BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


What's the last song that made you cry?

 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
 
Cat Chant
17:08 / 21.06.05
I think the Cohen version of Hallelujah has the definitive lyrics (not least because it contains the verse that goes you say I took the name in vain/I don't even know the Name/but if I did, well really, what's it to ya?). Hang on, though, is the Cohen one missing the verse that goes how to shoot somebody who outdrew ya? Because that is the other best verse in the song... But still, on the whole, I like the Cohen lyrics, and I just have a huge thing for Uncle Len's voice. I think the Jeff Buckely version is really beautiful and moving, but for me it works best as, well, as fanfiction - it's a loving and very interesting reworking of the song, but it's not the song. *prods brane in effort to see why* I think it's mostly because I find it a bit show-offy (that 40-second ooo in Halleloooooooojah, near the end); it feels a bit too crafted a performance of pain for me to give my heart to it, finally. I like my male voices affectless.

sorry for offtopic - let's get back to the weeping...
 
 
Withiel: DALI'S ROTTWEILER
20:58 / 21.06.05
The Rufus Wainwright version of "Hallelujah" makes me cry, but mainly because it's the only version that most people know due to the sodding Shrek soundtrack, and it really really doesn't suit his voice in the slightest.

The last song that made me cry was Leonard Cohen's Winter Lady, and it does so almost every time I hear it, because it fills my head with painfully beautiful images. Strangely, when I actually sing it, it makes me grin like a Cheshire Cat, though.
 
 
This Sunday
21:36 / 21.06.05
On the sad side: A week ago, I teared up somewhere early into Mari Ijima's 'No Limits' album - Because I'm weak, apparently.

Happy/bittersweet tears: Yesterday, Tom Waits, 'Somewhere', the cover - And anybody who doesn't get at least a little teary, must've lost their soul a long time ago.
 
 
Essential Dazzler
22:17 / 21.06.05
I can't really narrow it down to one song, as pretty much the whole album get's me teary-eyed, but "The Unauthorised Biography of Reinhold Messner" by Ben Folds five is just the most perfect piece of piano-based pop music ever produced.

"I love you/Goodbye"

"I left you awake to cry the tears/While I was dreaming in streams"

"From the back of your big brown eyes/I knew you'd be gone as soon as you could/and I hoped you would/we could see that you weren't yourself/and the lines on your face did tell/It's just as well/You'd never be yourself again"

"Lying awake in my hospital room/Silas Creek parkway is my only view/And the doctor just came by and told me the news/I need a second opinion/I don't believe that it's true"

Indeed.
 
 
Scrubb is on a downward spiral
22:20 / 21.06.05
Seem to be getting tearful to every other song I hear at the minute, but think that that's more about things being generally rather stressful rather than the universe conspiring to bombard me with upsetting tunes.

Best of You by the Foo Fighters seems to be pushing the "cry, dammit" button every time I've heard it recently. Partly I think because the first time I heard it was when feeling very low, and it's got tied into that. Also partly the lyrics about being tired of having to start again tying in with other things.

Also Anthem by Uncle Leonard Cohen for different reasons. Generally this works as a "injecting some ray of hope whilst feelin blue" thing but not at the moment.

Sorry. That was all rather whingy and non-insightful.
 
 
Bed Head
19:48 / 29.07.05
Wow, what a thread.

There’s an album, I think this is the CD version, of a tribute concert after Woody Guthrie - a bunch of frizzly folk-rock characters (Seeger, Arlo, Odetta, Dylan, Baez, Havens, etc) do a couple of concerts to commemorate Woody and to raise money for Huntingdon’s disease charities. This being 1968, they do it as a concept-album type piece about Woody Guthrie’s life story, and between songs we get readings from his autobiography and other writings. He’s a good writer, if you like that impassioned folksy beat-writer thing, which I do, and the readings are done by people like Will Geer, who I don’t know anything about, and Peter Fonda, who I kinda do.


