BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Bleak House

 
 
Benny the Ball
07:35 / 07.11.05
Okay, so who's been watching this? The format is fantastically well suited to the sprawling books narrative.

So far the cast has done a great job - Guppy is fantastic;y realised, and for the most they are as large and crude as you should expect from Dickens.

My one major problem, and it is quiet present in any Dickensian adaptation, is that Dickens draws fantastic child characters, always some of the most interesting in his books, however, stage school kids do not do them justice at all. Joe the sweeper is a great character in the book, but the actor that they have playing him in the show isn't very good at all. Is this the directors fault, or the actors?

So anyway, a thread to discuss this programme, whether it works in its format, if the characters are what you'd expect, Have you read the book, does it make you want to read the book? Why are BBC so good at this sort of thing?
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
07:58 / 07.11.05
Jo the sweeper isn't a great character in the book in the sense of being a recognisable human being, though - he's a tool for Dickens to make a moral point, and many readers - including Dickens scholars - feel that he's handled a little mawkishly. I definitely think it's a role very difficult for an actor to play, especially a child actor, without falling into cliche or parody.
 
 
■
09:41 / 07.11.05
I love it. It's all so wonderfully melodramatic. I think Gillian Anderson is overdoing it a wee bit, but she's got the blend of haughty bitchiness and vulnerability down right. Isn't Denis Lawson great, though? Such a lovely character who you just know is heading for a fall. Guppy is wonderful as well, slimy and misguidedly well-meaning, who is that guy? He's vaguely familiar, but I can't recall seeing him in any other big roles. It's interesting the way they've taken a load of big names and put them in the background roles, while the young leads are effectively unknowns (except Sukie-Mae Cantrell from Who as Esther, natch).
Could have done without Alistair McGowan, though.
 
 
Benny the Ball
15:49 / 07.11.05
Guppy, Burn Goram or Gorman - I kind of recognise him also, but can't place him.
 
  
Add Your Reply