BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Top 5 Comics of 2005

 
 
Haus of Mystery
09:56 / 21.12.05
Okay, exactly what it says on the tin. Please give reasons though, lists are no use. Due to being at work I myself will get around to doing my own in a bit, but I wanted to get the ball rolling.

Away you go...
 
 
sleazenation
10:39 / 21.12.05
I have a feeling that seven soldiers will feature highly in this list- but which two soldiers won't make it on the list?

I'd think that WE3 and the reprint of City of Glass would have to feature highly as well. Other than than thart, I'd struggle because what I'm reading and enjoying and what has been published this year tend to be very different lists...
 
 
Sniv
11:15 / 21.12.05
Hmmm... can this be anything that came out this year, single issues, or major arcs? I'll be using both. In no particular order (other than the order I think of them in):

- Seven Soldiers: The Manhattan Guardian #4
- I must have read this book five times in a row when I first got it, it blew my tiny mind, and completely redifined for me what the Seven Soldiers thing was all about. Very very cool.

- Ultimate Fantastic Four (all year, especially the zombie story)
- Currently my favourite Ultimate book, I'm really liking both Millar's handling of the characters and Greg Land's sickeningly good artwork. I used to like his pencils on Nightwing and Birds of Prey, but he really (with great help from his colourist, I presume) has become something else in the past few years. His zombies were fucking awesome, and were worth the price of entry alone. Great stuff.

- All Star Batman and Robin the Boy Wonder (both issues)
- Yeah, I know I'm going to get a lot of stick over this but whatdafug, I loved it. From the look of glee on Dick's face in his first splash page to Batman being a complete cock when dealing with a traumatised little kid, I've been enjoying this, and am looking forward to the rest. Flying Batmobile... I mean, c'mon!! Unlike most other knee-jerk internet whiners, I have faith in the abilities of Miller and Lee, and am looking forward to the development of the characters and the story as time goes on (who knows, maybe we'll get another three issues next year!)

- Mike Allred's Solo
- This was easily the most joycore comic I've read all year. Right from the touching Bizarro intro, I could tell this comic would be a little bit special, and it didn't disappoint at all. Hourman's tweaked-out Hour of Power was great, silly fun. The little Mister Miracle story really made me laugh too, I appreciated its throwaway sadomasochism, and the Batman story was surprisingly heartfelt and relevant in these dark times (for comic characters that is). Which leads us nicely to...

- Infinite Crisis
- Yeah!! *twitching on floor, paroxysms of fanboy ecstacy*
Well, dependoing on how you grew up, it was either going to be this or House of M, wasn't it? House of M turned me off pretty quick (not a big mutant fan + too much Bendis = skip), and DC was always my first love so this... this has indeed been giving me fever-dreams for a while now. There's just so much going on, so many angles, so many bits and bobs, it's just an exhilerating ride, even if we a) don't really know what's going on yet and b) don't really think they can pull it off. The last event that got me this excited was the 'No Man's Land' arc in Batman in '99, and 8C has a similar premise - mosaic pieces creating a larger whole, with the purpose of redefining what these comics will be about for the forseeable future. Cool.
 
 
Quimper
16:40 / 21.12.05
- Phoenix: Endsong
If for nothing else, the art was just the best to look at all year. Plus, it solidified Scott and Emma's relationship, instead of doing what we all thought would happen...undoing Grant's work. Plus, it was a cosmic-scale story told entirely in the woods next to the mansion.

- Astonishing X-Men #4
Hell, it was inevitable. But it was done well! The return of Piotr Rasputin. That panel with Kitty's hand on her heart still makes me shiver.

- Seven Soldiers: Manhattan Guardian
The best Marvel book of the year was put out by DC. #4 is fucking genius.

- X-Factor #1
All this bullshit, and something good comes out of it. Characters with personalities! Woo-Hoo! Film noir dark. Swearing. Boozing. Pushing. All in a day's work.

- Seven Soldiers: Zatanna
Okay. This is the book of the year to me. You don't just like Zee, you absolutely fucking love her. Funny. Gorgeous to look at. And GM is at his self-aware meta best. Any comic that makes me interact with it as if this is The Neverending Story gets Best in Show.
 
 
Lel
21:28 / 21.12.05
Favorite Ongoing: Astonishing X-Men

Favorite Mini: Its a toss up between a few of the Seven Soldiers. None stand out as the best, but together they are amazing.
 
 
The Falcon
22:55 / 21.12.05
I think that's incorrect. Zatanna clearly stands out to me as the best. I think especially #1 and #4 are the best two comics I've read since... probably since the last issue of the Filth. Just exactly the sort of stuff I want from Grantbooks; all that meta stuff, and you feel a bit ooh - I kind of believe in magic today, isn't it smashing.

Zatanna #1 has ruined pretty much all of Promethea for me singlehandedly; don't go back afterward - there's just no point (honestly, it's total rubbish in comparison,) 's like sniffing a line after you done smoked the rock, I expect. Jim Baxter, 1967, that kind of thing.