It’s a record that never fails to make me cry. And I don’t want it to ever fail to make me cry, I don’t want the day to come when my heart has hardened and I *just* listen to it without getting knocked down and then lifted up by it. I’m aware that to a cynical ear it could very easily sound mawkish or overdone, and I so don’t ever want to think that. I save it up and don’t listen to it very often, so as not to wear out the effect.

So. It’s the closing sequence on side 4 that does it for me. First you get a song, ‘1913 Massacre’, which is about a load of kids and their families dying at the hands of a bunch of company enforcers, and mixed up with the bleak, mournful arrangement, it’s got this angry, burning resentment at this horrible crime inflicted by the rich on the dirt poor. Then the readings start and Judy Collins reads you a piece he wrote about his sister dying. She was caught up in a house fire, it’s pretty horrid, and Judy's voice falters and quavers as she reads, and her words are surrounded by that particular kind of auditorium silence where you can hear the sound of thousands of people being silent at the same time. It’s a horrible story, and then you get Claire’s deathbed words to Woody, something like ‘don’t you cry. Don’t you dare cry’ and the idea that Woody should laugh instead. And live.

And then a guitar strums and Odetta - booming, god-voiced Odetta - lets rip with ‘This Land Is Your Land’, and in the middle of that, a snippet of a reading fades in, with Will Geer reading out some of Woody Guthrie’s more famous lines, which go like this:

“I hate a song that makes you think that you are not any good. I hate a song that makes you think that you are just born to lose. Bound to lose. No good to nobody. No good for nothing. Because you are too old or too young or too fat or too slim too ugly or too this or too that. Songs that run you down or poke fun at you on account of your bad luck or hard traveling. I am out to fight those songs to my very last breath of air and my last drop of blood. I am out to sing songs that will prove to you that this is your world, and that if it has hit you pretty hard and knocked you for a dozen loops, no matter what color, what size you are, how you are built, I am out to sing the songs that make you take pride in yourself and in your work”,

...it's rousing stuff, and he reads it so as to rouse, and the audience fiercely roars approval and almost drowns out his voice before he can finish, and your heart bursts and lets go a ‘yeah!’. And then you wipe away your tears and switch off the record player and go and get some real work done/conquer the fucking universe. You’ve heard a horrible story about death, and then you are pretty much ordered to go and live your life. Right now.

It’s immensely powerful. It’s my ‘In case of emergency - play record!’ record that I should hang on the wall behind a glass panel. It can snap me out of the deepest funk. It’s very, very important that I don’t wear this record out. Because I’m rubbish at crying, I don’t cry easily, I tend to bottle it up if I’m unhappy, so it’s a *really* good, healthy, useful thing to have this trigger sitting on my shelf. A good cathartic cry followed by an instruction to bloody well get on with it. Rock.
 
 
Unencumbered
07:39 / 30.07.05
Red and Gold by Fairport Convention gets me every time. I sat and listened to it recently and just let the tears stream down my face. No other song has, at least for me, portrayed the stupidity and futility of war better.

Am I showing my age?
 
 
Seth
09:00 / 30.07.05
Not even Les Mortes Dansant by Magnum?
 
 
Jack The Bodiless
11:23 / 30.07.05
Although I really like Jack Fear's comparison of the two different versions of 'Hurt', because it's bloody well written and really made me think about them... like the twat I am I just have to disagree...

When Trent Reznor — a callow, whiny poseur, a millionaire superstar in his prime, with his whole life ahead of him and all the time he needs to repent — sings "Hurt," it's a fiction, a character song. Not a song about Trent Reznor, but a song about somebody else, looking back on what he's done, assessing his life's work and finding it vain.

