BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Garth Nix - Is he (lazy generalisation alert!) the new Philip Pullman?

 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
19:16 / 04.12.05
I'm about halfway through Sabriel and haven't been as excited by a writer since I started on Northern Lights. Yet Garth Nix seems to be lacking the crossover success with the adult market enjoyed by Rowling and Pullman. It would seem to have enough basic simularities with the LotR/Northern Lights stories to get a lot more interest than it is, although it goes in a very different direction.

Who else has read these books?
 
 
■
20:48 / 04.12.05
Well, hardly new. I recently flogged an early 1980s copy of Warlock magazine with a short story of his in it on eBay. I started Sabriel a few years ago and got a bit bored. Maybe I'll give him another try. Pullman grabbed me from the first with a "what is this?", Sabriel made me go "what's going on?" but in a bad way.
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
06:39 / 05.12.05
Interesting. Maybe I've read enough fantasy that despite the oddities it fits a recognisable shape so that I can press on with it in the same way that I have difficulties whenever I try to approach James Joyce, not understanding the landscape?
 
 
Aimes
09:11 / 05.12.05
It's definitely worth persevering with Sabriel, I think. The Old Kingdom trilogy has a great world background to it and he manages to keep the storytelling going at a good pace. (Although there are some wobbly bits in Abhorsen.)

I wouldn't recommend his kids series, The Keys to the Kingdom, though. The first one (Mister Monday) was ok, but the two after that were just crap! Completely flat and almost non existent story. It felt like he was trying to pad out a short story so that it was up to novel length, but failed miserably at it!
 
 
solid~liquid onwards
19:58 / 23.12.05
I get loads of fantasy books from my mum. I read the old kingdom trilogy about a year back. I would file it under entertaining distraction its nothing special (opinion)
 
  
Add Your Reply