BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


High Atop The Watchtower - a short story

 
 
matthew.
22:56 / 30.01.06
“God, it’s hot as hell,” says Chris.
      “What?”
      “Hot as hell.”
      “Yeah, outside,” says Todd. “The Explorer has air conditioning, though.”
      “Come on in, close the door.”
      Todd enters, with James in tow. Todd’s wearing sweats, the better to eat more, and he hasn’t put any gel in his hair. James has, however, and his cologne precedes him.
      Chris shakes Todd’s hand and says, “Bring you a beer?”
      “You know it man. Where’s the wife?”
      Evelyn says, “In the kitchen. How are you, Todd?”
      “Great,” he leans in and kisses her on the cheek.
      She pulls back. “What are you wearing?”
      “Sweats. I gotta fit a lot of food in here, man.”
      “Huh. Don’t forget to say hello to… Esther.”
      “Oh - yeah - sure. Where is she?”
      “Her room.”
      James bolts past them and goes to the living room, where the TV stands gesticulating. He sees Tom wearing jeans and a T-shirt. James enters as the TV sputters and moans.
      “Hey.”
      “Hey.”
      “What’re you watching?”
      “Much – the Countdown.”
      “Cool.”
      Chris opens the front door and smiles. “Hello, Lily. Nice to see you. Spenser, how are you?”
      Michael rides in after, a pale kid in black, with a dirty white collar. Chris doesn’t say anything to him. He turns to Lily and kisses her on the cheek.
      “How’s business?”
      “None of your business,” she snaps.
      “Oh – sorry – I-”
      Her face softens imperceptibly. “Fine. It’s going fine. Thanks for asking.”
      Spenser says to Michael, “They’re probably in the living room,” and then the pale kid trots there, black garb gliding over marble tile.
      “Hey, Chris, you can’t kiss your sister?”
      Nora steps into the house, sweat glistening her brow.
      Chris turns and says, “Oh – sorry.” He kisses Nora on the cheek.
      “It’s too damn hot. Can’t you turn on the air conditioning? That door is heavy like the prison door.”
      “Isn’t it on?”
      “Chris is too cheap for that,” Lily says to Nora.
      “Oh. I see.”
      Todd says, “Food smells good, Ev.”
      “Thank you.”
      “So, Chris, you watch the game last night?”
      “Last night?”
      “The Leafs won. Of course.”
      “Of course.”
      “What are you watching?” Michael asks.
      “Countdown.”
      “Jesus, what are you wearing?” James asks.
      “Shut up.”
      “Ooh. Touchy.” He turns to the TV. “God, I hate this video.”
      “It’s hot in here,” Michael says.
      Tom says, “Yeah.”
      “Maybe because you’re wearing all black.”
      “Shut up.”
      Todd says, “Knock, knock.”
      Sitting on her bed, Esther looks up with brown eyes. “Hi, uncle Todd.”
      “Hey, my pearl, didja change your hair?”
      She touches the brown hair lightly and looks down in her lap. “Yeah.” She puts down her textbook.
      “It looks good. You look good. How do you feel?”
“She feels fine,” says Evelyn, standing behind Todd in the doorway. She sees Esther and says, “Is that what you’re wearing for dinner?”
      Esther looks down at her brown t-shirt with a small red logo. “I – yes. Why?”
      “Nothing.”
      “I think it’s fine,” Todd whispers.
      Lily and Nora are in the dining room, both looking out the front window. With their hands pulling open the drapes minutely, they put their faces close to the glass.
      “I love that colour.”
      “What? That red?”
      “No, the green.”
      “Disgusting trim.”
      “No.”
      “The scheme is all backwards.”
      “Eh you’re right.”
      “That rose bush is nice.”
      “Yeah.”
      “But everybody has crap like that. Intruding on us. You know?”
      “I guess.”
      “It’s so hot in here.”
      “Stop talking about it. Stop reminding me.”
      “Well, tell Chris.”
      “Did you see… Esther yet?”
      “No – have you?”
      “No. We should go see her. Find out how she’s… doing.”
      “Yeah. See if she’s holding up.”
      “Yeah. Chris! I need a drink.”
      “What?” he asks from the kitchen. He stands against the counter holding a beer, and Todd smiles and says, “You’d better go in there.”
      Evelyn says nothing while she tosses a salad.
      Spenser asks of the cook, “Is there anything I can do?”
