BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Stirling Eco-Village

 
 
Leidan
20:42 / 08.07.05
Hey guys, I've just come back from the Stirling eco-village. I thought you guys might like to hear about it; It was a pretty incredible place, both in terms of the community it managed to set up and perpetuate, and the political actions that went on around it and as a result of the planning ability it provided.

The eco-village was set up to be a base of political action against the G8 summit - but it also turned into a very cool experimental community. The site was perhaps around 3000 - 5000 strong between monday and thursday. It was organised with a basic grounding of rules regarding safety, and a list of job roles, but beyond (and even within) these basics there was *no* centralised authority, or at least none we could actually feel. It felt like every individual was empowered to the degree he or she desired; all the 'official' positions were filled by volunteer inhabitants of the village; not only could you freely become part of the power and organisational structure, you were encouraged and asked to do so. Within these roles it seemed that nothing impeded or retarded your 'progress' (i.e. how many decisions came down to you, how many people asked your advice, etc) other than your intelligence and creativity within the task.

The site was organised into 'barrios', small self-governing communities of perhaps between 20 and 150 each. Many barrios had their own kitchen, and many offered specific aid to actions - for example, transport, food, music, etc. Information was desseminated quickly using this system - barrios would almost always have representatives at central meetings, who could then quickly and effectively relay relevant information back to the barrio. The meetings themselves were amazingly effective on the whole, if sometimes long - they used the system i'm sure lots of you are familiar with, with central facilitators who theoretically are extremely unbiased with little sense of self, providing a structure for questions and points from, generally, *any* person present. This person was generally given an incredible degree of respect and authority, simply because he or she had chosen to speak. One example was when perhaps 50 or so people were standing at the back of a meeting in a crowd; a random girl right at the back requested we sit down for audio reasons; the instant the request was made all 50 individuals (most of them anarchists too!) sat down with no dissent or question.

This combined with the apparent intelligence of a number of people present made for apparently extremely effective insurgency planning. It all felt very organic. Although I'm not an experienced activist (which is why this has made such an impact on me), basically it seemed like the actions on wednesday morning - the blockades of the M9 and A9 - were very well planned and executed, considering the context and nature of the situation.

In a certain way the camp felt like getting out into nature - the structures of power were just not there. Everybody was doing their own thing, and pretty much nobody else got pissed off about it. The only time I saw grave disagreement was when the site tried to fit into the media hole; when we tried to make a statement to release to the press regarding the attacks on London. I find this very suggestive.

Generalising is foolish but fun, so: the main groups were pretty much intellectual students who were a bit frightened of extreme actions and a bit politically confused and/or fluffy(I'm one of these), old crusties who had lived on the edge too long, middle-aged working-class english anarchists, intense europeans, and a core of extremely influential, intelligent and balanced individuals who seemed to operate on anarchist principles combined with very strong political conviction.

So yeah, it seems like everyone left the site very empowered and with lots of ideas (especially about clowns; everybody loved the clowns. they are awesome.) I was going to describe some of the blockade actions, but it felt kind of indulgent... if you're interested though...

Cool, peace, love, etc,
Daniel
 
 
Tryphena Absent
01:17 / 09.07.05
I'm interested in the blockade actions and would love to hear anything else you have to add. Feel free to carry on describing, this is probably the part of the protests that I've found most interesting as I have read about the eco-commune elsewhere- I think it might have been in the press somewhere and it sounds like a very positive experience, particularly the way you describe the power structures in the commune.

I assume you mean The Clown Army when you say everybody loved the clowns, the whole clown idea strikes me as fantastic. I might go along to one of their introductory sessions when they next come into London.
 
 
Leidan
08:37 / 09.07.05
Yes! CIRCA! They are unbelievably awesome; in my opinion the most truly revolutionary insurgent force in the west. They question not just political but social and personal issues, which nevertheless run back to the political... the classic clown operation being highlighting the police officers' lack of humanity during a given operation; they don't laugh, don't interact, etc etc. Defusing the situation by making people laugh at it totally transcends the whole bipolar fighting thing... we're all just humans in the end, etcetc.

