BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Carter Beats the Devil

 
 
Loomis
13:52 / 18.01.05
I'm sure I've noticed a few mentions of this book on Barbelith in the past but there doesn't seem to be a thread on it so here goes.

I adored it. Just delightful. I've never had any particular interest in magic but was looking forward to that part of the novel after reading Kavalier & Klay, and I found it to be presented very smoothly. Just enough detail to make you feel like you understood what he was doing, but without giving much away. The two novels often get mentioned together which is inevitable I suppose, and I must say that although I liked K & K, I enjoyed Carter much more. I think it skipped along more lightly and didn't get bogged down on any one thing. The plot was paced evenly and the hand of the author was rarely seen.

My envy of Gold for writing this as his first book has only been soothed by learning yesterday that this is in fact the fourth book he has written, though only the first to see the light of day. Daunting yet encouraging for those of us with the same aspirations.

Hmmm. Not sure what I have to add really unless we get a discussion going. Only finished it two days ago and am still in gushing mode. Anyone got anything constructive to add? What did you like or dislike about it?
 
 
Jack Fear
14:13 / 18.01.05
Yes, a fantastic book. The way historical novels should be—it rewards, but does not demand, knowledge of the period—and although Gold has obviously done extensive research, he never shoves it at you in a show-offy sort of way.

Like using "Fun In High Skule," who were in fact the Marx Brothers, as background characters. If you don't know that they were the Marx Brothers, it doesn't effect your enjoyment of the book as you're reading it. If you find it out later, then you go "Holy shit!" and immediately go back and re-read all the sections they were in. And if you know your Marx Brothers trivia before you start reading carter Beats the Devil, then get a little extra chuckle.

A lesser writer would tip his hand with an expository sentence or two...

"You know," said Julius, "I've been thinking we should change the name of the act. What's wrong with 'The Marx Brothers'?"

...or some other such cack. Gold is a wise and graceful writer.

And the section on young Charles's first escape—the snowbound house, the drunken caretaker, the rusty torture devices—Christ, it's been a year since I read the book and it gives me chills just thinking about it.
 
 
admiral sausage
20:23 / 18.01.05
A really beautiful book, will re - read now knowing the Marks Brothers stuff.

Ive been looking out for any new material from Glen David Gould, he did write a short story in Mc Sweeney's Mammoth Treasury of Thrilling Tales, about the execution (by hanging) of a circus elephant. Well worth picking up (good shorts by Michael Moorcock and Elmore Leonard too),
 
 
Ariadne
09:47 / 26.01.05
SPOILERS!





Just finished. Cracking book, good pace, interesting subject to build a story around. If I'd one criticism it would be that the character of Carter kind of passed me by. I didn't ever really believe that magic had saved his sense of self, and that without it he'd be the scared little boy again - he seemed quite a cocky chap to me. So while the knife through his hand was gruesome, I couldn't quite get into the whole 'will I ever be the same again?' vibe. He was likely to have to get a job at the local call centre anyway, with his financial situation so far up the spout.

Having something like the magic as a setting is very handy - it gives a whole background for the action and characters to work around. Personally, I'd have liked to hear more about how it worked - that would be really interesting. For instance, when Griffin handcuffed Mysterioso and the handcuffs jumped onto his own wrists my initial reaction was 'that's dumb', and I'd have enjoyed it more if there was some indication of just how that coudl possibly happen. But then I suppose Gold would be strung up by the Magic Circle with his head in a brank, if he actually gave away 'trade secrets'. Assuming he knows them in the first place.

It was just nicely done, with a good mix of the prosaic day to day events and the more fairy-tale aspects - the friendly lion, the pretty blind girl, and the evil blank-eyed enemy magician.
 
 
The Return Of Rothkoid
01:00 / 09.02.05
Interesting to see you hadn't read this, Loomis - I would've thought you'd devoured it long ago!

I read a copy of it just after it came out, and really enjoyed it. I thought it seemed a little more forced than Kavalier and Clay, but yanno, I've always had a thing for stage-magicians of the oldschool sort.

So yes. Enjoyable, but also a little disappointing, is how I recall it.
 
  
Add Your Reply