BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Saw II

 
 
matthew.
04:51 / 29.10.05
Well. Just came from the theatre, or the multiplex, if you prefer. Yep. I paid 8.75 Canadian to watch SAW II.

I liked Saw. It was somewhat entertaining, other than the extreme lapses in logic and a plot lifted from Cube and Seven. I also have a love of Elwes (dig that entrance in Shadow of the Vampire).

But SAW II... Is it good, is it bad? I'm going to be spoiler free in this post, and tell you nothing of the plot, save for the fact that it treads unbelievably familiar ground. If you know anything about horror movies, well, my friends, you've seen this before.

At least the acting is a little better, and they have more of a budget, so the awful "car chase" of the first movie is not repeated. The director, new to the (probably) series, uses most of the same tricks as the first film. He just adds a sense of... professionalism. The same cannot be said for the ludicrous script, penned by the original writer of the first film, who also played the photographer in said movie.

The fun in Saw and Saw II is the guessing game. I absolutely love trying to guess the inevitable twist ending. There's nothing more fun. Thanks to The Sixth Sense, everything's gotta have a twist ending, even if it doesn't make any fucking sense (I'm looking at you, Haute Tension, you bitch). Yet, there is true fun to be found in trying to predict the craziness. This twist ending? Yeah, it was okay, only if you completely disregard any logic whatsoever.

So go see Saw II only if you liked Saw. Otherwise, you'll be grinding your teeth and praying that Eli Roth makes another film. (It's called Hostel and it's going to blow the roof off of Saw and Saw II combined.)
 
 
Murray Hamhandler
02:04 / 02.11.05
Every time someone's mentioned this movie, I've been all like, "What? Solitude? What's that about?".
 
 
Logos
02:41 / 02.11.05
Honestly, I wish someone would just post the Cliffs Notes versions of both movies, because I'm not interested enough to actually watch the darn things. At the same time, I've received enough partial plot spoilers that I'd kind of like to know what happens to all of the characters and such.
 
 
Jackie Susann
11:14 / 28.06.07
SPOILERS FOR THE FIRST ONE





Okay this is random, but at work today I had an argument about Saw, how dumb it was, and my co-worker insisting I was wrong. So I kind of went, come on, the killer laid totally immobile in the room with them for like three hours without them noticing him breathing? And co-worker insisted there was a brilliant twist in part two that explained this.

Now I am pretty sure there isn't. But it there is, I would like to know what it is.
 
 
H3ct0r L1m4
17:46 / 29.06.07
actually, it's in SAW 3 that it's shown in a flashback how Jigsaw and his assistant set the whole bathroom scenario seen in 1.
 
 
Jackie Susann
21:01 / 29.06.07
Is it even remotely logical?
 
 
H3ct0r L1m4
22:24 / 30.06.07
yeah, it is, hehe

as far as the SAW series can be.
 
 
H3ct0r L1m4
22:26 / 30.06.07
oh, and it's not a brilliant twist - just something Jigsaw can do, the control freak that he is.
 
  
Add Your Reply