Also let's suppose that you or I want to be a member of CIRCA (which we do!) - what stops us? The only thing I can see is the mental blocks inside ourselves; our shyness and fear of others. The clowns make you question these hang-ups, which in turn makes you question the social structures which arguably perpetuate them.

I was talking to a continental clown the other day, and he had a whole damn philosophy! It was like, the feather duster tickling stuff makes the police or protestors actually *aware* of their bodies, maybe taking them out of their narrow mental role they defined for themselves, at least temporarily. Also when we got blockaded inside the village on thursday night, when riot police were at the gate and tempers were running high, he described how he went out there with a harpsichord and played sad night-music, as if the whole thing were a dream.. amazing!

So yeah, the clowns really act on protestors as much as police; I have to say that most protestors just have a conveyor belt mindset... like, walk down this road looking glum, take the set coach out of there. The legally sanctioned march in Auchterarder for instance was really boring (at least where I was away from the violence), until I played with a clown! soo cool.

So yeah definitely join the clowns; they are where it's at.
 
 
Broomvondle
14:49 / 10.07.05
I was at the Stirling Ecovillage too!

I was in the rather sedate People and Planet area, apologies for my lack of Anarchist-ness. I pretty-much agree with you're generalizations of the people there - I fell into the confused student category as well.

The decision making did seem to work reasonably, but you are glossing over some of the problems the site had. The model certainly was not sustainable for any length of time there were lots of indicators for this:

-The donation system for meals was losing money.

-People weren't returning the mugs and cutlery.

-People got drunk/stoned and fouled up the portaloos, so they went out of order rapidly.

-There was a period when someone was warning that a diarrhea outbreak was going to mean the site needed closing.

I am really interested in discussing how the model could be improved upon.
 
 
Broomvondle
14:52 / 10.07.05
Also I have to say the warning system wasn't foolproof, some random set off the blockade alarm in the middle of the night - because one police van was parked nearbye.
 
 
Leidan
19:25 / 10.07.05
It's true that that particular camp wouldn't have been sustainable, but those problems I think might not be totally fateful. The toilet thing; I think the compost toilets had no horror at all. I personally used the portaloos because that was what I was used to, but if there had ONLY been compost toilets then everything would've been cool, I think. Using them could have cleared up the illness problem too, perhaps...

Money was the main problem, obviously that entire system would have to be changed for a long-term living situation... the thing I think was really important about the site was the destruction of passivity and the beginning of personal inclusion in every process, so maybe if we followed those principles food-wise, everyone could contribute to buying their own barrios food (or the equivalent of a barrio) and cooking and serving the food, and then food would just be handed out freely to whoever, maintaining the free atmosphere.

As to the warning system, that was just funny and, I thought, interesting.. I was actually on the gate on I think monday night for the 1st or 2nd false alarm; we heard this voice echoing out of the darkness TWO POLICE COMING UP THE ROAD TWO POLICE COMING UP THE ROAD TWO POLICE COMING UP THE ROAD, this total crazy guy overreacting completely; then somebody in the gate overreacted, probably just hearing the word 'police' and forgetting the 'two' part, and rang the alarm, which had the whole camp up in arms. All this requires is a set of intelligent gate-people, which wouldn't be that hard... also hopefully if there were a long-term camp it wouldn't be in direct conflict with the police.

It's a shame you were in the P&P area; I went there quite a bit and the atmosphere was quite different, pretty enclosed. That's the price you pay for being with lots of youthful pretty people I guess... I was lucky, I didnt have a tent or a set group of mates to hang out with; I was forced to ask my local anarchist barrio for a place to stay... so I ended up sleeping in the 1 in 12 bar! And also wander round and absorb the atmosphere, which was really valuable. My email/msn is herewardthewake@hotmail.com if you're interested in talking about stuff.. cool!
 
 
Broomvondle
09:08 / 11.07.05
Cool. I'll put you on my MSN list. You might want to remove your email address from your last post so no-one gets hold of your email - use the private message function on the site to send an email address.

I like the fact that with no resources you were able to find a place to stay, that's a good sign. There were some excellent examples of free association like that. Me and some friends did help out in a barrio kitchen for example. You could see 'alienation' breaking down.

