BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Theatre ends play in Sikh protest

 
 
Warewullf
15:44 / 20.12.04
From the BBC:

A play which led to violent protests among the Sikh community in Birmingham has had its run cancelled by the city's Repertory Theatre.
...
Three police officers were hurt during clashes after 400 demonstrators gathered outside on Saturday.


So what do we think about this? Did the protesters have the right to forcibly stop a play that they found offensive? Did it really attack their religion as a whole?

And what about this part:
"We have nothing against freedom of speech, but you do not make a mockery of someone's faith or beliefs. That is oppression."

That's a bit much, isn't it? It's not an attack against the whole religion, rather a stroy about abuses going on in one temple. And even it were a damning critique of the religion as a whole, so what? Christians have to deal with that every day, why should anyone else be exempt?
 
 
LykeX
19:55 / 20.12.04
One thing I wonder about things like this is, all the people who were protesting, wrecking other people's property and even causing personal injury, had they all seen the play? If not, how did they really know that the play portrayed them infairly?

I have a tendency to put these things in the class of mass hysteria.

Of course, the only thing I know about this is the bbc article.
 
 
w1rebaby
20:28 / 20.12.04
The theatre itself has a message board - I haven't checked it all yet but it seems to have been fairly thoroughly trolled.

Obviously I've not seen the play but from all I've read it sounds like the author simply had the temerity to include some authority figures in a less-than-favourable light, rather than being in any way "anti-Sikh"; I'm therefore leaning towards it being a result of conservative elements organising and stimulating outrage. And clearly I'm not going to approve of that.

On the other hand it's being tied in to the recent Dutch murder and so on in what feels to me like a rather worrying "these brown people with their primitive autocratic religions" way, and I'm a little wary of that. The news coverage I just saw on ITV for instance seemed to be quite happy to portray it as "the Sikh community turning on one of their own" rather than, say, there being any comment from Sikhs who are on any other side.

Interesting comment here:

The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Birmingham, the Most Reverend Vincent Nichols, said: "Such a deliberate, even if fictional, violation of the sacred place of the Sikh religion demeans the sacred places of every religion."

He's clearly aware of the utility to him of any precedent set here, then.
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
21:02 / 20.12.04
it sounds like the author simply had the temerity to include some authority figures in a less-than-favourable light, rather than being in any way "anti-Sikh"

Well, the fact that the action, including a rape, takes place in a Sikh Temple - although where the Roman Catholic church was in the last act of "End of Days" I have no idea. There is also an argument that the Sikhs protesting outside were protesting peacefully, and things kicked off when drunken people spilling out of pubs started a ruck. I'm not sure about the accuracy of those reports.

I can understand why the Rep took this decision - especially when children would be coming to see the kids' show at the same time - but it sets a bad precedent. If it's moved to a less breakable venue, as has been offered, it needs to be protected. It's a business decision for the Rep. On the plus side, it will now sell out every night in a new venue...
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
22:06 / 20.12.04
As far as I know, the author is herself a Sikh...
 
 
Ganesh
02:14 / 21.12.04
Am I right in thinking it's a comedy? If so, it strikes me as something of a Sikh joke.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
05:15 / 21.12.04
According to R4 news, another theatre in the area is already looking to show it.
And apparently the Independent today carries a transcript of the offending scene... on the front page.

So not quite the victory for mob rule we'd feared.
 
 
LykeX
07:24 / 21.12.04
Nice one, 'Nesh.
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
08:06 / 21.12.04
A spokesman on Newsnight said the Sikh community had been demonstrating peacefully for a week and then, on Saturday night, young Sikhs who didn't wear turbans came out of the pub and decided to get lairy. But on reading the extract there was no attacking the faith. Hopefully it'll be restaged at some point.

In fact, I think the last thing that attacked a faith was either 'The Last Temptation of Christ' or 'Satanic Verses', most of the complaints about things since then have tended to be from various church officials worried that whatever they're complaining about damages their self-appointed position of importance and influence in the community.
 
 
foot long subbacultcha
14:29 / 21.12.04
I've grown up as a product of the Sikh community. I don't call myself a Sikh, but I misleadingly wear a kara. I haven't seen the play but now I want to. If anything, this has been great publicity for the author. I don't want to sound too cynical. She has been threatened with death and kidnapping, which unfortunately is typical in certain elements of the community as I've experienced within my own family.

It's really sad for me to see Sikhs getting pictured in the media like this. It only takes a few extreme elements, some of them ignorant Brits, some of them naive traditionalists fresh off the boat from Punjab, to make a public mess. Sikhism is largely unknown even in Britain and it's a shame that this is how it's presented. The religion was formed as a struggle of freedom for all and was way ahead of its time in terms of promoting equality in all respects.

There are deep rooted problems, though. But that's the way with all faiths. Sikhism has people who desperately want it to survive in a traidtional form, at the hypocritical cost of certain freedoms and desires for expression. The problem is that it's hard to acknowledge this from the outside, because it's a relatively small, relatively new religion (despite the massive unsung contributions Sikhs have made to the world).

Things will change within the community as more young artists begin to express themselves. It's just a shame that these growing pains have had to cause such a damaging noise in front of millions.

I'm very annoyed about this. I have a dream novel I'd like to write one day set in the times of the religion's beginnings which explores some of the themes that have been fussed over, and I wonder if I can get a work like that out and still be able to talk to my mum and dad!

The resistance to the play is evidence enough of the play's importance, especially in its extreme, uncompromising form. Even if it's crap. Setting it in a Gurdwara is incredibly disgusting, and it's fair enough for people to complain about that. But the reaction and the closing down of the play completely negates the protests. That I find more disgusting.

Something I wrote which should be more palatable:

http://www.percythechicken.com/corner.php?show=12
 
 
Spatula Clarke
11:37 / 22.12.04
According to R4 news, another theatre in the area is already looking to show it.

They've dropped the idea now, at the author's request. "Because of threats to her safety," say the BBC's local news.
 
  
Add Your Reply