BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Devil's Advocate - Movies

 
 
Jack The Bodiless
10:32 / 04.08.05
Based on the thread in Radio & Music - I thought it might be a laugh for us to take a movie/director/actor/genre/whatever that you either love wholeheartedly or hate unreservedly... and then tell everyone why that thing is either utterly shit or fucking wonderful. Think about how your favourite movie is vastly overrated, or how that actor you loathe is tragically underrated. You can treat it as an interesting writing exercise, a way of examining and reevaluating your preconceptions and prejudices, or just as as a bit of a crack. Posts over 500 words for preference, please for the love of God no lists, one liners or posts that end in "no, no, I can't keep this up...". And sarcasm, whether you're clearly just taking the piss, or clearly mugging someone else's argument to take the piss out of them, is verboten.

sentimentity got the hang of it in the other thread - here's another example:-

Stanley Kubrick is, of course, a genius. I use the present tense because the film-making oeuvre he's left behind, films that defy convention and casual genre-labelling, define the man. A perfectionist often accused of draining the emotion from his creations, Kubrick in fact instilled them with a complex balance of resonating emotional harmonics - there are no easy identifications in his movies, no obvious threads to follow or characters to empathise with. Stylistically the father of the baroque obsessive perfectionism seen in the work of David Fincher and the manic creativity of David O. Russell and, with Lean, a clear influence on the widescreen majesty of Ridley Scott's movies, his use of space and set in cinema has simply never been equalled, his eye for the perfect take, the perfect shot, the perfect composition - all unsurpassed both before and after his death.
 
 
Keith, like a scientist
12:35 / 04.08.05
And here I thought this thread was going to be about your love of Devil's Advocate with Pacino and Reeves.
 
 
Tuna Ghost: Pratt knot hero
18:47 / 04.08.05
It could be, couldn't it?
 
 
All Acting Regiment
20:38 / 04.08.05
You know, some people complain about Star Wars Episodes I-III. Some people who are adults. And they complain that a children's film is childish. I just don't understand that attitude. It's like saying that Action Man is shit because he can't defend your home.

They also say that any ounce of challenge or technical ingenuity has dissappeared out of the window in order to fit the "Blockbuster" formula of CGI and safe plots.

What these people suffer from is some kind of misguided idea that any given film is obliged to try and be an "artwork" as opposed to a "product": that it is obliged to challenge, as opposed to repeat, past sucesses.

This view of film's purpose might be a good one to aspire to, and one which i hope all of us here would carry out had we the chance; but it is simply not the one held by the majority of people who make films.

To complain endlessly and unproductively when people make crap films -criticism without intending to create an alternative- could be said to be pointless; on the other hand, to make your own films, or to help people who are trying to make good films, and to rejoice when good ones appear, is grand.
 
  
Add Your Reply