BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Your Essential Directors

 
 
PatrickMM
15:10 / 22.08.04
I feel like in comics, if you ask people their favorite writers, you always get the same answer (Morrison, Moore, Ellis, Ennis), but there seems to be a larger cannon of beloved directors in film. So, the question is, who are the directors whose name alone makes you instantly want to see a film, regardless of the plot, and what's your favorite film from this director?

For me, the list goes like this...

David Lynch - Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me
Tim Burton - Batman Returns
Quentin Tarantino - Kill Bill (I)
Terry Gilliam - Brazil
Darren Aronofsky - Pi
Richard Linlater - Waking Life
PT Anderson - Magnolia
Michael Mann - The Insider
Sofia Coppola - Lost in Translation
Spike Jonze - Being John Malkovich

And just for fairness, I'll throw in a must see writer. Any movie that Charlie Kaufman writes, I'll see, and his best so far is Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.
 
 
TeN
19:00 / 22.08.04
Goddamnit! That's my exact list!

I guess you were wrong about the broader spectrum of film, haha.

I have different favorite films though. I'll just list them for the hell of it:

David Lynch - Eraserhead
Tim Burton - Big Fish
Quentin Tarantino - Pulp Fiction
Terry Gilliam - Brazil
Darren Aronofsky - Pi
Richard Linlater - Waking Life
PT Anderson - Magnolia
Michael Mann - Collateral
Sofia Coppola - Lost in Translation
Spike Jonze - Adaptation
 
 
TeN
19:04 / 22.08.04
Oh, and how could I forget these two:

Hideako Anno - Neon Genesis Evangelion
Don Hertzfeldt - Rejected

I know, I know - tv series and short film, but still, they're amazing.
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
19:23 / 22.08.04
I feel like in comics, if you ask people their favorite writers, you always get the same answer (Morrison, Moore, Ellis, Ennis),

Have you considered making more diverse friends?

Now, this is what we in the biz call a list thread. It doesn't actually tell us anything very interesting about any of the directors being mentioned. In fact, it is just a list of favourite films. Might I suggest that instead people select one or more directors and explain what it is about their work that makes them a favourite of theirs?
 
 
Benny the Ball
20:27 / 22.08.04
I'm struggling to come up with one, let alone a list!

The closest would, I guess, be John Carpenter, but even he has gone off the boil.

But before the boil was offed. Well, I loved horror as a kid, and I found that his were the only horror films that thought about what was happening beyond the horror. Most franchises worked on a formula, Nightmare... films had to have x amount of freddie quips, Friday... films were all about the teen sex out of marriage murder thing. But John made films about some man who had enough of life and seemed down and wasted, and then something truely horrific came along and that man had to fight his way through it, even though he was fighting to preserve an end that he wasn't exactly too pleased with.
 
 
PatrickMM
21:12 / 22.08.04
Have you considered making more diverse friends?

I'm not saying that people just read them, but those writers almost always come up when you ask people their favorites, in a way that you don't hear in music or movies. I don't care how diverse your friends are, if they read comics, odds are Alan Moore is one of their favorite writers.

Now, this is what we in the biz call a list thread. It doesn't actually tell us anything very interesting about any of the directors being mentioned. In fact, it is just a list of favourite films. Might I suggest that instead people select one or more directors and explain what it is about their work that makes them a favourite of theirs?

This is true, I was just trying to get a little survey of people's favorite directors, but I'd be glad to expand on my choices.

David Lynch - Lynch's movies are completely unique, and seem to exist in a timeless dimension that's at once dated and completely modern. Eraserhead is the most alien movie I've ever seen, and seems to be set in a completely different world. Twin Peaks is the best TV show of all time, and the red room sequences are my favorite things ever filmed. The finale is a great example of telling a story solely with visual symbols, and the film is the best example of blending really abstract content with a strong emotional core. Mulholland Drive is the culmination of everything he's done to date, a really great movie. Lynch also has strong thematic threads connecting his films, making them work well as an entire body of work.

