voice to hit it, makes one a bit edgy listening, though when it worked it was sublime.
As far as Mimi Goese solo effort, I thought it was pretty good, but a bit more cool and synthetic.
Tim Sommer was a VJ on VH-1 for a while, and I think he's done some producing. He's now in a band "Hi-fi Sky"
Hahn Rowe has done some soundtracks, producing, and does some DJing in NYC under the name "Somatic". |