No, it's really not. Leaving aside the issue of whether Reznor was a "callow, whiny poseur" at the time that he wrote The Downward Spiral, which is of course wholly subjective depending on whether you buy into Reznor or not... you can't analyse Nine Inch Nails' version of 'Hurt' using the same tools that you do Cash's cover. You're absolutely right, Jack, in your description of how Cash approached and covered the song - but he remade the song for himself, performed an almost matchless feat in modern music by appropriating 'Hurt' for himself and to represent his situation. That, coupled with the stunning video... still makes me cry. Months after his wife died, and on borrowed time himself, with a little help Cash crafted his own eulogy. I remember seeing the video on the end credits of Top Of The Pops 2 and afterwards feeling actually bereft - just alone, and very small. I felt misplaced, if that makes any sense... I'd just seen a man speak at his own funeral and bring the house down. Reznor, like Otis Redding before him with Aretha Franklin's cover of 'Respect', has pretty much given the song to Cash:

"The video he made of that song was overwhelming. When I saw it the power and beauty of music struck me in a really profound way. I was at a point in my life when I was really unsure if I was any good or if I had anything to say. The song came out of a really ugly corner of my mind and turned into something with a frail beauty. And then several years later an icon from a completely different world takes the song and juxtaposes himself into it in a way that seems more powerful to me than my own version. I was flattered as an artist and as a human being they could do that with my song. And it came at a very insecure time in my life and it felt like a nudge and boost and a hug from God. It said 'everything's OK and the world is bigger than what's just in my head.'"

Although The Downward Spiral was an experiment in writing 'in character', Reznor was never trying to look back over some fictionalised life. The intention was to extrapolate out of his own life a violently self-destructive, self-sufficent and self-centred persona, seeing what would happen if he examined his own life in detail in order to destroy it. He's said variously that it was a premonition of the junkie fuck-up his life would become, and a trial run before he wrecked himself... either way, on a record full of fear and loathing, it's the only song that admits that he might need help of some kind, and was written after the rest of the album was completely finished (he almost left it off because he thought it showed too much remorse for the screwed mess he'd written).

For all that "authenticity" is generally a debased coin, in this case it transforms the song from a self-pitying moan to something stately and honest and (to me, anyway) quite moving.

I'd disagree too that "authenticity is generally a debased coin" - the whole concept of what it means to be 'authentic' is a lot more complicated than that. Reznor's 'Hurt' is the sound of someone unsure if he has anything to give apart from shit (sorry, Deva!), to himself or anyone else. Cash's 'Hurt' is the sound of a man saying goodbye, acknowledging his regrets and declaring that he'd change it all if he could - but he can't. There's nothing 'inauthentic' in either, with the songwriter's version or the cover - and I think the only reason the concept of authenticity appears in any way 'debased' is because of it's appropriation by the narrow-minded for use as a blunt instrument to bludgeon music they don't appreciate. Either the indie fans declare it lacks something 'authentic' - a songwriting credit from the producer instead of the band, a too-obvious marketing campaign, whatever - or it's accused by your more hipster types of being crammed to bursting with signifiers of 'authenticity' to the extent that it's derided as overly-worthy reactionary sludge...

That may or may not make sense. I haven't slept, and I'm pretty fucked.
 
 
Unencumbered
12:52 / 30.07.05
Not even Les Mortes Dansant by Magnum?

Not even that. It's a fine song but it doesn't have the same emotional impact on me. A splendid singalong, though.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
14:33 / 30.07.05
For some reason Shivaree's "Mexican Boyfriend" has been getting me every time. Never having been in love with a guy who died in a car accident (or, indeed, been a "girl"), I can only assume it's the sound that does it...

It's the bit where she sings

What they said was the man drifted over the line
Drove you away and a little girl out of her mind
And the rain came down and washed off your face
Washed you away, left carnations and stone in your place


that always leaves me a wreck. And I don't know why.
 
 
Jack The Bodiless
15:27 / 30.07.05
U2's 'Sometimes You Can't Make It On You Own'. My parents split up last year, and my dad - one of the cornerstones of my life - moved permanently to California.

And it's you when I look in the mirror
And it's you when I don't pick up the phone
Sometimes you can't make it on your own


I know he's still alive. I know I haven't lost him. It just feels like it. And every time I hear this song, I well up. Bono lost his own dad last year. This song's about him, and, for me, about mine.

