BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Whatever happened to Chuck Austen?

 
 
Jack Denfeld
08:39 / 17.02.06
I remember this guy was the most hated guy on the internet since Ron Marz made Hal go whacko. Kinda feel bad for the guy after reading this interview.
chuck speaks
Some interesting bits.
On his sucky X-Men issues.
A lot of people didn't like "Draco," but we tried. It's really tough, because people say "Y'know, we've been reading the same old thing" so then you give them something different and they say "Oh I hate what you did." That's another time I ran into someone who didn't like my work. So, we're up to three, now. Maybe I got more complaints than I realized [laughs]. He said, "That Draco thing-- it sucked" and I replied, "Ok, so what do you want me to do about that?" to which he replied "I've been collecting X-Men for 16 years and now I've stopped." So I say, "Well, I guess I saved you three dollars a month!"- what am I supposed to say to that? "Draco" got some negative response, but we were trying to do our best and put out something that everyone would like. And we failed. [laughs] No one died.

On claims that he is a misogynist.
When I read my comics about hot women with enormous tits, I want them to be realistically portrayed as strong, independent babes who don't need a man, but still feel good enough about themselves to wear skin-tight clothing and pose provocatively while settling their differences with violence!" I mean, really. Come on. That's a bizarre thing to say: do people even know what misogynist means? It means "hates all women." Really, do you get that out of my writing?

Retailers hated him so much they told Didio they'd never order a book by Austen? Blacklisted.
They were having problems with my scripts and general direction, and sales weren't where they wanted them. They wanted a top ten book, and felt another writer could get them there, when I couldn't. What I was told was that Dan Didio had a conversation with various retailers who said they would never order anything with my name on it because they hated me so much, and that it was creating a ceiling of sales on "Action" that I would never be able to break through. So, I was off Superman. I refused to work under a pseudonym, so DC fired me and blacklisted me from the company. I took that as the opportunity to get out of comics and back into other forms of creativity

The state of the industry and why all the crossovers.
Well, y'know, I haven't really looked back at it much since I left, but from what I hear, you can tell it's gone in the opposite direction. When Joe [Quesada, Marvel EiC] brought me onboard, he was trying to reach out beyond the current market and was trying to find someone who could write outward to new readers. From what I hear, they've completely pulled back from that and they've come to the realization, as I did near the end, that there are no new readers. It's all the long-term fan base that's been there for many years and you have to appeal to them or you don't appeal to anybody. So, everyone's doing more crossovers and big events to spike up sales numbers, so it sounds like they've kind of reverted back to what it was in, what, the early nineties? I have to wonder, and I don't know the sales figures, if sales are still overall generally on a decline, but I don't know what to think about the market. Obviously the direction I was going wasn't working for them, especially if you've got stores that won't carry your book because they don't like you personally, no matter what their customers, fans and readers may think. That's a pretty strong message to a company to go the other way. Appease the fans, or die.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
08:45 / 17.02.06
I think the most informative bit is this:

And misogynist? Who says that? Some guy trying to pick up on a feminist? "Hey, baby. Wanna go out with me? I can use the word misogynist in a sentence."

Especially when juxtaposed with the (not work safe) art from WorldWatch or whatever it's called, his magnum opus. I'd never considered Austen to be an active misogynist per se before, largely because every time I tried to read one of his comics it was impossible to get any sense of anything informing his work other than the shard of metal which presumably passed through his frontal lobes during some horrible car accident...
 
 
Jack Denfeld
08:49 / 17.02.06
I didn't see the watchworld pics from there. Maybe I have a porno blocker on, I'll check again. I don't remember hearing the misogyny thing at Barbelith when we talked about him, it was more like a pervert vibe if I recall.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
08:53 / 17.02.06
(not work safe) art from WorldWatch or whatever it's called
Ewwwwww, why do comic book pubes always look so weird?
 
 
sleazenation
09:28 / 17.02.06
Austin certainly appears to have a charmless lack of self-awareness and any critical faculties regarding his work...

I've flicked through one of his sex comics... Strips i think it was callled. Oddly enough it didn't read quite as badly as his supercomics. As I think I've said before I was so disappointed (to put it mildly) at how badly Austin's US WARMACHINE series read that I couldn't see how he got more writing commissions, let alone one on one of Marvel's flagship titles. I guess he was both a speedy and reasonably easy for editorial staff to deal with...
 
 
Professor Silly
20:47 / 17.02.06
I too collected USWarMachine...and found it utterly terrible--some of the worst writing I've ever seen.

Good riddence. Hopefully the man will find success elsewhere and never work in comics again.
 
 
This Sunday
01:27 / 18.02.06
I'm possibly the one person who found Nurse Annie entertaining, in her psychotic obsessive god-they-let-her-raise-a-kid way, but this 'Boys of Summer'? What's up with that cover? That's not thematic something or other, that's just, well, it's a teenage girl showing us her undies, that's what it is. Getting out of a baseball uniform.
I've defended AssBat and the Quitely Emma cover and oh, loads and loads ('Ghost in the Shell 2') of ('Angel Stomp Future') things ('Eko Eko Azarak'), but... it's not offensive because it'd only offend if I were actually going to purchase it - it's absurd. I'm having 'Plague of Angels' flashbacks, all 'I still don't know why you're dressed like that' and such.
His point on sex versus violence in fiction is a legit one, though. I flat out don't get people who're completely fine with heads exploding and arms being ripped off, but avert their eyes - and try to avert everyone else's - when somebody takes off their shirt.
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
01:33 / 22.02.06
I feel like I could be taken out and beaten for saying it, but I liked his run on Action Comics, and it kind of showed me how on-line fans almost have too much say in things. His sales weren't any worse than any of the other Superman teams, and his X-Men certainly sold a lot better than the book sells now...it's shed 25,000 in sales since his last issue.

Did I like it? No. But I don't think he should have been beaten like a Liefeld doll, and there are a LOT of other writers who are much worse and much more abusive toward women with their writing.

Interviews like thgat one don't help him any, though, and I wonder if he's already got work lined up outside the field and this was a big "fuck you" to on-line fans.
 
  
Add Your Reply