BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Barbelith Is A Place To Learn/Be Challenged/Review Your Views

 
 
All Acting Regiment
10:19 / 14.10.05
Something I've been thinking about recently is how so many people (inlcuding my self at first) seem to see a place like Barbelith as somewhere to come and rant: always throwing their opinion out at the highest volume. These aren't neccesarily tolls proper- they just don't understand that you have to be happy to have your views and ideas challenged to take part in Barbelith (I think this last point is pretty much self evident, but do say if you disagree).

Seeing as this is a central point of Barbelith- as opposed to other message boards which seem quite happy to offer a mouthing off service without any element of the participants being challenged, and being required to respond effectively to those challenges- could we not in some way make this clear, in, as it were, "big red letters" on the registration pages, and up at the top of the front page?

Obviiously I'm not being as anal as to actually specify the font or colour, but I just think making this element of the site more widely signposted it might save us some wasted time and atract people who want to join in properly.
 
 
Jub
11:01 / 14.10.05
The registration process is already lengthy enough, and the people coming through have largely been great. There's recently been a couple of trolls but I thought they were long registered "sleeping" suits of persistant trolls.

I'm not sure what big red letters would acheive which the current system doesn't already address.
 
 
Jack Fear
11:10 / 14.10.05
And, y'know, you figured it out pretty quick. Any half-bright and reasonably observant person will suss it in a hurry.

And if s/he can't deal with it, s/he'll leave—which is probably a good thing for all parties concerned, frankly.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
14:19 / 14.10.05
It seems clear to me that Barbelith is a place to be challenged. There are more people here who are challenged than ever before!
 
 
---
16:23 / 14.10.05
There are more people here who are challenged than ever before!

Are you trying to imply that I might be mentally challenged?
 
 
grant
20:23 / 14.10.05
That's the limit!



SIR, I DEMAND SATISFACTION!
 
 
grant
20:24 / 14.10.05
Now that that's out of the way, I don't see how "a place to be challenged" is a different remit than "a place for debate," since it's hard to debate without challenges.

Maybe a line or two somewhere in the wiki would help clarify that....
 
 
Mazarine
23:31 / 14.10.05
"Barbelith is not your blog!" perhaps?
 
 
Quantum
13:47 / 17.10.05
"We challenge fat tories and pine trees!"
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
16:48 / 17.10.05
Dude, let it go...
 
  
Add Your Reply