      “Not really. Just go into the dining room.”
      “Okay.” Spenser takes his Caesar and passes underneath the dark cross at the entrance of the kitchen. He looks at it briefly and then looks in the dining room. Lily glances from the window at her husband and then returns her gaze.
      “Lily,” Nora says, “tell me you’ve heard that C___ broke up with M___.”
      “What? No?”
      “Yes.”
      “How? Why?”
      “How? Why? I’ll tell you. Over the phone.”
      “No.”
      “Lily,” says Spenser. “Did you tell Nora about our trip to Edmonton?”
      Nora says, “Excuse us.”
      Lily says, “Not now.”
      Spenser sits, watching his wife and his sister-in-law and Chris enters the room, handing a drink to one of his sisters. When he gets back to the kitchen, Todd says, “58. You’re getting up there, man.”
      “57. Not 58. Where’s Michelle?”
      Evelyn glares at Chris.
      Todd looks up at the dark cross on the kitchen doorway. “She’s not… coming. We’re, ah, not together anymore. Again.”
      “Oh – sorry.”
      “How’s Esther, my pearl?” Todd asks.
      “Fine.”
      “Is she moving back home?”
      “I think so.”
      “She’s twenty five. She’s old enough to – hello.”
      Esther walks in. “Talking about me, uncle Todd?” She blinks slowly.
      “Nah,” he smiles.
      Evelyn says, “Don’t be rude.”
      “I wasn’t.”
      “Dad, can I talk to you?”
      Chris says, “Sure. We’ll just go over-”
      “No, in the hall’s fine. Uh, do I have to eat? I’m not hungry. Can I just sit in my room?”
      “You’ll break your mother’s heart, honey.”
      “She doesn’t care if I’m there.”
      “I don’t think so, honey. It’s fine. Just do it for me, okay? For me?”
      “I just don’t feel like sitting there.”
      “Please.”
      In the living room, with eyes and mouths open, three boys, aged 20, 17, and 12 are sitting silently in front of the blaring TV. Michael the eldest gets up to leave.
      “Where are you going?” James asks, the youngest.
      “Yeah, where are you going?”
      “Somewhere else. It’s too hot.”
      “Well, you are wearing a ton of black.”
      “Yeah, you… freak.” Tom says.
      “Fuck,” James says.
      Tom says, “Hey, watch it. My mom doesn’t like that language.”
      “Fuck your mom.”
      “Shut up. What about your mom? She’s a whore. That’s what my mom says.” Tom sneers.
      Michael leaves the room. Tom stands up and follows.
      James says to no one, “Fine. Leave. Fucking fags.” Then he stands up and follows them.
      They all pass the kitchen and Evelyn sees them. “Oh, good. Here, start taking plates.”
      “What?” Tom whines.
      “Here.”
      “That’s too many, Aunt Evelyn.”
      “Don’t drop any.”
      Spenser swirls his drink and watches them carry cutlery and plates. He says nothing. He feels that he needs ice in his drink. Ice.
      Todd and Chris leave the kitchen to the dining room. One of them says, “Almost done, Ev?”
      “Pretty much. Go get your sister, Chris.”
      “Anything else, Aunt Evelyn?”
      “No, go sit – wait. Take the buns.”
      Chris says, “It’s time to get… settled.”
      “It’s too hot, Chris.”
      “Really? I thought it was getting better.”
      Lily moves the curtains aside. “I hate this street. So empty.”
      Spenser puts hand on his wife’s shoulder. She does not notice. She says to Nora, “What a funny car.”
      “I bet that’s…”
      “What?”
      “It’s weird looking.”
      “Did you hear…” says Spenser.
      “What?”
      “Did you hear that Lily and I are going to Edmonton?”
      “Yes. Yes, I did.”
      “When are we leaving?” Spenser asks. “It’s August – what? August fifteenth today. So we leave in, uh, nine days.”
      “You’ll buy me something?”
      “Yes,” Lily says.
      “We should go sit down.”
      “Okay,” says Spenser.
      Evelyn carts out the brown turkey and drops it on the table. She calls to the women watching at the window. “Well, come on then.”
      They stand up and drag their drinks to the table. Evelyn sees them hesitating at chairs and she says, “You know where to sit. You’ve been sitting there for years.”
      “Ready to go?” Todd asks.
      “I’m starving,” Chris says.
      “Can you fill my drink up?” asks Lily.
      “Me, too,” says Nora.
      “Sure.”