Where are we now?
I've got to let you know
A house still doesn't make a home
Don't leave me here alone...
And it's you when I look in the mirror
And it's you that makes it hard to let go
Sometimes you can't make it on your own


This always kills me. Every time. Still can't quite believe a current U2 song can do this to me. Life's a fucking odd thing. Still, there's something cathartic about it. Thanks, Hewson, you podgy bastard.
 
 
gridley
14:45 / 31.07.05
Oddly enough on all counts, it was Maggie Gyllenhaal singing Billy Joel's "Don't Go Changing" at the end of the film Happy Endings. Of course, it had a bit of push from the emotional resolving of various plotlines in the film, but the song itself was one I've never particularly cared for.

Maggie's singing was pretty terrific. Her voice reminded me a lot of Rilo Kiley's Jenny Lewis. Plus, she's a skilled enough actress that she can project the emotional moments of the song, without her singing suffering or going over the top.

The other songs she sings in the film are quite good too, but that's the one that brought a tear to my eye.
 
 
Jack The Bodiless
19:16 / 31.07.05
I'm assuming you mean 'Just The Way You Are'?
 
 
gridley
01:11 / 01.08.05
Ah, indeed I did. Thanks.
 
 
Shrug
01:50 / 09.12.05
Last year having stayed awake forty eight hours, a Coldplay song (I think it may have been The Scientist) coupled with the prospect of going into work made me breakdown in tears.
I didn't cry because of some wonderfully conveyed emotion on Chris Martin's part mind you, just because of nails down the blackboard sheer irritation inducing tone, video & sound of the song. Being a bit tired has to be factored in there somewhere too of course but I think the *actual* final straw was not being able to find the fucking remote.

I have to thank Coldplay for murdering my resolve to leave the house that fateful morn though as I got to spend the rest of the day snugly ensconced in bed and the crying left me with just enough throaty mucus remnant to make an effective "I'm sick" call to work.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
10:29 / 09.12.05
Current 93's Anyway, People Die just really upset me. I think it was the timing, really- it's an immensely sad piece of music anyway (it's a collaboration with Hilmar Orn Hilmarsson, with lots of big, mournful synths, and bells and stuff), and I was playing it while I was tidying up, and I found a whole shitload of dog toys I'd never been able to bring myself to throw out. If I'd planned on that, I'd have put something happier on, I guess.
 
 
Haus of Mystery
12:37 / 09.12.05
Umm.. I guess it's Neghborhood no.4 (7 kettles) off The Arcade Fire's Funeral. It was the day after a savagely shitty row with my girlfriend, work was unspeakably awful, so I curled up under a duvet, smoked a spliff and had a little bit of a well-up to this song. Their whole deal is very melodramatic and overwrought, but this song is so effortlessly achingly beautiful. A slow burner on an album of storming torch-pop, but it did the trick that day. Catharsis was achieved and the world kept on turning.
 
 
elene
13:44 / 09.12.05
Cat Power's "Good Woman." I think that was the most recent anyway. Happens every second time I listen to it.

I agree with Jack (The Bodiless), when he argues so eloquently about Hurt. Others: Downtown (when singing it for myself anyway), and "Bring it on Home to Me" (Sam Cooke - live - "I don't want you operator, ..."); and just generally when listening to "In The Aeroplane ..." too, like TeN. Buckely performing Hallelujah on the live DVD.

God, I do cry a lot!
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
21:49 / 09.12.05
Oh GOD 'Good Woman' destroys me. The bit where she sings "I will miss..." and the backing vocals go "I - will - miss" - arrrggghhhh. Hold me, someone.
 
 
chiaroscuroing
22:37 / 09.12.05
Been Drinkin' Water Out of a Hollow Log.

Mississippi Fred McDowell.

This is song always mankes my heart ache, Freddie, classic bottleneck slide guitar and a soft voice lined with humanity.

...Lord I'm gwoin' somewhere I ain't never been before.

Damn right Freddie.

