BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


One Tree Hill (E4)

 
 
Dxncxn
15:50 / 30.08.05
It’s the Rolling Stones to The O.C.’s Beatles!* Or possibly just the Dawson’s Creek to its 90210.** It’s the programme about Basketball - although actually not so much anymore - with Chad Michael Murray (Tristan in Gilmore Girls/Charlie in Dawson’s Creek) in it, and series two began a month or so ago on E4, and I wondered if anyone else was watching...

High school tv is very much my thing, for whatever reason - I get more joy out of a pretty-good high school show than a cop show (or whatever) of a similar quality. Which is a round-about way of saying that even though it’s shaken off its early-season jitters & got back to its best, I wouldn’t bother recommending the show to anyone who isn’t predisposed to liking such things. But the disillusioned folk on the The O.C. thread might do worse than to give it a go. Because while it has the same problems as most high school tv - boring stories involving grown-ups, the occasional embarrassing episode about the dangers of drugs, a close-to-absolute lack of originality - unlike The O.C. these days, they don’t seem to have run out of ideas: there’s still some level of linear progression in the narrative, rather than endlessly looping break-ups & make-ups; they generally manage what, for me, is the most important trick, which is for the storylines to appear come naturally out of the characters they’ve created, rather than being awkwardly imposed on them. And it certainly doesn’t hurt that CMM is the best looking leading man on a tv show since Luke Perry.

So: what do people think of the new characters? Isn’t Brooke fantastic? Is that teacher of Karen’s really, as me and one of my mates decided recently, the least irritating teacher on tv ever? Has there ever been a worse theme tune? And, most importantly, I’d be very excited if anyone else was as amused as I was by Peyton’s ‘Finding Emo’ t-shirt last week.

I have loads more, but I thought I’d wait & see if anyone else was watching before I continued...

____________
* An assertion which is primarily tongue-in-cheek, although I think there are certain elements of truth to it.

** An assertion which I thoroughly support, but won’t go in to for fear of boring people.
 
 
gridley
19:23 / 30.08.05
I avoided One Tree Hill for most of season one, because I just had too many high school soap operas on my plate. Once I started watched though, I got fairly hooked. You're right to compare it to Dawson's Creek, I think. It's like Dawson's Creek, but about extroverts instead of introverts.

One Tree Hill has one of the best soap opera villians going in Dan (the evil father to the warring half-brothers).

The actress who plays Brook is very good too, and her character has had a really nice arc. I'm interested to see where it all goes.
 
 
Tryphena Absent
21:38 / 30.08.05
I don't really like One Tree Hill because it doesn't make the same kind of wider social statement that The OC does. The characters seem to be cut outs to me, stereotypes with nothing to infringe upon their culture. All of them are insiders in some way or another and no matter how hard they seem to threaten their own culture it's always their own. The thing that I continue to like about The OC, even when it seems to be losing its edge is that Ryan, no matter how much a part of his adopted world he becomes, has all these ties trying to pull him back. Lucas has all these ties trying to bring him in and he accepts them and then he gives his Coach this little speech about how much everyone needs him and I find it trite in precisely the same way that Dawson's Creek was. Dawson's Creek was of course quite an interesting show because it was really all about the slow destruction of Jen... they just didn't realise it, they thought it was about Dawson. One Tree Hill has one over on it because at least they realise the show is about Lucas and his relationship with Nathan.
 
  
Add Your Reply