      Michael and James are already sitting. Michael asks Chris, when he returns, if he can have a beer.
      “Sure. You’re old enough.”
      “And you’re old,” says Tom.
      Esther emerges and nobody says anything. They look down at their empty plates. Evelyn comes out and says, “Okay. Salad.”
      Tom looks at Esther and says, “So where’s Steve tonight?”
      Chris swats his head.
      Esther looks down at her plate.
      Everybody bows their heads while Evelyn sits. Then, she says something which ends in “amen”.
      Then everybody eats.
      “Pass me the salt.”
      “Where’s the cranberry sauce?”
      “Good bird, Ev, good bird.”
      “How’s school?”
      “How’s business?”
      “Did anybody see the meteor last night? Almost looked like a letter….”
      “I will die if I don’t get the salt.”
      “I mean it, Ev, good bird.”
      The food is consumed and the leftovers are placed in old containers that once held butter. Somebody looks at Esther and then looks away.
      “Anybody want coffee?”
      “Please.” “Yes.” “Thanks, Ev.”
      “Esther, help me with the coffee.”
      “Okay.”
      Todd groans and stretches. “I don’t think I could ever get up again.”
      “Yeah, I’m, like, glued to this chair.”
      Spenser rubs his eyes. He looks back up at Nora.
      “I’m never moving,” says Chris. “Good meal, wasn’t it, Tom?”
      “Yeah.”
      Esther passes the dark cross in the hallway but doesn’t see it, and she enters the dining room, purveying cups of coffee. She places them in front of people.
      “No cream?” asks Todd.
      “Why don’t you get some cream, Esther?” asks Chris.
      “Get it yourself,” snaps Nora.
      Chris stands up and goes to the kitchen, but Evelyn stops in the doorway. She places the cream on the table.
      Tom sneers at Esther. “Too bad you couldn’t fetch for your husb-”
      Chris slaps his head while James giggles slightly.
      Spenser turns to Esther and gazes at her impassive face. He sees nothing there.
      “Oh, I can’t get up.”
      “I’m going to bring out the pie.”
      “Great.”
      “It’s not so bad in here. It’s not that hot, I mean.”
      “What?”
      “The heat. It’s gone.”
      James says, “I wonder if Steve is hot?”
      Chris reaches to slap him, but he can’t. Tom simply giggles. Esther looks at her brother who is saying something to James. She stands up abruptly, with tears squeezing out of her brown eyes.
      “Honey-”
      “I can’t. This….” She leaves.
      “What is…” starts Nora.
      “It’s her own fault,” Lily says firmly. “She brought this on herself. Can’t do anything to keep herself in check.”
      Chris sighs loudly.
      Evelyn comes out with pie. She drops pieces onto plates and then opens a container of white whipped cream. She dollops generous helpings onto the pies.
      “They look like clouds,” says James.
      “Does nobody…” says Michael. He stands up and follows Esther’s path to her room.
      “Where’s Esther?” asks Evelyn.
      “Oh, this pie is heavenly.”
      “Good pie, Ev.”
      Michael enters the room and he watches Esther cry on her bed. She holds her face in her hands, and she does not notice Michael’s entrance.
      “Are you okay?”
      “Oh – oh my God, you scared me.”
      “I’m sorry. Are you okay?”
      “I’m fine, thanks.”
      “Do you want to talk about it?”
      “No.”
      He sits down and scratches his nose. “It’s okay. Everything is okay.”
      In the kitchen, Nora says to Lily, “Just getting up like that.”
      “So rude.”
      “What do you expect? Look what she did.”
      Evelyn comes carrying dishes. She says, “It’s none of your business.”
      “What?”
      “Esther’s divor-”
      “Don’t-”
      “So, mind your business,” Evelyn says.
      “What’s going on, Ev? Nor?”
      “Nothing, Todd.”
      “I see.”
      Lily says, “Chris. I’m leaving. Apparently I’m not welcome here.”
      Chris chuckles a little. “Listen, she didn’t mean anything. I’m sorry.”
      “James? Go find Michael. We’re leaving.”
      “She’s… Esther has broken the sixth comman-”
      “Shut it,” says Evelyn. “I know what’s she’s done.”
      Michael says to Esther, “It’s okay. God will forgive you.” Michael scratches his nose again.
      “I know.”
      In the kitchen, Evelyn shouts over everybody, “I know what she did. It’s between her and God.”


