BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


CSI

 
 
Foust is SO authentic
16:56 / 05.10.04
I was a huge CSI fan in season one, then school commitments kept me from it for the next two years, and I forgot about it last year. I'm back into season 4, though.

I've been wondering why the show is such a ratings juggernaught, and I think there's a few answers.

The least interesting answers are the most obvious - the cool tech stuff and the gore. We all like the various gadgets and replays of how the victim's body was traumatized.

But there's more important stuff going on. I think what really endears this show to its audience is the family-type interplay between the characters. Catherine Willows is the mother. Brown, Stokes & Sidle are the teenagers, and Greg is the bratty little kid.

But it all revolves around Grissom. Age wise, he is paired with the wife/mother figure, Catherine. He is the gruff, distant authority figure. He can be a hardass; he's the disciplinary figure. He offers sage advice, and the team - especially the younger members - clearly want to impress and please him.

Grissom is an idealized father figure in one important way - he can be pleased, and he can admit when he's wrong.

How many people watch CSI, recognize Grissom as human enough to be their father, yet with many of their father's faults removed?

This is partly why I don't think the spin offs will work as well - I've only watched them sparingly, and they lack the family element. Once the gore and tech wear out, all they'll have left is the other important factor they share with the original.

Dead nekkid women. My my, but this show loves to play with the connection between death and the erotic. How often are women in bikinis or lingerie found with their limbs spread, or in a come-hither pose? Never contorted in pain. They look like they're sleeping after good sex.

I don't think other cop shows have the same reliance on eroticising death, with the posssible exception of Law & Order: SVU. LO:SVU is different, though; CSI's necrophilia is subtle, not played for shock; it's not overtly violent - just sexy.

Hell, Sara Sidle & Grissom even have an Electra complex going on!
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
01:25 / 08.10.04
I think the series work because they are,m at their heart, simple mysteries that are quickly solved in most cases. No soap opera elements, no deep character studies, just an hour where you put the puzzle peices together, the characters catch the bad guy, and they go home.

There's a "comfort TV" element to it that I see...scientists bringing order out of chaos.
 
 
Mystery Gypt
04:14 / 09.10.04
interestingly, there seems to be a mystery over this shows success going all the way up to people in the industry itself... this past week's variety had an article saying, essentially, "we really don't know why people like this show... except i suppose because its a well written thriller with a good cast... and so those spinoffs i guess will do the same..." or something to that vague an effect. google for it at variety.com
 
  
Add Your Reply