Tim Burton - His work is visually dazzling, and his body of work collectively is a great explanation of the outsider and society. I love the way Edward Scissorhands, Batman Returns, The Nightmare Before Christmas and Ed Wood are all basically about the same thing, the outsider coming to terms with his place in society. They all have different takes on this theme, and taken collectively, they become greater than the sum of their parts.

Quentin Tarantino - His movies have a very pop sensibility, and he's one of the best directors at using "gimmicky" structures and editing techniques in a way that supports the story. He takes a lot of risks, and almost all of them pay off. His movies are always very cool, largely because of great musical choices. And in Kill Bill II and Jackie Brown, he shows that he can handle real emotional content as well as any director out there.

Terry Gilliam - Gilliam is one of the best visual storytellers out there, and his explorations of fantasy vs. reality are always interesting. While I like all his stuff, nothing is as brilliant as Brazil, which is on par with 1984 in creating a dystopian world, one that twenty years later is still painfully relevant.

Darren Aronofsky - He's the only director to take music video style cutting and use it not just to be cool, but to service the story. The soundtracks for both his movies are amazing, and, particularly in Requiem, the bold editing choices make what could have been a simple melodrama into something epic. The closing sequence of Requiem left me practically catatonic.

Richard Linlater - He's the best director at making stories about people talking, that are absolutely riveting. I love the philosophical explorations of Waking Life, the rambling narrative of Dazed and Confused. Before Sunrise and Before Sunset fit together perfectly, have perfectly drawn characters. The fact that he could make 80 minutes of talking one of the most riveting movies I've ever seen demonstrates his skill.

PT Anderson - Watching Magnolia forced me to completely reevaluate film. The way he combined all those stories, with characters interacting with each other, and thematic parallels developing. After the three hours, I was just wishing it wouldn't end. Boogie Nights is similar in its scope, and also features brilliant editing and camerawork. Plus, his use of music is rivaled only by Tarantino. The Magnolia "One" sequence, at the beginning of the movie, is, IMO, the most well constructed sequence in any movie.

Michael Mann - The Insider was like The X-Files, only real, and Heat was the definitve crime movie. I feel like nothing in the genre could top it in terms of scope. He is a genius at taking huge epic stories, and finding the human story within it. Plus, he can stage an amazing action sequence, as in the club shootout in Collateral.

Sofia Coppola - Lost in Translation really got to me emotionally. She's great at combining emotional stories with amazing visuals. The cityscape of Tokyo, or the dreamlike photography of The Virgin Suicides amplify the emotion of the characters. Plus, she's another director who knows how to use music. The Air soundtrack to Virgin Suicides was amazing, as was LiT's music.

Spike Jonze - He takes really bizarre stories, and grounds them in reality. Being John Malkovich feels grimy and real, despite the absurd subject matter. The Malkovich in Malkovich sequence was a real highlight.
 
 
The Photographer in Blowup
18:01 / 29.08.04
I can't believe all the love for Mann's The Insider: I was thinking I was the only one! Mann combined the perfect editing, cinematography, screenplay and score for this modern masterpiece. The movie should be dull, but instead it's fast-paced and gripping. I'd love seeing Mann writing more of his movies: what he did with Crowe and Pacino's characters was beautiful! The variety of feelings Crowe had to convey, the facial expressions, the body language, the silent moments, it was my favourite performance of 1999.

And I'm always a sucker for an uplifting, feel-good movie; Jeffrey Wigand is like Atticus Finch updated for the cynical new millenium... swears, drinks like a sponge, is angry, lacks social skills, but he's still that loving father doing what's right for his daughters. When the un-cut interview is finally aired, to the sound of the beautiful 'Sacrifice,' there's a quick scene in which Jefrey's daughter turns away from the tv to look at him, and perhaps just glance justifies all the adversities jeffrey went through to get the truth out; he's doing it for his daughters, to make them proud of him one day.

This is what Mann is great at, capturing these little moments of intimacy.
 
  
Add Your Reply