I wrote this story for short story journal at my school. Earlier I submitted my "Hyperparenting" story (which did not fare well on Barbelith), and it was rejected. The main complaint was that the characters had nothing to do. I thought about this for awhile. So with a new story in mind, I wanted to try an experiment in dialogue only, which didn't work, so I added some minimal narrator. I was interested in large family dynamics, as I do not have a large family (almost the opposite). I was also interested in Christianity's constant desire to judge. I wrote a story then about a modern Christian family's judgement of an adulterous daughter. But I wanted minimal narrator, so the characters had to reveal it to the reader. Then, I read an interview with David Mamet about his Glengarry Glen Ross; he said that play was about how people don't communicate with each other. The characters in my story couldn't just say it; they had to dance around it. To make it obvious, I added in the reticence of "the divor-". Also, I wanted to add something literary (read: snobbery). That's where the Scarlet Letter imagery comes in: the rose bush, the prison door, the priest, the dark cross, the small red logo, the meteor. And then, on the bottom of all this, the structure superficially uses Dante's trip through the other realm: hell, purgatory, and then heaven. I know it's not sutble, but I'm frightened that if I didn't make it obvious, this journal at school would not get it without this giant paragraph of explanation ("if you have to explain it, Chief, it's not good").

(By the way, this is the fourth draft: a true milestone for my editorial skills. Usually I get to the second and I give up. This story had two seperate people read it: one a poet (third draft), the other a copywriter(fourth draft) )
 
 
autran
11:27 / 31.01.06
OK, I just had a quick read.

It charges along like a MG with the top down. Good.
I also think you did a good job of creating a crowd of people, although I didn't get that they were family.

I think the main weakness is that the themes you mentioned in your explanatory para did not come out very strongly. Not to me, anyway.

I also didn't get the Dante reference, but then I haven't read the Divine Comedy.

There are quite a few adverbs. Maybe you meant that as a stylistic flourish? If not then I understand it is de rigeur to avoid them these days. (Even so, if you want to be a minimal narrator then you should probably take out "imperceptibly".)

Finally, a real low-level detail point: "purveying" implies a business so you might want to change to "conveying", which could mean just carrying.
 
 
matthew.
22:39 / 31.01.06
I should probably re-examine my use of adverbs. Thanks for the comments.
 
 
matthew.
03:01 / 09.02.06
bump. Read me, people.
 
 
Loomis
12:36 / 09.02.06
I'm afraid I gave up halfway through. It may just be down to my own comprehension skills, but I just can't follow the endless dialogue without more expository prose to encapsulate it and give it shape. I know you said it's an experiment in style, so maybe it just depends on reader preference, but it's not a style I'm used to so I found it hard to get into.

It remindes me of reading a film script after you've seen the film and it seems so empty compared to all the nuance you took for granted on the screen. This reads to me like a film script, where you would expect so much more to be added by the expressions and glances of the actors. But in fiction you have to provide that yourself.
 
 
matthew.
02:39 / 10.02.06
Originally, it was a script in my head.

I guess, Loomis, you wouldn't care for William Gaddis, whose later novels consisted of almost 100% dialogue, without any indication of who said what. I cannot emphasize enough what an influence Gaddis was on this story.... I opted for very few repetitions and "uh" and "um".
 
 
All Acting Regiment
05:07 / 10.02.06
I totally appreciate what you were trying to do, Matt, so don't be disheartened, but again, I really think you need more descriptions of characters. Just to get a handle on it. There's some good stuff in there but it's just bewildering at the moment.

And adding those descriptions and stuff in doesn't neccesarily have to be wracked by Convention, as it were- assuming you're working against Convention.

I think one of the most helpful things I've picked up off of my course is that it's sometimes better to fiddle with the exisiting features to make them fresh rather than drop them altogether. I mean novels have evolved, and like tigers, most things that are in there need to be- they just need to be done in a way that isn't banal.

How else can I put it...you'll get more mileage from subverting something once you've drawn the reader in than you will from locking them out.
 
 
matthew.
11:20 / 10.02.06
once you've drawn the reader in than you will from locking them out.

