BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Iraq war victim's mother taking Blair to court

 
 
Ganesh
12:06 / 29.04.05
It seems the publication of Lord Goldsmith's initial report has provoked at least one court action, as reported in today's Scotsman:

Mrs Gentle, of Pollok in Glasgow, revealed her intentions after it emerged that the Attorney General warned the Prime Minister that British ministers and troops could end up in court over the war.

Today, at a press conference in East Kilbride, where Mrs Gentle is standing against Armed Forces Minister Adam Ingram, she said: "We want justice not just for Gordon but for all the boys killed in Iraq and for all the Iraqis that have been killed.

"I am now seeking legal advice to take Tony Blair to court for war crimes because I believe he is responsible for my son’s death, responsible for the rest of the boys’ deaths.

"It is time we all stood up to the Government and told them that we are not going to take any more of their lies."

Human Rights lawyer Aamer Anwar is acting for Mrs Gentle. He said: "We will fight tooth and nail to get Tony Blair into court.

"Mr Blair owes the life of many sons and daughters, a debt he can never repay.

"Tony Blair sent Gordon Gentle to die for oil. He claimed this war was to stop weapons of mass destruction, but we now know it was for the illegal aim of regime change.

"This is now the time for accountability – over 88 British servicemen killed, over 100,000 innocent Iraqi victims, men, women and children dead.

"Tony Blair and his ministers for war such as Adam Ingram are not fit to hold office and we intend to use this election and the courts to make them pay the price because they are nothing more than accomplices to murder."

He added: "The first action is to seek a judicial review under Article 2 of the European Convention On Human Rights.

"The Government have a positive duty to protect life and that responsibility was undermined by the decision to proceed to war on an illegal basis."


Rose Gentle adds, "I am not a politician trying to score cheap political points but a mother seeking justice for my son, who was killed serving in Iraq.".

Does the fact that this is being initiated by a grieving mother make it easier or harder for Blair to dismiss?
 
 
Not in the Face
13:19 / 29.04.05
I'd say it makes it easier for him to dismiss it because I she can't hope to achieve anything through the courts. From what the article says she hopes to hold Blair accountable for the death of her son when it was the entire government - including the Labour party really, that made the decision. And no UK court is going to commit itself at this stage to judging its own government guilty of war crimes. Its also not clear that he did lie etc, in a way that could be proven in court given the immense latitude that prime ministers have in this country.

It would be far better for a political organisation to take Blair up on some issue regarding the parliamentary process and clarifying the prime minister's obligations in these situations. This would be more useful to the country, and be an area the courts would be happier to make a decision on.
 
 
Mourne Kransky
21:44 / 29.04.05
Mrs Gentle has Right and Reason on her side. TB lied to take us to war. We know he lied to take us to war, qed. He decided to go to war way back in 2003, or before, and shaped every public utterance thereafter with that in mind, while he tried to find an acceptable way to say "I've promised George, therefore one hundred thousand Iraqis must die, and Mrs Gentle's son."
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
15:08 / 30.04.05
I don't think it was the entire government that made the decision was it? Even discounting the whole 'Blair promised the previous summer' conspiracy theory, it was Blair or possibly Blair + Cabinet that committed the country to military action wasn't it? Even if the Commons had somehow developed a spine and voted no, Blair was in no way required to pay any attention to that.

Sadly this has almost zero chance of going anywhere. I seem to recall several groups tried similar measures just before/ just after war was declared and they were all dismissed by the courts. I doubt this will be any different.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
16:14 / 30.04.05
I, too, think the poor lady doesn't have a chance in hell. But I'm glad she's doing it- it keeps the pressure on, keeps it a "live" issue. Added to which, it's about all she can do, and she has my best wishes.
 
  
Add Your Reply