BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Superhero RPGs

 
 
COBRAnomicon!
14:06 / 01.09.05
Some friends and I are thinking of getting back into the waters of dice-and-paper RPGs. We got big jollies out of the old DC Heroes game in the early 90s, but it doesn't seem to be around any more. Any recommendations/thoughts on the crop of superhero games currently available?
 
 
A0S
14:26 / 01.09.05
I haven't played it myself (yet) but a lot of people I know love Mutants & Masterminds by Green Ronin.
 
 
Laughing
19:36 / 01.09.05
I've been running a Mutants & Masterminds game with some buddies for a few weeks and it's going pretty well. M&M is a D20 game and I'm not a big fan of that system, but my players seem to like it. They're both used to Dungeons & Dragons so it wasn't a complete culture shock for them to make the change over. Character creation is geared toward making really powerful characters though; it's easy for PCs to start out obscenely powerful with just a little min-maxing. But that does fit in with the superpowers theme, plus it's easy to just throw someone bigger at them. "Your pathetic mutant powers are no match for... Carnifex, the Eater of Galaxies!!"

Another good choice is White Wolf's Aberrant, even though it's actually a sci-fi game disguised as a superhero game (as opposed to its sister game, Trinity, which is a superhero game disguised as a sci-fi game). Aberrant deals with superhumans in as realistic a way as you can get when the world is populated by flying people who shoot lasers from their faces. It tries to portray what people with amazing powers would actually do in the real world. For example, if you had super-strength would you A) crack open a bank vault and bring down the wrath of the cops, military, and the Justice League, or B) get a multimillion dollar contract with Gold's Gym? Sure, bank robbery is fun, but it's just not as lucrative.
 
 
Evil Scientist
19:43 / 01.09.05
Aberrant is the tops as far as I'm concerned. I've been GMing a game using this system for the last four years or so. It can get a little preachy though about how it's "not a superheroes game" but that's White Wolf for you. It's one of the few supers games I've read that makes a stab at playing characters with a transhumanist mindset (an organisation called the Teragen, their sourcebook is a fantastic read).
 
 
sine
21:16 / 01.09.05
I have a heavily modified/drifted ruleset of Godlike called PsyCho we've been using for the past two years - I was really into Godlike for a while, but when the WW2 charm wore off, it needed conceptual overhaul. The changes are interesting, very pomo - plays a bit like Marvelman(Miracleman), but with doses of Changling - the base setting is twenty years in the future, but the characters careen through hallucinated states of reprogramming modeled after the various eras of comics - hence, they filter their reality moment to moment according to the "rules" of their psychosis : i.e. Golden Age, Silver Age, Grim Eighties, etc. Requires lots of thinking on one's feet, but I'm blessed with a clever bunch.
 
 
charrellz
23:14 / 01.09.05
You can find most of the manuals for an abandoned TSR Marvel superhero game here. Not the best system, but it's still pretty fun.
 
 
Lord Morgue
08:44 / 02.09.05
I'm an old booster for the original Marvel Heroes RPG- it had the best system for balancing out insanely varying power levels, while keeping the RP'ing elements in (something Palladium's Heroes Unlimited was always afraid to do, making their name pretty ironic.)and encouraging play in-character with the Karma stat. It had some very good ideas for quick-and-nasty classification of hand-to-hand skills, and the "power feats" rules let you try any weird one-off stunts a hero did in a book, like Iceman using his powers to dry things out, or Captain America jumping off a building and using his shield to absorb the impact.
Here's an old online game site with some pretty good archived alternate-team Avengers RP'ing, and links to what online texts there are.
Marvel Super Heroes
 
 
hanabius yamamura
21:54 / 03.09.05
... I bought, but haven't played yet, the GURPS Superhero expansion ... might be worth a look as GURPS is good fun and highly flexible / customisable ...

h
 
  
Add Your Reply