BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The future of the U.S. Supreme Court

 
 
Mazarine
02:22 / 04.09.05
Chief Justice Rehnquist is dead of cancer, Justice O'Connor is retiring, so what's the future of the Supreme Court? On one hand, Bush now has two slots to fill, on the other hand, absolutely no one is happy with Bush right now.

How bad do you think it's going to get? Is Clarence Thomas going to be tapped for the top slot? Will this distract everyone from Bush's complete and utter failure with regards to Hurricane Katrina?
 
 
Jake, Colossus of Clout
02:25 / 04.09.05
Jinx!
 
 
MJ-12
02:34 / 04.09.05
I expect Bush will nominate his horse.
 
 
Jake, Colossus of Clout
02:34 / 04.09.05
(Copied from my duplicate thread)

Okay, so the old snake finally kicked it.

This is, as expected, going to lead to Bush's second Supreme Court nomination. Considering that Bush's political stock is plummeting, what do you think we can expect? Between Iraq and the colossal fuck-ups in handling Hurricane Katrina, the fake president is treading on thin ice.

It'll be hard for him to find a bigger conservative asshole than Rehnquist (Scalia's already there, after all), and even harder to push him through.

So: Scalia becomes the head of the Court? I wouldn't doubt it. The evil fucker.

Honestly, I'm still pissed at O'Connor for retiring when Bush was in office. She must have known he would appoint an evil shit to the court. How could she?

I'm going to toast the passing of a dirtbag with some rye whiskey. Happy trails Rehnquist, you dick.
 
 
alejandrodelloco
03:09 / 04.09.05
Damn, damn, damn, damn, damn.

Rehnquist was a cocksucker, but I just hope that the next guy isn't worse.
 
 
Ganesh
08:48 / 04.09.05
Can Saudis be nominated?
 
 
Cherielabombe
09:37 / 04.09.05
As Rheinquist was a conservative and not a swing-voter as O'Connor was, as far as who will be nominated next, I am not overly worried about a conservative replacing a conservative.

Optimist that I am, in a way I think Bush having two spots on the Supreme Court to fill at about the same time is good, as Rheinquist's death reminds people that we also have John J Roberts' confirmation hearings coming up. Due to the situation with Hurricane Katrina's aftermath, Roberts was expected to sail through, but this I think turns people's attention back to the Supreme Court (somewhat) and hopefully will make it at least a little more difficult to 'sail through.'
 
 
cfm
09:38 / 04.09.05
Will this distract everyone from Bush's complete and utter failure with regards to Hurricane Katrina?

Well, the Bush administration only seems to allow one story on its plate at one time, preferably a good one that overrides bad ones. Notice how there's been little, if not any, coverage of the war during the Katrina disaster?

Katrina, however, is high-profile and close to home, which makes me suspect that the administration won't be able to pretend it doesn't exist or isn't happening while they pick a nominee. Few have complained about a sudden and complete lack of Iraq news, and yet I think people would cry bloody murder of Katrina suddenly dropped off our screens in favor of the second Supreme Court justice debate.

Heh. Short post from an unknown quantity, who will now bow out and return later. I'll be interested to see where this discussion goes, on Barbelith and in the world.
 
 
Mazarine
14:20 / 04.09.05
Due to the situation with Hurricane Katrina's aftermath, Roberts was expected to sail through, but this I think turns people's attention back to the Supreme Court (somewhat) and hopefully will make it at least a little more difficult to 'sail through.'

I agree. That, and while Bush can't seek another term, members of Congress can, and with Katrina in the news, it may also occur to them that now is not the time to be seen making Bush's life easy.
 
 
Persephone
11:43 / 05.09.05
Roberts gets the tap for the top spot--
 
 
Mazarine
14:21 / 05.09.05
Great. The noob. Fantastic.
 
 
netbanshee
14:51 / 05.09.05
Since Roberts is being tapped for Chief Justice, he should be under more scrutiny during the nomination process. He's been a slippery fucker up to this point and apparently one is considered moderate when you're just not told of what wing-nutty ideas are trapped in their heads.

There's already been a slight delay due to close timing to Bill's death and the state of events w/ Katrina and all... hopefully Dems can use any time they can get to either mount serious opposition or at least get more of his views on record.

I'm just hoping that Bush taps an O'Conner-like justice to the retired spot and places like people in similar positions to their predecessors.
 
 
Persephone
15:47 / 05.09.05
It's not unusual for chief justices to be appointed from outside the court, though.
 
 
diz
09:11 / 07.09.05
He's been a slippery fucker up to this point and apparently one is considered moderate when you're just not told of what wing-nutty ideas are trapped in their heads.

This is what worries me the most about him. He's been remarkably sunny and smiley and hard as fuck to pin down ideologically, but Bush must have picked him for some reason. My fear is that he's secretly a total fascist, and was picked because he hasn't really been in a position where he'd leave a paper trail that would tip us off about it.

As for the other slot, I'm hoping that Bush's well-known preference for personal loyalty outweighs his debt to movement conservatives and he picks Gonzalez. The fact that I'm hoping Mr. Torture Memo himself gets sent to the Supreme Court indicates how dire the situation is.
 
 
grant
15:02 / 03.10.05
White House consigliere Harriet Miers nominated.

She's never been a judge, was the first woman president of the Texas Bar Ass'n, and basically filled in Alberto Gonzalez's slot when he went off to be Attorney General.

Not many people know anything about her or her views.


Excerpts from AP:
Senate Republicans said they would press for confirmation by Thanksgiving — a tight timetable by recent standards that allowed less than eight weeks for lawmakers to review her record, hold hearings and vote.

....

Senate Democratic Leader Harry Reid was complimentary, issuing a statement that said he likes Miers and adding "the Supreme Court would benefit from the addition of a justice who has real experience as a practicing lawyer."

....

Reid had personally recommended that Bush consider Miers for nomination, according to several sources familiar with the president's consultations with individual senators. Of equal importance as the White House maps its confirmation campaign is that the Nevada Democrat had warned Bush that the selection of any of several other contenders could trigger a bruising partisan struggle.

At the same time, Republican strategists who spoke on condition of anonymity said they would have to work hard to assure the support of some of the more conservative Republicans in the Senate.



She's been tight with Bush since the 90s, and she's already getting flak from Operation Rescue, who view the fact that she's a Southern Methodist as an admission that she's pro-abortion, I think.

She's worked pro-bono for a group called Exodus Ministries -- it seems likely that this is a faith-based group that works on helping ex-cons stay out of jail, but there's another group by the same name that helps, uh, cure homosexuals. The ex-con Exodus is based in Dallas, so that's probably the one.

More on Miers over here at Talking Points Memo. Follow the links for more info.
 
 
grant
15:14 / 03.10.05
Some conservatives already making with the "filibuster" talk.

So, a wedge issue.
 
 
bjacques
15:53 / 06.10.05
Regardless of her judicial philosophy, this will raise the number to four justices who won't say no to a little more executive encroachment on the judiciary. Or a little favor down the road.
 
  
Add Your Reply