And the transcendant,

Blind Willie Johnson - Dark was the night, cold was the ground.

No words, hymn like hums and wave like ah's that lap and roar.

Sumptuous and blue.
 
 
■
00:07 / 10.12.05
Sunshine on my Shoulder by John Denver. So many links to being a little kid, so many memories about my family. Don't play Denver to me unless you want big girly sobbing or stoic attempts to avoid same.
 
 
Jack Fear
00:19 / 11.12.05
Seeing as it's Christmas, I've dragged out Jane Siberry's double live set Child, and whilst I was making dinner the full-band version of "The Valley" just sucker-punched me. The harmonies coming in on the first chorus, so fragile, so hopeful... Jesus God my shepherd. Not outright weeping, but I surely misted and that's no lie.

My tears didn't start in earnest until a couple hour slater, when "It's A Wonderful Life" came on the TV: from the very first lines... "Lord, help George Bailey..." Bwaaaaaaahhhhhhh.
 
 
Mirror
03:36 / 11.12.05
Agreed about his other recent covers, though: as much as I wanted to like his versions of "The Mercy Seat" and "I See A Darkness" and such, they fell terribly flat for me.

Funny you mention that - I See a Darkness is the last song that made me cry. To each his own, I guess. As far as Hurt goes, after hearing Cash's version the original just seems sort of... dull.

As far as a song that makes me cry routinely, though, Stuart Davis's Swim is right up there - it's just simple and human and given the way that my grandmother is living out the last years of her life, it cuts right to the quick.
 
 
I rose like the phoenix
18:58 / 11.12.05
I love this thread... so many songs make me cry... I think the most recent one was probably 'The Luckiest' by Ben Folds.

Without going into long, personal detail, I've had a really rough few years. Had a really AWFUL break-up, health issues, etc.

Then I met someone who continues to be absolutely amazing. This song just makes me think of him, always.

'The Luckiest'

I don’t get many things right the first time
In fact, I am told that a lot
Now I know all the wrong turns, the stumbles and falls
Brought me here
*interrupts* It's this line here that hits me in the heart.

And where was I before the day
That I first saw your lovely face?
Now I see it everyday
And I know

That I am
I am
I am
The luckiest

What if I’d been born fifty years before you
In a house on a street where you lived?
Maybe I’d be outside as you passed on your bike
Would I know?

And in a white sea of eyes
I see one pair that I recognize
And I know

That I am
I am
I am
The luckiest

I love you more than I have ever found a way to say to you

Next door there’s an old man who lived to his nineties
And one day passed away in his sleep
And his wife; she stayed for a couple of days
And passed away

I’m sorry, I know that’s a strange way to tell you that I know we belong
That I know

That I am
I am
I am
The luckiest
 
 
Cat Chant
13:09 / 12.12.05
ooh, haven't looked at this thread in ages.

The last song to make me cry was the Doctor Who theme song, when I watched the last season on DVD the other week. I've always loved that tune - I think it's so otherwordly and eerie and splendid - and hearing it again reminded me strongly of being a young kid in the living-room in my parents home, just wishing so much that someone would take me away from all the claustrophobia and muffled emotions. In a TARDIS, if need be.

I don't think I ever articulated any of those huge feelings to myself at the time; I just stored them in the theme tune, and downloaded them as tears twenty years later.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
14:20 / 12.12.05
Current 93 again, I'm afraid... in the pub this afternoon, feeling sorry for myself, and yet again, they were a bad choice. "A Sadness Song"... it doesn't help that it was the version with Rose McDowall on vocals- I don't know if it's just me, but her voice is always beautiful and sad. (One of the reasons why Strawberry Switchblade's album is, to me, the greatest post-Beatles pop album in the world).
 
 
grant
14:49 / 13.12.05
It's an odd little song on one of Rizla's comps, a track called "The Leanover" by Life Without Buildings. It consists of a noodly little repetitive/meditative guitar line that builds nicely into a chorus then stops and quiets down into the verse, so it feels like you do after some kind of strong emotional trauma -- that wavelike sense of things spinning tighter then stopping abruptly while you catch your breath, then starting up again.