I suppose that's my biggest flaw in this story. Thanks for the help, everyone.
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
12:26 / 19.02.06
I think one problem is that the description is lopsided - so, for example, we are given the ages of the sons, and of one of the adults. We are told Esther has brown eyes (twice), that Todd is wearing sweats, that James is wearing cologne and gel in his hair. Some of this detail is nice - I like the way that James' uncertainty and adolescence is shown by making too much of an effort for a family dinner. It does mean that the characters without descriptive points seem to fade, however. Esther is the only character who really gets a face; when we get down to Nora, Spenser or Lily, I had to draw a map just to remind myself of who they were, and I struggled to understand why they were. As a result, some of the lengthy passages of dialogue seemed to hang in the air without any real ascription. Which needn't be a problem - you're communicating feel here, and one of the the things you might want your reader to feel is that these are well-worn conversations without a real communicative load. However, it does risk dragging or skimming.

Key themes – large families and religion/adultery/divorce. The large families pretty much saddles you with a big cast list, which might help to explain why minor characters feel like chaff – at times it feels like a puzzle as much as a story, as you try to work out who is where when. Would it maybe be better to trim the list a little? The children, in particular, I found a bit surplus to requirements, barring Tom, and the scene with them seems not to add much in its current form – could I ask what your intention was in that section?

Religion/adultery/divorce – I like the way this was handled – the interaction of Todd and Esther in particular. However, if you want to rewrite this for another audience after submission, would it be worth removing the specific word “divor-”, which seems a bit signposty? The sixth commandment bit I like better, in part because it references back – everyone commits adultery, but only the religious think of it in terms of breaking commandments. However, I didn't feel that the narrative of religiosity was integrated – perhaps because many of the overt references – the cross, the commandment – came late. I'd look at what you can do or not do with the narrative voice here, as well – for example, the only thing that is not communicated in direct speech is Evelyn's saying of grace. This might give the impression that the rest of those around the table are not interested in what she is saying, and as near as I can tell they are - at least a moiety of them are Christians, if not more. After my first reading, certainly, I was left wondering why grace had not been said – I had been attuned to direct speech to the point where I had to reread it. Could you integrate religiosity more closely into their interactions?
 
 
Saltation
15:51 / 21.02.06
[please read following in offthecuff conversational style. maybe read it aloud.]

dunno...
it feels...

well...um (ah, etc)... to my taste, it's too slow. but it's too slow [for me] as a direct result of your explicit and deliberate stylistic choice: micro-replication of dialogue. i can't fault your dialogue or your replication of scenes. it's just... it requires [for me] a lot of patience from the reader, and much willingness to put their environment to one side and replace it with another so that they can follow along with the another.

i'm not saying that's good or bad.

i will say that that kinda makes big demands on your audience, and those who can't meet those demands will tend not to finish your story.
if you're happy targetting this story at that subset: big tick, from my perspective.
 
 
matthew.
16:43 / 21.02.06
I see that the big problem is the impenetrability of the story. I admit that I wanted it to be difficult. The reader is supposed to work to get in. Thanks for comments, people.
 
 
All Acting Regiment
18:13 / 21.02.06
Also, I think "Up on the watchtower" might be a better title than "High Atop The Watchtower". Dramatic's good but simple's better.
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
22:31 / 21.02.06
The reader is supposed to work to get in.

I'd almost never suggest this, but maybe after it has fulfilled its immediate purpose, you might think about making it harder work - redraft it to take away all the specific references to Esther's divorce, and leave it to the reader to put the clues together. Possibly with a slightly lower character count, that might leave the reader feeling sweaty but fulfilled.
 
 
matthew.
16:06 / 12.05.06
By the way, regardless of whether or not it's advised, my next project is going to take this dialogue style to a whole 'nother level. I'm going to write the Ulysses (or perhaps the JR) of spy novels. I've already written a small chunk of how I see this going. The narrator only gets into the head of one character, and it's in an impressionist monologue.

My love affair with post-modernism has come to an end with this Watchtower story. I'm going back to modernism with this gigantic spy novel.
 
 
sibyline, beating Qalyn to a Q
11:56 / 13.05.06
matt, my one piece of advice is to take more of a gander at conventional fiction and write it effectively, then move on to experimentation. it really helps to have a completely ingrained sense of how a straightforward, classic story works so that when you try to take away / substitute elements, you have more control over what you're working with.

also, more often than not, difficult writers have had to build trust with readers. for me to read something obscure or challenging, i have to know that the writer is not being obscure for the sake of obscurity, and i have no way of knowing that unless i've built up trust with that writer.

i thought the opening was promising, but was put off by "his cologne precedes him," and then got lost somewhere in the dialogue along the way.
 
  
Add Your Reply