BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Casanova

 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
20:09 / 04.04.05
"Now... mine doesn't do that."

Russell T Davies has knocked it out the fucking park with this one. David Tennant should play the hero of everything from now on, and would/will make a great Doctor Who, probably better than Ellecleston. Nina Sosanya finally gets a role in something good after being the best thing in Teachers, one of the few likeable people in Nathan Barley, and... shit, she was in Love Actually too? The poor woman. Matt Lucas is hilarious. GitFromSpooks is suitably gittish. Door from Neverwhere has not aged, disturbingly.

I really hope you're all watching this.
 
 
■
20:43 / 04.04.05
Double celebration!

i) Casanova is fantastic and I can't wait for next Monday
ii) I agree for once with everything Fly says in a post and have little to add except: "Bloody Hell!"

Remarkable.
 
 
Eloi Tsabaoth
20:46 / 04.04.05
Doesn't David Tennant strike you as a bizarre combination of Dudley Moore, Kenneth Connor and Rollo Kim, but in a good way?
 
 
Tryphena Absent
21:58 / 04.04.05
I'm a bit disturbed by the reviews that this show has received? What were those people watching because I thought it was fabulous?!!
 
 
■
22:06 / 04.04.05
Not very much given the slackness of the BBC previews dept in getting tapes of it out. I asked for every episode and they failed to send any.
 
 
Nobody's girl
23:02 / 04.04.05
Not bad eh? I saw David Tennant in "Takin' Over the Asylum" recently thanks to a lovely internet archivist, so I had a shrewd idea he'd kick ass and he certainly did not disappoint. He'll make a great Doctor, hooray!
 
 
Whisky Priestess
23:16 / 04.04.05
Hmm. I like some of the humour but I think it's a bit too shiny-funky jump-cut pop-video wacky for my taste. Plus the fact that, against all historical likelihood, RTD or the casting director seems to feel the need to sprinkle every single scene with at least 50% random ethnic minorities - why?? Ironically, if Othello, the most conspicuous black Venetian in literature*, appeared in Casanova's multicultural Venice, he wouldn't even stand out in the crowd.

Mind you, I suppose that's the least of the grating anachronisms ... and it is quite fun, although I still think the entire cast has been fed too much tartrazine before bedtime.

* anyone know if he was a historical figure too? I'm curious now ...
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
07:36 / 05.04.05
I don't think Othello's strictly historical - Shakespeare possibly took the story from Cinthio's Gli Hecatomithi (the hundred stories)... Ruskin claims that the Venetian Doge Cristopher Moro (presumably Christopher the Moor?) was the basis of Othello, but I don't know whether this has ever been substantiated.

I caught the last quarter of an hour of this, and enjoyed it a lot more than I expected - enough to make me wish I'd seen the rest. The adverts did it a huge disservice, I think - not realising it was RTD, I expected a Neil Morrissey nobathon with nice dresses, which it seems not to have been, although I was a bit hacked off that the castrato turned out to be a girl. Boooo!

And yes - Door is uncannily preserved. The only way we can tell that she has become a woman is that she has not been cast in Neil Gaiman's no-doubt-epochal MirrorMask.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
08:13 / 05.04.05
I was a bit hacked off that the castrato turned out to be a girl

I think RTD probably struck the right note here though, in terms of bringing in what one might call a queer sensibility whilst keeping Jacko basically heterosexual*.

Jacko starts off all cocky and "I can tell she's a girl unlike the rest of you fools", but he's then convinced that Bellino is a boy and forced to admit/realise that it doesn't really matter, he still would. Only then once he's accepted B as male is he allowed to see B as female - I think it's much easier to be hacked off about the fact that he then says "right, now you don't need to bother dressing up as a boy anymore!", except for the fact that we still have lines about the fact that Jacko is the wife in the relationship, and for the possibility that things will be complicated further in the next two episodes.

I do like the fact that other than pursuing Bellino (and presumably Henriette), we haven't seen Casanova doing much active, successful seducing. Both the girl who first initiates him and the two sisters completely take the lead - and none of these people are 'conventionally' attractive. Now I'm not going to suggest that that's 'subversive' because the same thing tended to happen to Robin Asquith, but it is interesting, as is the fact that these examples portary underage sexuality and heavily implied incest respectively in positive terms.

*Not that I think a writer has to do that, but I get this suspicion that this writer might have set himself that constraint, almost as a formalistic challenge.
 
 
Scrambled Password Bogus Email
08:32 / 05.04.05
It's advert free on BBC3...And 3 weeks ahead of Terrestrial.
(Scans quite nicely for another couplet, but I can't think of a rhyme for 'Terrestrial')
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
09:58 / 05.04.05
DOOR! Fuck, I KNEW I knew her!
 