The vocals are waiflike and appear to be completely improvised, like the chanted thoughts of a sidewalk schizophrenic or acid casualty -- "contact contact contact, can you feel it? can you feel it?" It's a song that feels like it's striving for meaning.

This is kind of what I wanted when, as a college kid back in the 80s, I heard there was a new band called "The New Bohemians." I wanted this. It wasn't this. It's kind of, well, nutty, but a little too melancholy or nostalgic to be laughable.

I was listening to this song over and over again in the Wilma aftermath, so maybe that was part of it, too. Chaotic, but sweet.

There's an mp3 of the acoustic version and a (broken?) ram file of the album version on the band's audio page. There's an excerpt available as a stream here.
 
 
electric monk
14:30 / 14.12.05
'S funny what storms can do to us, isn't it?

Mine's Demon Days by Gorillaz. The song mainly, but also the whole album to some extent. This CD was a constant in my player around the time of Hurricane Katrina, and the one became wrapped around the other so that I really cannot put the album on without being transported back to those first days after the storm watching the coverage on the news, feeling fucking helpless, knowing it could have been me and my family and friends trapped in attics, etc.

Choice Katrina-overlaid, tear-inducing snippets include:

Are we the last living souls?
Are we the last living souls?

-----

I need a gun to keep myself from harm
The poor people are burning in the sun
And they ain't got a chance
They ain't got a chance
I need a gun
Cuz all I do is dance

-----

Seems like everybody's out to test ya
Till they see you break
You can't conceal the hate that consumes ya

...filled with guilt
From things that I've seen
Your water's from a bottle
Mine's from a canteen
At night I hear the shots ring
So I'm a light sleeper
The cost of life seems to get cheaper.

-----

Melancholy town where we never smile
And all I want to hear is the message beep
My dreams, they come and kiss me
Cuz I don't get no sleep.

-----

(picturing Dubya's face in my head during the laugh on "Feel Good, Inc.")

-----

God only knows it's getting hard
To see the sun coming thru
I love you
But what are we going to do?

-----

In these demon days, we're so cold inside.
It's so hard for a good soul to survive.
You can't even trust the air you breathe.
Mother Earth wants us all to leave.
The lies become reality.
You love yourself
And trust the TV.
Pick yourself up, it's a brand new day
So turn yourself round
Don't burn yourself
Turn yourself
Turn yourself around to the sun.


It's troubling to me, because I love the album but I know I've forged associations that I'll never be able to leave out of the listening experience. Katrina's aftermath will always play out to "Last Living Souls". The mess at the Superdome will always be soundtracked by "Kids with Guns". Dubya will always laugh. That impotent rage and immense sadness I felt will always be readily accessible to me by just pressing "PLAY".

"Demon Days" is on the player now, and I am tearing up something fierce. The mournful violins fade up and I can feel myself slump in my seat. The opening verses kinda keep me in stasis there, hanging in this funk. And then this angelic choir comes in, moving me to sadness beyond measure. In that minute or two, I seriously question the viability of the human race and pray for succor. And in the end, it comes, picking me up from that depth and taking me above. Helping me turn myself around. To the sun.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
16:32 / 14.12.05
I was fairly emotional, really quite close to tears while listening to a lot of 'Down In Albion' by Babyshambles.

I was so torrrid with feelings that I had to put the thing in the bin, in the end.
 
 
lonely as a cloud...
13:45 / 16.12.05
Just last night, I was getting a lift to the tram station from my mother, and there was a Makem & Clancy CD in the player. Tommy Makem and Willy Clancy, incidentally, were an Irish folk duo of the 60's and 70's, who made rollneck Aran sweaters quite popular in the US when they first visited in the 60's - because one of their mothers had knitted some for them just before they went there.
Anyway. One of their most popular and well-known songs is The Dutchman. And it always makes me feel weepy. It's about an old Dutchman and his wife.
"The dutchman still wears wooden shoes
His cap and coat are patched with love that Margaret sewed in
Sometimes he thinks he's still in Rotterdam
He watches tugboats down canals
And calls out to them when he thinks he knows the captain
'Till Margaret comes to take him home again
Through unforgiving streets that trip him though she holds his arm
Sometimes he thinks that he's alone and calls her name"
I dunno why, really, it just tears me up for no particular reason.
 