And #4 is the best GM comic since the last one where you had to a) charge a sigil or b) the character interacted with higher planes of reality... but also incredibly resonant and touching. + further pisstaking of Alan, and his beard in the single finest sentence ever to be in a comic. (Even though I love Alan, really I do - the grumpy old jobby.)

I really would have trouble selecting further comics, including all the Morrison ones, below these. Plus, I don't want it to be utterly self-evident what a mainstream whooore I am. Captain America #1 was what they call solid, I guess; very strong on plot and character elements, great shock ending. Lovely, hard art.
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
08:36 / 28.12.05
I read so few comics that I can't suggest much more than We3, I don't normally like Grant's compressed stuff but I think it worked well, I still think the ending is a cheat though, but the bunny shitting the bomb was priceless.

I must say I did quite like Avengers Dissassembled, probably because I don't really care about any of the characters, it's just that the final chapter is so amazingly badly plotted and incoherent it's like a masterclass in how not to write a story.

Did Promethea finish off this year? If so I'll nominate the last collection of that.
 
 
Benny the Ball
14:35 / 28.12.05
I've already typed one out, and it rather annoying got lost when my system decided to switch my browser off, anyway, disclaimer for how this won't be too in depth.

1. Frankenstein #1 - I've enjoyed the S7 series a lot, but have said before that a lot of the series' early books have suffered slightly from over-dosing in issue one-itus. This book caught me in a good mood, and feeling really happy about how the series was running, and just looked fabulous and felt like a great deal of fun.

2. X-Factor #1 - I've always enjoyed PD's Jamie Madrox, and think that Sook's art holds that great middle ground between looking real enough and comic book enough to be its own thing. Plus, with Milligan on X-Men, it feels like fun to read X books again.

3. JLC - started off with GM's great story, followed up with Giffen and DM and KM's good ol' JL, and even the long winded Ellis story has had some fun moments (the latest issue had Supes being very Super).

4. Villains United - a great great charcter driven story, excellently scripted - the torture issue alone made it one of the best series of the year. Stood out amongst the 8C prequels (OMAC was okay, but lost it a little).

no five just yet...
 
 
ThePirateKing
19:00 / 10.01.06

My comic of the year is easily we3 which I thought was just wonderful storytelling. Loved it.

Of the regular monthy titles I think I've looked forward to THE ULTIMATES the most every month. Good art, great humour.
 
 
matthew.
20:10 / 10.01.06
I second Ultimate Fantastic Four because those guys are putting in an effort to explain the science of being a fantastic foursome. Even if the science is bunk (a good portion of it is, if you read/believe the letters column), I have to commend them for trying.

Paging Dr. Cameron Stewart! We need your opinion in the comics forum! What do you think?
 
 
doyoufeelloved
21:21 / 10.01.06
because those guys are putting in an effort to explain the science of being a fantastic foursome

I totally agree with you (loved Ellis' run on this, stronger than a lot of his recent work), right up until the most recent issue, in which Reed Richards invents a helmet that makes anything he can think of happen. Seriously. Mark Millar never saw a corner he can't write himself out of with a liberal helping of bullshit.

Books of the year for me: WE3, THE ULTIMATES, SEVEN SOLDIERS (with MANHATTAN GUARDIAN as my runaway favorite of the minis), ASTONISHING X-MEN, and, conceptually at the very least but often in execution as well, INFINITE CRISIS. I'd draw from outside the superhero universe more, but to be frank it's very difficult for me to keep track of what comes out in what year. NIGHT FISHER certainly qualifies, but does the one-volume BONE, or was that 2004? I don't know if I liked BLACK HOLE enough to rack it up there -- but oh shit, SCOTT PILGRIM vol. 2 was in 2005. Might want to sub that in for ASTONISHING X-MEN, actually.
 
 
Billuccho!
22:37 / 10.01.06
The Street Angel collection came out this year. It's easily one of the best comics of the current century. Uber joycore and all that of the everything-plus-the-kitchen-sink variety.

Seven Soldiers was certainly good. I don't think I can choose a favorite mini, and my favorite single issue of it all is probably still #0, though Guardian #3 and 4 were also some of my favorites.

Fell is a very interesting comics experiment that actually worked out well. Sixteen dense pages of story with some of Ellis's greatest dialogue and tight plotting.

Desolation Jones is another Ellis title, and this one's a lot of fun too. Yeah, okay, it's another spin on his grumpy bastard archetype, but it's also crime noir with a twinge of sci-fi. The delicious JH Williams art is what really puts it high on my list. Also, the lettering. Jones has the best lettering in comics. Thank you, Todd Klein.

Solo is a marvelous idea, and this year we got the Cooke and Allred issues, which included lots of things I love about comics. Did the Pope issue come out this year, too? I still haven't tracked down a copy of that, but I shall.

Honerable mentions include All-Star Superman, JLA: Classified, and the We3 collection.
 
  
Add Your Reply