 
Olulabelle
10:09 / 05.04.05
I watched the first scene with the 'comedy' missing-the horse jump followed by some Benny Hill style running around over Venitian Bridges, and then I switched it off to do something less boring instead.

Perhaps I should not have?
 
 
■
11:49 / 05.04.05
(Scans quite nicely for another couplet, but I can't think of a rhyme for 'Terrestrial')

I can, it starts with B and would probably be apposite to the discussion, even if it's not in the programme.
 
 
adamswish
09:16 / 08.04.05
Door from Neverwhere has not aged, disturbingly.

Thank you fly, that explains the odd sensation when I watched this that I knew her from somewhere.

Doesn't David Tennant strike you as a bizarre combination of ...and Rollo Kim, but in a good way?

Thank you Bizunth, for the same reason I'm thanking Fly and for making me spit tea all over the works computer.

And if you thought the first episode was good wait for the other two of the series (aw the benefits of having freeview at home).

Although my favourite part is during Jack's rise in society and he turns to the camera and says: "This is begining to scare me."

And shame on the lot of you for not falling to your knees in respect and awe at Peter O'Toole.
 
 
Scrambled Password Bogus Email
10:11 / 08.04.05
Cube - yes, yes, but I've always pronounced that with the 'e' as 'ea', like its derivation. Must try harder!
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
07:33 / 10.04.05
Tennant has the most wonderful blue eyes. There's a nice long scene in episode three where you get to bathe in their limpid wossnames. I'll wait until you terrestrial types have caught up...
 
 
Tryphena Absent
20:00 / 11.04.05
I don't understand why so many reviewers have claimed that it is difficult to get from Tennant to O'Toole. I can easily imagine one becoming the other later in life. Are critics simply lacking in imagine (not that it takes very much) or are they being deliberately wank?
 
 
■
20:58 / 11.04.05
Oh, shit. I knew there was something I meant to watch tonight. Grr [scampers off to UKNova].
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
21:20 / 11.04.05
Casanova, on arriving in England: "A lot of the men are homosexuals. That could be something to do with the milk."

Now, is it me, or is the question of whether or not milk makes you gay one that has only been asked previously on Barbelith?
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
14:47 / 19.04.05
Absolutely.

Does anyone have the final ep. on video? The tape containing it (and Dr. Who arrgh bollocks) got eaten.
 
 
Spatula Clarke
16:02 / 19.04.05
Are critics simply lacking in imagine (not that it takes very much) or are they being deliberately wank?

Deliberately wank. There's a huge gap in the story's timeline from the last time we see Tennant as Casanova to O'Toole's version. It's only really a valid complaint if you live on a planet where people stay exactly the same for their entire lives, and I'd suspect that anyone making it was only doing so because they couldn't find anything worth complaining about. Either that or they'd written their review and found they had some word count left over.

Only saw the second and third parts, but loved them. There was a natural flow and movement to everything - especially the script and directing - which totally sucked me in.

Shame that we were left with no opportunity to absorb it at the end, though, what with Phil fucking Mitchell screaming all over the credits. Pet peeve at the moment, as if you couldn't tell - it's like the BBC have got a warning siren installed that goes off whenever there's been more than 58 minutes of programing without any violent misery.
 
 
Warewullf
16:20 / 19.04.05
I loved this series. Thought it was absolutley great fun. Funny and surprisingly touching in all the right ways.

That last episode was fantastic. Loved the way that er... wassername, the castrata, changed from wonderfully optimistic to obscenely decadent.

A great series but I can totally understand why some (most?) people wouldn't like it. To put it Irishly, too modren!
 
 
■
21:44 / 22.04.05
what with Phil fucking Mitchell screaming all over the credits
Mitch Benn did a great skit on the Now Show about that tonight. I think I may be becoming a sentimental old fool, but that's twice in a month I've blubbed at a drama. Gawd bless P.O'T.

ps. Haus, I would recommend UKNova, I think the ep3 torrent should still be there.
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
14:56 / 23.04.05
The dueling scene where we go from hating the rotter to feeling pity for him to hating him again when he finds a way to screw Casanova over was masterly.

But I feel we were at the mercy of some slightly crappy editing, or perhaps RTD thought he had more time to play with. So Casanova's son, after being mute for the preceeding one and a half episodes is suddenly talking and this isn't mentioned. The 'flashbacks' for the death of Rocco was a bit off too, seeing as he was as much a friend to Casanova as his servent. And the guy they got to play the older son of Casanova didn't look much like the younger actors either.

But otherwise, big yays for this.
 
  
Add Your Reply