I'm not sure that in a temporary community of you can really develop the kind of reciprocating culture needed to sustain a donation system. I have always had more sympathy for Mutualist Anarchism so I wouldn't object to seeing a market mechanism running on the site. People could offer a small amount of their labour in return for food.

I totally agree on the toilet situation, the compost toilets did indeed rule, they are much cheaper, cleaner and more environmentally friendly than any alternatives. I was impressed, I don't know whether Glastonbury will adopt them any time soon though. I think the toilet situation was more indicative of the fact that people weren't all showing the level of self-responsibility that we would ideally like an anarchist community to evolve.

You're right the atmosphere in the P&P camp was entirely different but this was kind of neccessary as we have young sixth-form students in the groups who found the rest of the camp a little threatening, People and Planet didn't really belong there to be honest. Anyway, call me old fashioned but I still do like hanging around with sexy young liberals and chatting up Oxford theology students with big words like 'pantheism'. I'm totally un-radical, I know, I even went to Live8 because People and Planet were distributing tickets.

I think at the next opportunity we need to see the establishment of the first ever Barbelith barrio.
 
 
Whale... Whale... Fish!
11:34 / 11.07.05
Aw... man, I wish i'd been at the eco-camp!

From the pictures and articles on Indymedia it looked like a great, empowering experience!

I myself travelled to Gleneagles with WRP/SSP/Anarcho-groups, which was great in itself but I really wish I had experienced the Stirling Camp.

Roll on Heiligendamm 2007!
 
 
Whale... Whale... Fish!
11:39 / 11.07.05
On a side note about CIRCA...

A memory that will last for a while would be two clowns tickling a MET uniform. When the copper looked like he'd about had enough the female clown gave him a big hug and a kiss, and the male clown joined him. At this point the crowd around gave out a unified "aw...", obviously embarassing the cop as he turned away bright red!

Defeating the police state with love!
 
 
Cat Chant
09:57 / 16.07.05
I had a friend who was there, I think, with a big Gandalf banner saying "G8 POLICE - YOU WILL NOT PASS!", which backfired somewhat when all the policemen kept borrowing it to have their photo taken with it...
 
 
Grey Cell
11:15 / 18.07.05
I'm pretty sorry I didn't make it to Scotland after all now...

"I totally agree on the toilet situation, the compost toilets did indeed rule, they are much cheaper, cleaner and more environmentally friendly than any alternatives."

We've had one in a local squat (the local squat at the moment, sadly) for a couple of years now, and indeed, I'm still amazed at how well it works. Even the occasional drunk barfing/pissing in it doesn't seem to cause much harm.
The only drawback is that people aren't really motivated to go outside and use it in the winter when it's -15°C at night...

"When the copper looked like he'd about had enough the female clown gave him a big hug and a kiss, and the male clown joined him. At this point the crowd around gave out a unified "aw...", obviously embarassing the cop as he turned away bright red"

Yeah, and I wouldn't be surprised if the cops decided to play along nicely and just wait for a chance to take revenge once the witnesses were gone. Happened to a couple of our clowns after an action at a local detention camp for illegal immigrants. (didn't get beaten up, but that was about the only break they got - they were being hassled for hours)
Hell, I wouldn't even be surprised if they classified this as "assaulting a police officer" and clobbered the clowns... There's probably a law against ridiculing cops too.

I hope they won't fall apart the way the Tute Bianchi (sp?) did; I agree there's some really good ideas behind CIRCA. But I wouldn't count on too many of these getting across to the people (cops, telly watchers, ...) they're aimed at, even when given a fair chance.

It was pretty sickening to hear our national TV station describe the clowns as a scary horde of mindless huns in clown disguise. But then, after their coverage of our last Reclaim The Streets a couple of years ago, that really shouldn't have surprised me. I'm still fuming over that one too. Bastards.


And Broomvondle - don't bother apologizing for not being radical enough. Just be honest with yourself and go as far as you think is fit, not as far as some others would like you to go. Most "serious" anarchists will accept that, no need to feel bad about it. (I suffered from similar "am I for real" guilt trips the first year or so, it's just a waste of good energy)
 
  
Add Your Reply