 
Cowboy Scientist
18:21 / 14.08.06
Okay, I'm bringing this thread back from the dead!

This song makes me cry like a bastard... it reminds me of a girl I was really in love with, when I was 14-to-16 years old, but it all turned out wrong... it still makes me teary-eyed... anyways... the song is kinda-known, because it was in the Cowboy Bebop soundtrack, I think it was the only song they used not made specially for the show.

Call Me Call Me by Steve Conte (click for the mp3)

I close my eyes and I keep seeing things
Rainbow waterfalls
Sunny liquid dreams
Confusion creeps inside me raining doubt
Gotta get to you
But I don't know how
Call me call me
Let me know it's alright
Call me call me
Don't you think it's 'bout time
Please won't you call and
Ease my mind
Reasons for me to find you
Peace of mind
What can I do
To get me to you

I had your number quite some time ago
Back when we were young
But I had to grow
Ten thousand years I've searched it seems and now
Gotta get to you
Won't you tell me how
Call me call me
Let me know you are there
Call me call me
I wanna know you still care
Come on now won't you
Ease my mind
Reasons for me to find you
Peace of mind
What can I do
To get me to you
Come on now won't you
Ease my mind
Reasons for me to find you
Peace of mind
Reasons for livin my life
Ease my mind
Reasons for me to know you
Peace of mind
What can I do
To get me to you
 
 
MattShepherd: I WEDDED KALI!
19:06 / 14.08.06
Apocryphal story, but it still makes me get sniffly every time I hear a certain song.

Before I was in high school, its senior choir (sort of a jazz combo thing, think Manhattan Transfer type stuff) was participating in a province-wide competition/festival for, well, senior choirs. They were pretty good, and practiced their faces off for months, and were pretty much psyched to rule the province-wide choir competition. Oddly enough, one of the other choirs, a stiff competitor, hadn't shown up shortly before the competition started, but whatever.

Among the repertoire was "Tuxedo Junction," "I'll Be Seeing You" and "After The Gold Rush" (yes, the Neil Young song, and it actually sort of works when sung by a bunch of fifteen-to-eighteen-year-olds a capella. Weird but true).

Then they found out that the reason that one of the other choirs hadn't shown up is that there'd been some sort of van accident and two of the choir members in the other choir had been killed. Everyone was pretty shaken; I don't think anyone in our senior choir was close friends with the kids that had died, but in small towns neighboring small towns, everyone is a friend of a friend, and besides, the older members of the choir had been seeing these other kids at competitions for two or three years by now. They knew them on a nodding basis at the very least.

The show must go on, though, and "Tuxedo Junction" goes off without a hitch, but right around "the chestnut tree/the wishing well" in "I'll Be Seeing You," one of the choir members starts sniffling. And then it's just a shuddering emotional train wreck, as the baritone starts bawling and then everyone's crying, standing on stage and sobbing and the conductor -- our music teacher -- can't even get it together enough to usher everyone off stage, because he's crying too, and the audience, none of whom probably know anything about what the hell is going on, watches this group of sparky young teens in sequined bow ties just fucking collapse on stage.

They didn't win.

The music teacher left the school the following year, and I was told this story when I joined senior choir. I don't know if it's true or not, but the older senior choir members swore to it, and they were (in theory) in school when this happened.

So maybe it's all crap. I was 15 or so when it was told to me, and ever since then I've choked up when I hear "I'll Be Seeing You." Most recently last week, on the radio, during a documentary on WWII veterans.
 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
  
Add Your Reply